A Year of War in the Middle East Cost Americans Nearly $23 Billion
U.S. taxpayers are underwriting wars in Gaza, Lebanon, Yemen, Syria, and Iraq.

War is not cheap, especially not the past year of Middle Eastern wars. While Israelis, Palestinians, Lebanese, and others pay with their lives by the tens of thousands, Americans are paying much of the financial cost of keeping the violence going.
A new study by the Costs of War Project at Brown University pinned down exactly what that cost is: at least $22.76 billion from October 7, 2023, to September 30, 2024. The bulk of the money, $17.9 billion, was spent on U.S. aid to the Israeli military—both financial grants given to Israel to purchase weapons, and the cost of replacing munitions such as artillery shells sent directly from American stockpiles to the Israeli army.
"The United States can walk and chew gum at the same time," Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin told reporters on October 13, 2023. "U.S. security assistance to Israel will flow in at the speed of war."
But the U.S. military itself has also burned through expensive ammunition dealing with the spillover of the war into Yemen, Syria, and Iraq.
The study only counts the direct burden on the U.S. military budget. It doesn't include indirect costs, "such as increased U.S. security assistance to Egypt, Saudi Arabia or any other countries, and costs to the commercial airline industry and to U.S. consumers." Nor does it count the $1 billion in U.S. humanitarian aid to Palestinians.
And the study's time frame doesn't include the ongoing Israeli ground invasion of Lebanon, which prompted even more U.S. military deployments to the region, or Iran's October 1 missile attack on Israeli military bases. During the latter incident, the U.S. Navy says it fired "about a dozen interceptors" at the Iranian missiles. "Assuming they were SM-3 interceptors, that represents the production run for an entire year, at a cost of about $400 million total," Middlebury Institute professor Jeffrey Lewis noted on social media.
It cost Israel and its allies $1.3 billion to shoot down a previous Iranian missile barrage in April 2024, retired Brig. Gen. Reem Aminoach told Bloomberg at the time. Soon after the April clashes, Congress budgeted another $5.2 billion for Israeli missile defense.
Last year, the U.S. military also burned through a year's worth of Tomahawk cruise missiles. Soon after the war in Gaza began, the Houthi movement of Yemen declared its solidarity with the Palestinian cause and began attacking international shipping. The U.S. Navy launched a campaign against the Houthis, firing 80 cruise missiles, more than it had purchased the year before, on the first night.
"Are [the airstrikes] stopping the Houthis? No," President Joe Biden told reporters at the time. "Are they going to continue? Yes."
Along with the missile defense aid, the April aid package included another $2.4 billion for U.S. military operations in the Middle East, including the deployment of two aircraft carriers to protect Israel from Iran. (One of the carriers has since returned home.) However, due to the daily costs of operating the aircraft carriers, "the U.S. is on pace to spend at least double the $2.4 billion already appropriated for regional defense," the study estimates.
The United States has also bombed Iraqi militias to prevent them from launching drones—it's unclear whether the target was Israel or U.S. bases—and clashed with those militias in Syria and Jordan.
Former president Donald Trump, meanwhile, has repeatedly argued that the Biden administration isn't supportive enough of Israel's war effort. "I did more for Israel than anybody," he bragged on Monday, two days after he backed a direct attack on Iran. "Israel will cease to exist in two years" if Vice President Kamala Harris is elected, Trump warned last month.
Israel, of course, is happy to take aid whether it comes from a Republican or Democratic administration. In December 2023, staff at the U.S. State Department's weapons export bureau were surprised to encounter an "unusual" thank you gift, ProPublica reported. The Israeli embassy had sent the officials cases of fancy wine with personalized notes.
The wars have also been a huge taxpayer subsidy to American arms manufacturers, the Brown University study adds. And those manufacturers have certainly noticed. In October 2023, the Guardian and Responsible Statecraft reported on a series of "unusually blunt" earnings calls discussing the impact of the war on shareholders.
"Hamas has created additional demand, we have this $106 billion request from the president," an investment analyst said at a weapons company's October 25 call, referring to the Biden administration's aid proposal for Israel and Ukraine at the time. He asked where the company was seeing the most demand.
