Guan Heng Exposed China's Uyghur Camps. ICE Wants To Deport Him.
U.S. immigration authorities should not do the bidding of the Chinese Communist Party.
Guan Heng is a former resident of China who did something amazing: He defied the country's authoritarian government and documented the abuses of Uyghur Muslims.
The 37-year-old citizen-journalist entered Xinjiang after downloading the satellite coordinates of alleged Uyghur detention facilities. He took pictures of the camps—camps that the Chinese Communist Party has claimed do not exist. He shared these images with BuzzFeed News, which then published an eye-opening series of articles about the internment of ethnic and religious minorities in China.
It was incredibly brave of Guan Heng to do this. Documenting the atrocities of tyrants is important work—and extremely dangerous. Heng knew that if the Chinese authorities got a chance, they would arrest him, question him, and possibly torture and even kill him. And so he fled China in 2021, traveling to Ecuador and eventually by boat to the U.S. He applied for asylum and obtained a work permit. He has been living quietly in New York ever since, working as an Uber driver and food deliverer.
A few months ago, in August, ICE detained him after he admitted he had initially entered the country illegally. Immigration authorities would now like to deport him, either to Uganda—where he would likely be taken back to China—or to China directly.
That would be a travesty. The feds should certainly not deport Guan Heng, no matter how he came to this country. On the contrary, he should be commended and welcomed. As The Wall Street Journal says:"It's hard to imagine a stronger case for asylum." There is no good reason for ICE to work as a communist government's enforcer.
It's true that many Americans want the federal government to vet asylum claims with greater care. But Guan Heng should easily pass any such test. If anything, the government should incentivize anti-communist whistleblowers and citizen-journalists to cooperate with the U.S. We want Chinese scientists, for instance, who have information about the possible lab origins of COVID-19 to document and disseminate any such evidence, and to seek refuge as far from Beijing's reach as possible.
Democrats on the U.S. House of Representative's Foreign Affairs committee appear to be taking up Guan Heng's case. That's good, but there is absolutely no reason for this to become a partisan issue. Any Republicans who care about China's authoritarian ways should concede that this is obviously a case where other considerations should overrule the Trump administration's deportation agenda.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please to post comments
Where, oh where, is Scumby the Scummy Chimp-Chump to call Guan Heng a "rapefugee" here for us, to enlighten us? I will bet some OTHER shitheads and assholes here will pick up the slack for Scumby the Scummy Chimp-Chump...
Well that was helpful.
He broke the law.
"If you can't do the time, don't do the crime".
Has NO ONE EVER broken the law, to help humanity? Have ye ever PervFectly heard of the "White Rose Society" in NAZI Germany? How about Jesus, Mahatma Gandhi, and MLK Jr.? Is the written law SACRED, to be WORSHITTED? Do YOU want to punish Guan Heng? If so, why? Do You PervFectly think and stink that the Chinese Government Almighty SHOULD be shitting on their own people? If so, why? So that Dear Orange Caligula can takes notes from the Chinese, to see how shit is done, to be applied HERE, pervhaps?
Oh, wait, maybe You Pervfectly think and stink that Guan Heng should have tried to hide in China for 20 some years, while he waits for Dear Orange Caligula and His Goons to give spermission to cum over here... Yeah, I get shit!
The north Koran refugees are tightly vetted in Korea, even if they’re visibly half skeleton due to starvation.
If any of them crossed illegally, the ROK would not just ignore them and give them work permit willy nilly, even if they exposed wrongdoing to a magazine. Truth be told, the Korean police would have at least questioned him the next day the article was published.
I have so much problem with Korea and Asia in general, but one thing I give them credit for is not sharing in the west suicidal empathy. The Chinese are commies who embed spies in the democrat party. If due diligence was done give the guy asylum. Otherwise he should be deported to an ally nation that can trusted to protect him.
Let the better people do the shit that we are too cowardly to do, yes!!! Then follow the Cummands of the Cummander in Chief, AKA Pussy-Grabber in Chief, and shit all over the favorite scapegoat of the day, which is the illegal sub-humans!
And there it is, the patented sqrlsy nonsensical rambling.
Disagree. Asylum has certainly been abused, but this seems like the right situation to allow a person to stay. I want as many people as possible exposing the communist pieces of shit. Sending him back would discourage that.
Amen! Kudos! Well stated!
He went through many other countries that would have offered asylum. Asylum isnt a shopping trip.
The US is one of the few countries on earth where China can't just act unrestrictedly. China has police stations in Canada and 30 other countries, FFS.
Parliamentary Committee Notes: Foreign Police Stations in Canada
In September 2022, the non-governmental organization Safeguard Defenders released a report entitled “110 Overseas – Chinese Transnational Policing Gone Wild” which alleged that the People’s Republic of China (PRC) established 54 overseas police stations (OPS) in 30 different countries, including in Canada. A follow-on report entitled “Patrol and Persuade” published in December 2022 claimed that 102 OPS were present in 53 countries.
Furthermore, in September and October 2022, several media outlets, reported on the actions of the Chinese Fuzhou Public Security Bureau’s (PSB) offices, which are located across five continents, including three in the Greater Toronto Area. These offices purport to assist Chinese nationals in Canada on a variety of fronts, from renewing driver’s licenses, to reporting incidents to local police. Media reports claim that these offices are being used as “clandestine hubs” for the Chinese state to target and compel alleged criminals to return to China to face justice.
