Brickbat: Shocking Mistake

A police officer in Waterbury, Connecticut, was arrested and charged with manslaughter and other offenses after body camera footage showed him mistakenly shooting a suspect with his gun instead of a Taser during a domestic violence call in October 2024, an incident the Waterbury Police Department called a tragic mistake. The officer, identified only as a 10-year veteran, fired a single shot that killed the suspect, who was allegedly holding a knife and advancing toward officers. The state's attorney confirmed the officer's intent was to deploy a Taser, but the mistaken use of a firearm led to the suspect's death, prompting a criminal investigation.

Comments

[Fist of Etiquette]

The officer, identified only as a 10-year veteran...

Arrested and charged but not named. Interesting.

If the victim was in fact advanced toward the cops with a knife, that situation might call for a gun instead of a taser.

[Rick James]

Yeah, that's what I came here to say. The number of police videos I've seen where a suspect was 'advancing towards the cops with a knife' whom was ultimately literally (not figuratively, but literally) filled with bullets is too many to count. In fact, it puts me in mind of a local cop about 15 years ago who was murdered on the side of the road here because a naked, unarmed man 'advanced towards the officer' and the officer made the unfortunate choice of deploying his taser which... had no effect on the naked, unarmed man who ultimately killed the officer.

If I were on the jury, unless there were some extremely extenuating circs, I'd probably vote to acquit.

[bacchys]

Depends on how far away he was.

But if Officer Bang Bang thought a taser was feasible, probably not very far. Which makes me suspect the suspect was not, in fact, advancing on anyone.

[diver64]

I'm a little confused. If a guy is charging at officers with a knife then he intends to inflict harm and the officer has every right to shoot him to stop the attack. Is the officer obligated to wait until the man stabs him before reacting?
Pro Tip: If you want to avoid being shot by a police officer do not head at them with a weapon in your hand.

[MatthewSlyfield]

"If a guy is charging at officers with a knife then he intends to inflict harm and the officer has every right to shoot him to stop the attack."

I think that police need to be held accountable for not only excessive force, but mistaken uses of force.

That said, taking the claim that the suspect was advancing (the article does not say charging) on the officers with a knife at face value, this would seem to be a justified shooting.

[mad.casual]

Pro Tip: If you want to avoid being shot by a police officer do not head at them with a weapon in your hand.

Call me an "EVIL KKKRISCHUN NASHUNALIST MISOGYNIST!" or whatever, while we're wishing in one hand and shitting in the other, might as well wish that people find a better way to handle domestic disturbances than picking up a knife in the first place. A husband or wife getting convicted of manslaughter for shooting someone approaching him/her with a knife isn't really any better.

But then I'm one of those insane "conservative" idiots that, when the cops show up to a call about a knife-wielding, 90 yr. old mental patient, blame the people who are directly, privately contracted to care for the person for failing to prevent the issue rather than faulting the public servants who cannot choose not to or fail to respond to such buck-passing incompetence.

[bacchys]

In other words, you're not a conservative. You're a fascist bootlicker.

[jimc5499]

Remember this is Reason. The cop is automatically in the wrong.

[MatthewSlyfield]

It's not Reason saying the cop was wrong here. The officer has been charged with a criminal offense.

[Rick James]

Right, maybe Reason is posting this because the officer was overcharged by a zealous prosecutor, using lawfare to attack an innocent man.

Over/under on that theory?

[mad.casual]

Over/under on that theory?

Presumably in... [scroll] Waterbury... we aren't talking about a Michael Jackson impersonator or a transgender sex "worker" with less than $100 to their name but, without even a definitive declaration to that effect, how are we to know?

[Stupid Government Tricks]

That summary doesn't match up with the link.

Devlin said the incident happened after Nunez fled from Thomas, who was trying to stop him after noticing that the license plates on the man’s Jeep Liberty parked at a Sunoco gas station on Windsor Avenue were registered to another vehicle.

Devlin said Thomas warned that, if Nunez did not stop, he would tase him.

“When Nunez continued to flee, Officer Thomas unholstered his actual firearm and fired one round at Nunez,” he said. “Nunez was not hit and subsequently was taken into custody.”

Devlin said he has determined the use of force was not justified.

“Nunez posed no threat of harm to Officer Thomas,” he said. “He was being pursued for misuse of a marker plate (an infraction) and interfering with an officer (a misdemeanor). There was no reasonable basis to use deadly force.”

With that, Devlin said his office has obtained a warrant to arrest Thomas and charge him with second-degree reckless endangerment and unlawful discharge of a firearm.

In the body camera footage from the incident, Thomas appears to be checking out the Jeep when Nunez and his friend come out of the gas station. He tries to stop him, but Nunez takes off running.

“Stop running or I’m going to (expletive) tase you,” Thomas says, while pulling out his handgun.

Thomas fires his pistol once, then says “Oh (expletive), I did not mean to do that.” He then pulls out his Taser and fires it before the video ends.

Devlin the pursuit ended when both Nunez and Thomas fell into a frozen brook. He said Nunez was then taken into custody.

[Stupid Government Tricks]

It's not even the same date.

State Inspector General Robert Devlin said in a report released Tuesday that Windsor Police Officer Brandon Thomas fired one round from his department-issued firearm at Geovanni Nunez on the night of Jan. 30.

[Phanatic]

Or the same town. Windsor != Waterbury.

[Stupid Government Tricks]

Damn. It probably could have said officer W Bush and I wouldn't have noticed.

[Jerry B.]

Perhaps this article was written by ChatGPT.

[Rick James]

Jesus, that makes it make sense. Thanks for clicking through and doing commenter research.

[RC]

Note to the author:
Double-check your link. This Brickbat is itself a shocking mistake.
The linked article and included body camera video clearly show that the cop shot at a fleeing suspect, then realized his mistake and switched to his taser, then denied having shot at the guy. It wasn't a domestic violence call, he was checking on a vehicle because it had the wrong plates, and the guy ran. The incident happened in January, the officer is named in the article, and a state IG investigation ruled that he wasn't justified in using his firearm.