"You know, the Israel situation obviously is a terrible one, frankly, and one that's just evolving as we speak," a weapons company executive responded. "But I think if you look at the incremental demand potential coming out of that, the biggest one to highlight and that really sticks out is probably on the artillery side."
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
There’s an agency that doesn’t ever run out of money.
Among others...
THE MAN IN THE ZLUUBEN
The Players:
Klautzen Schtuppen - Evil Globalist who is definitely NOT the leader of the WEF
Kahla-LAH Hamass - An unscrupulous brownish woman who is definitely NOT running for POTUS
Yoo Ching - An elder Manchurian who is the top aide and consultant to Schtuppen.
SCENE: A cavernous chamber in an underground super-bunker, a secret number of miles below Munich. Its walls are dark and embedded with many thousands diamonds and precious stones, though it is otherwise sparsely decorated. On the far wall is a huge fireplace of polished black stonework, adorned with a thousand human skulls. A flame fills the fireplace, casting a red glow about the chamber. Klautzen Schtuppen and Yoo Ching enter stage right (house left). An automatic door slides shut behind them. Schtuppen, in uncomfortable looking brown leather pants, sports a wide-ribbed charcoal-gray leather jacket with exaggerated shoulders, giving him the look one might find on the cover a science fiction paperback from the nineteen-fifties. Yoo Ching wears a plain white tuxedo.
SCHTUPPEN: It's kind of hot down here. Do we need the fireplace?
YOO CHING: Flame give off no heat. It is fakery. Hologram, you see. Problem is, we are so close to earth core it require enough power to run a small city just to keep it cool.
SCHTUPPEN: Why is that?
YOO CHING: Is because you insisted that your ZLUUBEN be located far enough below surface that you could foment nuclear war and survive it in stupendous luxury.
SCHTUPPEN: Did I? Hmmm... Does that include ALL OUT Nuclear war?
YOO CHING: Of course. And Global Famine, Pandemic, Total Economic Collapse, World War Three... Whatever is on the Menu.
SCHTUPPEN: Excellent! And ZLUUBEN? What is that again?
YOO CHING: It stand for Ztupendously Luxurious Underground Uber Bunker. You made acronym up yourself.
SCHTUPPEN: Did I? I zeem to have forgotten... Oh, of course. It is zomething I planned long ago... Yes! Now I remember. I added the extra E-N at the end to make it zound more Germanic.
YOO CHING: Correct.
SCHTUPPEN (looking around): I like the red glow. Nice effect. It reminds me of zomething...
YOO CHING: Zhoe Biden televised address to American public.
SCHTUPPEN: That's it! Thank you, Yoo.
At that moment a chime is heard. They both look toward the door.
YOO CHING: That will be your mistress. She has only just arrived from District of Columbia, United States.
SCHTUPPEN: Ah, yummy! You may leave now, Yoo.
Yoo Ching bows, then turns to exit the chamber. Moments later Kahla-LAH Hamass enters, wearing a light trench coat. Once fully inside the chamber she drops the trench coat to the floor, revealing a crimson negligee. She takes another step forward and does a turn, showing off her curves.
SCHTUPPEN: Kah-la-la-la-LAH! You look ravishing!
Schtuppen produces a cell phone and taps it a few times. A huge black oaken bed floats down from above and settles in the middle of the chamber. The door to the chamber slides shut and a heavy bolt is heard slamming into place. Kahla-LAH walks up to Schtuppen and they embrace.
SCHTUPPEN: I have a zurprise for you, my dear.
He walks to a side table and opens a twenty-four inch square envelope and removes a large black, translucent ring. He then positions it over his head and it floats there, suspended like the rings of Saturn, girding his gleaming, bald head about an inch above his pointy ears. It maintains its position automatically as he moves about, and has lit up to display a dramatic rendering of the zodiac.
KAHLA-LAH: Oh Joy, Klautzen! That is so... you!
SCHTUPPEN (beaming): Does it make me look extra diabolical?
KAHLA-LAH: Oh my darling! Uber, UBER diabolical! How does it stay in place?
SCHTUPPEN: I had magnetic studs embedded in my skull so it hovers in place. Nice effect, eh?
KAHLA-LAH: Very. But won't it get in the way when we make love?
SCHTUPPEN: Not at all. I can position it at any angle with a special app on my phone. It can be tilted up so we can kiss, if that is your conzern.
