Immigration

Community Groups Challenge Trump Administration's Attempt To Exclude Non-Citizens From Housing Benefits

A new lawsuit contends that a new rule that excludes mixed immigration status families from federal housing benefits is illegal.

|

Several Los Angeles County community groups and public housing residents are suing to block a new rule from the Trump administration's Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) that would require all public housing residents to verify that they are either citizens or immigrants who are eligible for federal housing assistance. 

The plaintiffs, which include three pseudonymous individuals, as well as the People Organized for Westside Renewal (POWER) and Union de Vecinos, argue that the new HUD rule will result in thousands of "mixed-status" families, whose households might include an illegal immigrant, losing benefits to which they were otherwise entitled. 

"No family should have to choose between staying together and keeping a roof over their heads. Yet HUD's rule would force precisely that choice on families across the country," said Amanda Mangaser Savage, strategic litigation counsel at Public Counsel, a public interest law firm representing the plaintiffs. 

Since 1980, federal law has generally prohibited anyone who wasn't a citizen or qualifying legal immigrant from receiving federal housing assistance. 

Congress over the years added several "family preservation" provisions into the law to allow "mixed-status" families to stay in subsidized units while also receiving smaller overall subsidies. 

One such provision allowed mixed-status households to live in federally subsidized housing provided that the ineligibility of any household member had not been affirmatively established. 

Benefits to these households would be prorated so that only eligible citizens or legal immigrants would receive financial assistance. 

This led the federal government to create an effective "don't ask, don't tell" rule for families applying for federal housing benefits. When asked about their immigration status, individual family members could opt to "not contend" they had an immigration status that would allow them to receive benefits. 

The financial aid provided to the family was reduced for every member who took this "do not contend" option. But because no member's ineligibility for benefits had been affirmatively established, the whole family could still receive a voucher or live in a subsidized unit. 

The Trump administration's new rule ends this de facto "don't ask, don't tell" system. Instead, it will require every member of a household receiving federal assistance to verify that they're a citizen or an eligible legal immigrant. 

Since the confirmation of one non-eligible family member is enough to deprive a whole family of federal housing benefits, this new rule will effectively require mixed-status families to forfeit their benefits or expel the ineligible member from the household. 

Since many mixed-status households are composed of citizen children and illegal immigrant parents, the family as a whole will have to forfeit their benefits and move. 

There are an estimated 80,000 people in mixed-status families currently who would lose their assistance under the rule, according to the Center for Budget and Priorities. 

The administration argues the new rule preserves scarce housing benefits for the American citizens they were intended for. 

"It's unacceptable that America's homeless veterans, disabled, elderly, and victims of domestic violence languish on waitlists while illegals and ineligibles scam our system," said HUD Secretary Scott Turner last week, when the new final rule was published. 

Critics of the Trump administration rule make two primary cases against requiring all housing benefit recipients to verify their citizenship or immigration status. 

The first is that it will cause mixed-status families to either break up or forfeit their benefits. That will be disruptive to the families themselves and runs contrary to Congress' intent when it added various "family preservation" amendments to the general ban on illegal immigrants receiving housing aid. 

The second is that the Trump administration's change will mean fewer families overall will receive assistance under current funding levels. Since mixed-status families receive prorated benefits, they are cheaper to subsidize. Replacing them with families that qualify for full benefits will result in larger subsidies going to fewer people. 

The Los Angeles plaintiffs' lawsuit primarily argues that the Trump administration's rule is illegal because it fully excludes mixed-status families from benefits Congress clearly intended them to have. 

The lawsuit was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California.