On October 27, 2022, the RCMP issued a media statement informing the public that it is investigating reports of criminal activity in relation to the so-called "police stations” alleged to be operating on behalf of the PRC in the Greater Toronto Area. As the RCMP is actively investigating this, it cannot comment further. Furthermore, on March 9, 2023, media outlets reported that the RCMP confirmed that two Montreal organizations, the Service à la Famille Chinoise du Grand Montréal, in Montreal's Chinatown, and the Centre Sino-Québec de la Rive-Sud, in Brossard, on the South Shore of Montreal, are being investigated as alleged Chinese police stations.
They have a station in NYC.
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c785n9pexjpo
And elsewhere.
https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2023/apr/19/china-places-police-stations-us-rights-group-claim/
Claimed list:
In the U.S., China has opened police stations in Los Angeles, San Francisco, Houston and in undisclosed cities in Nebraska, Minnesota and New York, according to the Spain-based human rights group Safeguard Defenders.
https://www.newsnationnow.com/world/china/china-secret-police-station-around-world/
Hell. They even owned Gov Hochul and other democrats.
How about we split the differences, blow up the 3 gorges damn during the flood season, and carpet bomb where internment/slave camps don't exist.
He broke Chinese law, which we in the US should have no business enforcing.
What if he was a murderer?
He broke immigration laws whose fix is deportation.
Ronald Reagan... Along with MANY MANY past presidents (and their administrations), of both parties, would NEVER even have considered forcibly deporting such a person!!! Shame, shame, SHAME on the DickTator-Boots-Lickers like JesseBahnFarter-Fuhrer here, and ALL other Orange Caligula suck-butts!!!
Orange Caligula has RUINED the GOP, and now is long-time into the path of ruining the USA!
Arriving without authorization and then claiming asylum is legal.
Asylum im the interior is not how the laws were set up dumdum.
We want Chinese scientists, for instance, who have information about the possible lab origins of COVID-19
Robby really wanted to come out as a conservative, but who gave you permission to talk like that?
Is Koch dead?
The lab leak theory has not only been completely debunked, it was not even possible. Highly contiguous viruses do not magically transport themselves nine miles without infecting people. Also samples collected from the wet market are completely consistent with animal to human transmission.
Walz +9
I'm starting to think that Molly is parody, at this point.
He's a time traveler from 2019.
This is a case for asylum on an individual basis, not an argument against deportation.
Did he actually GET asylum after applying for it? Why did the court find him deportable? ICE doesn’t just nab random person off the street and ask for citizenship, no matter how much ms now want that to be true.
If his background checks out, then give him asylum. But we live the tune of the wolf and vigilance is required.
"ICE doesn’t just nab random person off the street and ask for citizenship."
It nabs random people who are brown and 'fit the profile' (for example in the wrong place like at a construction job). It's allowed to do that according to the SC.
Sure thing, um, sparky.
You mean the sites they had warrants for due to information they employed illegals?
Look, the narrative doesn't work if you go for full information and disclosure so you have to be selective about the facts you allow out.
>>traveling to Ecuador
Why did he not stay there?
>We want Chinese scientists, for instance, who have information about the possible lab origins of COVID-19 to document and disseminate any such evidence, and to seek refuge as far from Beijing's reach as possible.
Why? Its clear that we already have that evidence. Its clear *the United States Government* was complicit - at minimum by funding the research there.
And nothing else happened.
So why are we going to waste our time?
>Guan Heng Exposed China's Uyghur Camps. ICE Wants To Deport Him.
I thought China was good? China doesn't do genocide - I was told only Israel does genocide. Israel bad. Evil even. Rape is resistance - Palestine good.
Also, I am told that we should be willing to go fight Russia in Ukraine. Because Russia bad.
But China good. China does all our manufacturing and anything we do to change that threatens Wolfe's and ENB's quality of life. Globalization good.
Its all about 'net benefit' Soave, and if you're not benefitting then you're just a poor loser who deserves to die.
So being a traitor snitch is cool now?
Why didn't he stay in ecuador?
Would you?
See, this is one of those rare-as-hens-teeth cases where a refugee claim is probably the right thing to apply for, because China will kill this man.
Wait...
So not only his his asylum claim not yet denied, he would simply be deported to not china?
https://www.vpm.org/npr-news/npr-news/2025-12-17/a-chinese-man-who-filmed-secret-footage-in-xinjiang-risks-deportation-from-the-u-s
Guan believed the film would lead to his arrest in China, so he hoped to reach the U.S. and ask for asylum.
For fearing his life he certainly limited his options. Let Europe take him. Let Canada take him.
The Department of Homeland Security said Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents had "encountered" Guan while carrying out a criminal search warrant, in a statement sent to NPR.
Lol. Even done with a legal warrant.
Carney works for China... No, literally.
Also China paid millions to Trudeau during his campaigns and then the Liberals shut down the inquiry into it.
Then send him to Europe.
List of countries not overly dependent on china.
https://ourworldindata.org/data-insights/in-most-countries-imports-from-china-account-for-less-than-10-of-gdp-even-where-china-is-the-top-partner
I find it odd that robby who has asked trump to ask congress to do anything now wants trump to make a special case exception here.
The law stops being a law once excuses or exceptions are made. He went through many asylum eligible countries.
FINE. Let's deport this guy instead:
https://notthebee.com/article/watch-these-woke-ignoramuses-confront-federal-agents-because-they-thought-they-were-ice