A small, round table rises from beneath the floor, upon which a bottle of red wine and two glasses are set. Schtuppen pours two glasses and hands one to Kahla-LAH. They move to the edge of the bed to make a toast.
SCHTUPPEN: To Evil.
They clink their glasses and sip.
SCHTUPPEN: So Kahla-LAH, how was your descent?
KAHLA-LAH: Quite pleasant, actually. I was so exhausted from the flight over that I slept for nearly three hours. I spent the rest of the six-and-a-half-hour descent between the spa and the video game room. You amaze me, Klautzen. Only you could have thought of an elevator with bedrooms and a spa and...
SCHTUPPEN: Wait till you see what we have planned for the new shaft we'll be opening up under Den Haag. That one will have all the amenities of the one here plus a swimming pool.
KAHLA-LAH: It must cost a fortune. It seems it would take all the money in the world to build such colossal things. Not to mention the energy.
SCHTUPPEN: Well my dear, you must consider all our sources. The UN, the Federal Reserve, the compounded interest on the US national debt, the graft from all the subsidized green energy, trillions in new taxes from our climate crisis fear mongering, leftover monies printed for the pandemic, kickbacks from all the dictators we have installed worldwide. Wall Street, London... do you have any idea how much capital is run through London? Switzerland? Offshore banks? We get an increasingly large piece of it all. Now consider the huge, unaccounted-for military and intelligence budgets. And thanks to the pandemic we were able to destroy thousands of small businesses and prop up our partners in warehousing and shipping with billions and billions in added revenues. In short, we DO own "all the money in the world."
KAHLA-LAH: It's... it's just so...
SCHTUPPEN: Evil?
KAHLA-LAH: Yes, but...
SCHTUPPEN: Meanwhile the world is being systematically destroyed. All according to plan. Chaotic migration, crime, terror, war, climate hysteria, pandemic fears, you name it. We will soon manipulate the weather... It's all in the playbook.
KAHLA-LAH: So it really IS a conspiracy...
SCHTUPPEN: Well, yes and no. Some conspiracies are necessary, of course. But the majority of our agreements are pure conniving. You see, conspiracies are messy and involve very careful vetting. You must trust your co-conspirators one hundred percent and take immense precautions so that you never get caught. Think of all the known conspiracies of the past where large numbers of the conspirators and hapless witnesses had to be eliminated. That's a lot of wet work. But when you are practiced in the art of conniving those stresses are eliminated. It's actually more evil, to be sure. But highly effective.
KAHLA-LAH: How so?
SCHTUPPEN: Well, when you conspire you join with others for specific, selfish goals. You hatch your plot, and your success depends upon how well you execute, and of course you are screwed if you get caught. But when you connive there is no residue. Conniving is... well, it's just more vile. There's a level of vileness to it that conspiracy cannot even approach. One: In a conspiracy you may be indifferent to your enemies; but when you are conniving, you truly despise them. Two: You rely on the same entrenched depravity and corruption shared among your co-connivers. You make no explicit deals with them because you already know "the deal", so to speak. Thus you deny your enemies an even playing field, and though they can clearly point out what you're up to, they have no proof of conspiracy. Three: Then you laugh in their faces, and all your co-connivers - the media, your propagandists, celebrities, shameless politicians, judges, lawyers - all of them can pile on with no fear of repercussions. You've seen this play out thousands of times I'm sure. And finally, Number Four: Fools smell blood in the water and join the feeding frenzy, elated with the ease with which they can join the winning side and torment the opposition. Conniving on this scale is the height of the black art, and we have mastered it.
KAHLA-LAH (giggles): Can we actually drink blood sometime?
SCHTUPPEN: Um, perhaps... But listen! Our tentacles are everywhere. We have even managed to corrupt the Libertarians via some high-placed moles in their organization. It dawned upon Yoo Ching one day that the Libertarians had the potential to attract millions of people with their simple, appealing message. He said that the message was powerful enough and their numbers zignificant enough that if they overcame some minor divisions within their ranks that appeal could snowball, and no candidate for high office would have a chance without their blessing. We could not abide that, so we set about exacerbating those differences, ultimately sowing confusion among them. It was quite simple when you look at it. We infiltrated their upper ranks and got them bickering amongst themselves over minutia. Distinctions between immigration, illegal immigration, migration and so on. They could have shrugged it all off and threw their support to a sensible policy but instead they were cowed into open borders, even going so far as to turn a blind eye to welfare for illegals at the expense of the taxpayer! Then we corralled them into some nonsensical positions in which many of them were actually SUPPORTING our censorship efforts. So, in essence, their libertarian center was kaput. We denied them the ability to define their own essence. Their membership suffered, and we zwooped in. And on top of it they never realized how abzurd it was for them to be running candidates for POTUS, which only diluted opportunities to align with any libertarian seeds within the major parties. We saw to their impotence. They never realized the strength they could have had. They wavered, and we are the victors!
KAHLA-LAH: The authors of confusion! And now we are poised, dare I say, to rule the world!
SCHTUPPEN: Yes! For a thousand years. And yet that is nothing compared to what might soon come to pass. Yoo Ching has explained to me wonders I could never have imagined. We will one day open a shaft right underneath CERN in Switzerland.
KAHLA-LAH: You mean the Super Duper Collider?
SCHTUPPEN: It's just Zuper Collider, I think. Anyway, when we have full control of CERN, Yoo Ching informs me that we can harness the energy to destroy the whole universe.
HAHLA-LAH (giggles): Wow, I never imagined... but what happens then?
SCHTUPPEN: Quite simply, we transition to an ALTERNATE universe. One where, say, I can be the ruler of the galaxy.
KAHLA-LAH: And I, perhaps the first Evil Woman President of the United States?
SCHTUPPEN (hesitates): Well, it pains me to disappoint you but, that is not possible. You see, according to Yoo Ching there already has been an alternate universe in which the first Evil Woman POTUS was elected.
KAHLA-LAH (frowns): That's just not fair.
SCHTUPPEN: Just be thankful you weren't born there. Yes, she was beyond evil; her wickedness was exponential... But it was not to last. It seems she gave a huge celebration after she took the election. It entailed the biggest fireworks display ever in Nova York City. And when it was all over, and all the sparks of the grand finale had zettled to the river, and all the peons and useful idiots were shouting and applauding and blowing their horns, then all of a sudden a zuper bright streak of blinding light went clear across the sky and well, the whole earth was blown to zmithereens. KA-BOOM! Gone in an instant.
KAHLA-LAH (her eyes widen and she starts giggling): Oh, that's SO unfair! How...
SCHTUPPEN: Yoo Ching has explained. Most likely a very large asteroid slammed into the earth at that moment. Yoo has posited that there are rare, unstable universes in which the inhabitants can create a situation that is so obscene and unthinkable that the planet itself simply has an obligation to zelf-destruct.
KAHLA-LAH (sighs): Yoo Ching is very smart.
SCHTUPPEN: Yes, he is. It is good to have him around.
Momentarily the intercom comes alive, filling the chamber with the sound of crickets chirping. Kahla-LAH looks about the chamber for the source of the sound.
SCHTUPPEN: Ah! Dinner is zerved!
KAHLA-LAH (visibly recoils): Hey, wait a minute lover boy...
SCHTUPPEN (laughing heartily): Don't worry my dear. I set that up just to see your reaction. I'm sorry - I just couldn't resist playing a little joke on you. Of course your meal will be ztupendous! Anything you could possibly desire. I have enlisted the finest chefs in Europe.
Kahla-LAH breathes a sigh of relief and looks askance at Schtuppen. Schtuppen then starts laughing again, a sonorous, diabolical tone. Kahla-LAH starts giggling, which soon becomes uncontrollable. Their laughter continues to rise to an other-worldly cacophony, echoing throughout the chamber as the curtain falls.
END
Well that explains pretty much everything. Bravo Madam!
Supporting Israel, the stolen shithole apartheid state, while they’re committing genocide in Gaza has cost every nation signatory to the UN genocide convention their credibility. They ALL stand as pariahs on the world’s stage.
Israel that stolen shithole apartheid state has received more aid most of it military from the U.S. than any other nation, 250 billion, since its theft in 1948 which started the last 75 years of conflict in the Middle East.
But that’s not anywhere near the total cost all the theft of Palestine.
The Balfour declaration was a promise of Palestine to Jews for bringing the anti war US into WW1 on the side of Britain that resulted in two more years of war and millions of lives.
Jewish Bolsheviks led by Lenin also overthrew the Russian monarchy in 1917 creating communism and the KGB How much has Russian communism cost?
In 1932 Jews were becoming impatient for their promised land, Palestine, and coordinated global boycotts against Germany to drive the world into WW2. How much did that cost?
In 1948 Jews finally stole Palestine referencing the Balfour Declaration and initiated the Middle East conflict that has raged and grown ever since. How much has that mess cost the world?
The Costs to American Taxpayers of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict: $3 Trillion BEFORE their holocaust in Gaza.
https://ifamericansknew.org/stat/cost.html
Refuted.
Now STFU and go join your Iranian friends in their evil jihad against Israel.
"We have even managed to corrupt the Libertarians via some high-placed moles in their organization. It dawned upon Yoo Ching one day that the Libertarians had the potential to attract millions of people with their simple, appealing message. He said that the message was powerful enough and their numbers zignificant enough that if they overcame some minor divisions within their ranks that appeal could snowball, and no candidate for high office would have a chance without their blessing. We could not abide that, so we set about exacerbating those differences, ultimately sowing confusion among them. It was quite simple when you look at it. We infiltrated their upper ranks and got them bickering amongst themselves over minutia. Distinctions between immigration, illegal immigration, migration and so on. They could have shrugged it all off and threw their support to a sensible policy but instead they were cowed into open borders, even going so far as to turn a blind eye to welfare for illegals at the expense of the taxpayer! Then we corralled them into some nonsensical positions in which many of them were actually SUPPORTING our censorship efforts. So, in essence, their libertarian center was kaput. We denied them the ability to define their own essence. Their membership suffered, and we zwooped in. And on top of it they never realized how abzurd it was for them to be running candidates for POTUS, which only diluted opportunities to align with any libertarian seeds within the major parties. We saw to their impotence. They never realized the strength they could have had. They wavered, and we are the victors!"
Indeed.
Rather vague. Can you expand on this and go into some detail. Too pithy.
Illegal aliens cost the taxpayers about $150 Billion last year. I'd say that was a much bigger problem.
Let me guess, it's all Trump's fault or JD Vance or the Abraham Accords, anything but the current regime in power or the Iranians backing all this.
And none of it is the result of Harris giving hundreds of billions of dollars to the Iranians.
Or more than three hundred billion$ to israel since 1947.
I’m seeing about $158 billion. And they’re a strategic ally. Not an enemy, like the Iranian regime. And the democrats have given them more than $158 billion just since Harris has been in charge. Obama gave them lots of money too.
But I get it, you hate Jews. Just be careful. You could end up like Misek.
Never go full Misek.
And just when we thought the NeoCon Hawks had all but vanished, here they are again in their trench coats flashing minors in the park.
They're like a case of a recurring STD. Just when you think it's gone, it flares back up again.
How much to nuke it all?
Thanks to Harris, Iran might be getting nuked, very soon. In fact, thanks to Harris, a nuclear WW3 might be inevitable.
Multiple military bases near where Helene ravaged, without providing assistance, but Biden-Harris focusing on their foreign forever proxy wars. Disgraceful. At least MacDill AFB moved their planes out of Milton’s path.
A tax strike is inevitable, we have nothing to lose at this point.
In a world in which the government can shut off your life with a couple of mouse clicks, a tax strike is not going to happen.
Trying to protect global trade from acts of piracy by forces such as the Houthis counts as "continuing the violence"?
What should be done about it then? The answer is not "nothing" as we are dependent on global trade, and on the economic side this publication argues that this is a good and even unavoidable condition.
The Party of Dick Cheney
The democrats?
The party of psychopaths
This year, Dick is behind Kamala.
Or perhaps in Kamala’s behind.
Dick is a WAD - Weapon of Ass Destruction
I’m sure Kamala is accustomed to having Dick behind, in front, and under her simultaneously.
Ron Paul is of course, correct about all this nonsense. We need to put an end to Washington's interventionist policies and its military adventurism.
Neither Trump not Harris will do it.
No they will not. I’m not a Romney fan but.. his quip on only fifty percent of Americans pay federal income taxes is spot on. The top ten-20 percent pay the majority within the top fifty percent.
Collapse of the republic is what happens when the welfare state, in all its forms- cronyism, open borders immigration, bureaucracy, media, NGOs, contractors, defined benefit pensions - win elections through progressive taxation and more bullshit jobs programs.
Yes, Harris’s war in the Middle East has cost us dearly. Just like her war in Ukraine, and her impending war in Taiwan.
"A Year of War in the Middle East Cost Americans Nearly $23 Billion."
...and how much money has Biden given the Ukraine to continue its war?
If Americans overwhelmingly continue voting for the winner of the pissing match to see who is the biggest warhawk on the ballot every time, we will continue to experience "Neverending War" - only the names will change: Making the World Safe for Democracy; or the Global War Against Terrorism; or Vital National Interests; or - but you get the idea!
The climate war
Fedtaxpayer strike 2025 or demand a federal flat tax.
We’re losing the republic every hour on the hour.
So I guess we're not doing Ukraine huh?
How often do you suppose that an attacking missile and the anti-missile system that shoots it down both come from the same manufacturer?
It works best to have compatible systems.
There is a meme showing the Iranian missiles with contrails with Israeli Iron Dome missiles with contrails. The captions are:
My tax dollars at work.
Also my tax dollars at work.
Supporting Israel, the stolen religious nationalist shithole apartheid state, while they’re committing genocide in Gaza has cost every nation signatory to the UN genocide convention their credibility. They ALL stand as pariahs on the world’s stage.
Israel that stolen shithole apartheid state has received more aid most of it military from the U.S. than any other nation, 250 billion, since its theft in 1948 which started the last 75 years of conflict in the Middle East.
But that’s not anywhere near the total cost all the theft of Palestine.
The Balfour declaration was a promise of Palestine to Jews for bringing the anti war US into WW1 on the side of Britain that resulted in two more years of war and millions of lives.
Jewish Bolsheviks led by Lenin also overthrew the Russian monarchy in 1917 creating communism and the KGB How much has Russian communism cost?
In 1932 Jews were becoming impatient for their promised land, Palestine, and coordinated global boycotts against Germany to drive the world into WW2. How much did that cost?
In 1948 Jews finally stole Palestine referencing the Balfour Declaration and initiated the Middle East conflict that has raged and grown ever since. How much has that mess cost the world?
The Costs to American Taxpayers of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict: $3 Trillion BEFORE their holocaust in Gaza.
https://ifamericansknew.org/stat/cost.html
Refuted.
Antisemetic conspiracy theory nutjobs are alive and well on Reason.
Hasbara shills for the atrocities of Israel are a dime a dozen.
Refuted.
And if you have the courage of your convictions. You will immediately head to Iran and fight for them. But you probably don’t have the guts. Hell, you’re afraid to reveal the slightest detail about yourself. You leftist shitweasels always are.
This is what you’re saying about yourself when you parrot “refuted”.
1. You’re upset by something I’ve said.
2. You’re too stupid to actually refute it.
3. You’re too bigoted to consider that what you can’t refute might be true.
4. You’re too stupid to consider your dilemma in silence.
5. You’re so angry that you’ll make a fool of yourself trying to anger me too.
6. In the case of a hasbara troll you’re willing to say all that about yourself for a few shekels.
Like I say to all fuckwits, prove it.
Clearly describe how you have specifically refuted anything that I’ve said with correctly applied logic and science AND provide a link to it so we can all fact check your claim.
If you think $23B is expensive, wait till every two-bit dictator realizes they can push America and its allies around. Then it will get expensive.
Democrats always project strength inwards at Americans, and only project weakness at foreign powers.
The Democrat party has no right to exist. Let’s make that a reality.
Gaza, Lebanon, Yemen, Syria, and Iraq.
What should really bother you about that price tag is that all five of those places can still be found on a map.
Syria should have been gone years ago. Gaza should have been razed to the ground on October 8, 2023, with Yemen following suit by the end of the same year.
We should be mopping up Lebanon today. And Iran should be on final notice: unconditional surrender to American/Israeli occupation/colonization - with Islam completely outlawed in the region by penalty of summary execution - or watch every major and then minor city be completely destroyed within a week. Russia and China will balk, but they don't care about their Iranian interests that much to make anything more than damning proclamations on the subject.
At which point we turn a menacing glare towards Turkey and the Saudis, and a sharp look at Afghanistan just for good measure.
Israel coordinated October 7 2023.
Their “response”, genocide, was planned long in advance.
Does anyone really believe that it’s a coincidence that Israel removed its defences, emptied its military bases and didn’t respond for 6 hours?
Even if it was, lol, all the "Palestinians" had to do was not kidnap, rape, and murder people. Boom, Israel's "plan" is stopped in its tracks.
But the "Palestinians" couldn't help themselves, could they. They're just awful. Israel wiping them out is for the best, don't you agree?
Even if it was eh? I wonder what the Israeli hostages and dead would have to say about being the bait in a trap.
Do US military personnel get to decide which orders they want to follow?
Especially if they don’t know their orders are coming from the enemy. Their terrorist apartheid oppressors for 76 years.
Who knows what they were told?
Lol fuckwit.
See, and that’s another thing “Palestine” could have not done – don’t take hostages. In fact, don’t bother the Israeli’s whatsoever. And then the Israeli’s wouldn’t be able to spring their “response.”
I mean, this could have all been avoided if someone – like you, perhaps - had just sat down with “Palestine” and calmly explained to them, “Look, if you can restrain yourselves from killing, raping, kidnapping, and holding people hostage, the Israeli’s won’t have an excuse to wipe you off the face of the Earth where, frankly, you belong.”
Why haven’t you – or anyone else – tried explaining that to “Palestine?”
Palestinians, and the entire Middle East, have suffered 76 years of Israeli occupation, terrorism and apartheid. Palestinians want their hostages back from Israel.
The US citizens have funded Israeli atrocities in every way possible.
Now Israel is openly defying the world by committing a holocaust in Gaza and the US still supports them.
Who is the “honest broker” to sit down with both Israel and Palestinians? The United Nations?
You didn’t answer the question.
Palestinians, and the entire Middle East, have suffered 76 years of Israeli occupation, terrorism and apartheid.
Wait, you’re contradicting yourself. (Also, what’s a “Palestinian?” That word has no meaning.)
Anyway, so Israel has been doing all this atrocity with total impunity, right? Like, literal terrorism and apartheid and blah blah blah. But for some reason (perhaps you’d care to explain?) they were holding off on outright genocide. And your argument is that they were waiting for some excuse to “respond” so that they could begin the genocide in earnest. Which, oddly enough, they’ve gone to great lengths to avoid during their retaliatory campaign and hostage rescue.
I mean, again, all “Palestine” had to do was NOT be murdering, raping, kidnapping, hostage-taking dirtbags. Why was that so hard for them?
Your argument is basically, “The slaver wanted to kill the slaves, which he could have at any time for any reason without a second thought since he was already so horrible and awful, but he waited until the slaves started killing and raping to do it, and then pounced on the opportunity and used it as his excuse to do so.”
Do you not realize how retarded that is, if the slaver is as evil as you want to paint him?
The US citizens have funded Israeli atrocities in every way possible.
Well, we want to be on the right side of history, as Barack might say.
Who is the “honest broker” to sit down with both Israel and Palestinians?
Galil.
OK fine, in all seriousness, jokes aside, I can get Israel to the table. Would you please page “Palestine” and tell them where to meet?
October 7 was coordinated by Israel.
Israel, not Palestinians, coordinated the killing of Israelis.
Israel has been committing a holocaust in Gaza for over a year.
OK, so let me make sure I'm perfectly clear here.
When "Palestine" took gleeful credit for all the rape and murder and burning babies alive, that was really some that was really just some tricksy Jew plot where they'd fake a bunch of hostage-taking (and subsequent murder) by "Palestinian" terrorists who... apparently were also in on the ruse? And that this was also coordinated hand-in-glove with Iran, whose money (from American Democrats) is the only reason the terrorist state of "Palestine" even exists in the first place?
Sounds kinda convoluted dude. I'm going to need you to map this one out for us. Step by step.
Israel coordinated it. Explain the last year, and whatever timeframe led up to "Palestine" killing and raping and burning and taking hostage and otherwise just being the least-deserving people on Earth of a continued existence.