Texas School Bans All-Black Clothing, Claims It's Associated With 'Mental Health Issues'
In a letter sent to parents, school officials say the clothing is more "associated with depression and mental health issues and/or criminality than with happy and healthy kids ready to learn."

An El Paso, Texas, middle school has banned students from wearing all-black clothing, claiming that the color is "associated with depression and mental health issues."
According to local news station KFOX14, Charles Middle School sent parents a letter informing them that the school's uniform policy would no longer allow students to wear all-black clothing. Instead, the school's dress code was rewritten to only allow students to wear khakis or blue jeans, with black or green polos and sweaters.
The changes were necessary to "[eliminate] a look that has taken over on campus with students wearing black tops with black bottoms, which has become more associated with depression and mental health issues and/or criminality than with happy and healthy kids ready to learn," the letter reads, according to KFOX14.
"What they are not allowing for students to wear clothing that is black from top to bottom," Norma De La Rosa, the president of the El Paso Teachers Association, said in a clarifying statement. "They can wear black shorts to go to PE. And they can wear it on free dress day, but they just cannot wear it from top to bottom."
The policy was met almost immediately with backlash from parents, who claimed it was unfair and nonsensical.
"Making students wear a different color isn't going to magically make them a completely different person," one parent commented online.
El Paso Independent School District officials have appeared to distance themselves from the decision in the wake of the backlash. "The campus prematurely communicated the dress code change as a final decision rather than a recommendation. We regret the miscommunication, particularly the intent behind the changes," a school district statement, obtained by the BBC, read.
This dress code change is one of the stranger attempts at handling rising rates of teen depression and anxiety. It's ridiculous to think that clothing is the cause of, rather than a meaningless correlation to, any behavioral or mental health problems a student is experiencing.
This decision reflects a kind of safetyism among school officials. Instead of attempting to address the cause of student behavioral issues, school officials are unnecessarily interfering with harmless self-expression—the exact kind of thing that could stave off, rather than create, mental health issues.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
The campus prematurely communicated the dress code change as a final decision rather than a recommendation. We regret the miscommunication, particularly the intent behind the changes,"
The sarc “I was just joking” defense.
Obama, "did I say we were going to have a fair and open process to select the nominee? my mistake...."
Johnny Cash hardest hit.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oDd32K-mOVw
For those who boycott YouTube:
Well, you wonder why I always dress in black
Why you never see bright colors on my back
And why does my appearance seem to have a somber tone
Well, there's a reason for the things that I have on
I wear the black for the poor and the beaten down
Livin' in the hopeless, hungry side of town
I wear it for the prisoner who is long paid for his crime
But is there because he's a victim of the times
I wear the black for those who've never read
Or listened to the words that Jesus said
About the road to happiness through love and charity
Why, you'd think He's talking straight to you and me
Well, we're doin' mighty fine, I do suppose
In our streak of lightnin' cars and fancy clothes
But just so we're reminded of the ones who are held back
Up front there ought to be a man in black
I wear it for the sick and lonely old
For the reckless ones whose bad trip left them cold
I wear the black in mournin' for the lives that could have been
Each week we lose a hundred fine young men
And I wear it for the thousands who have died
Believin' that the Lord was on their side
I wear it for another hundred-thousand who have died
Believin' that we all were on their side
Well, there's things that never will be right, I know
And things need changin' everywhere you go
But 'til we start to make a move to make a few things right
You'll never see me wear a suit of white
Ah, I'd love to wear a rainbow every day
And tell the world that everything's okay
But I'll try to carry off a little darkness on my back
'Til things are brighter, I'm the man in black
Well he does sound like he's depressed and has mental health issues.
"[eliminate] a look that has taken over on campus with students wearing black tops with black bottoms, which has become more associated with depression and mental health issues and/or criminality than with happy and healthy kids ready to learn,"
Antifa holding on line two - - - - - - - -
I think they might need to brush up on their understanding of cause an effect.
Why not just have a rule against being depressed?
Expulsion for not being cheery. It would at least eliminate the kids who don't feel like acting.
Seems like a stupid rule, with shaky reasoning. But at the same time, it seems to be a broad guideline that applies to all students. Unless it's targeting any particular expression or speech, I don't see that it runs afoul of 1A.
If parents/students don't like it, I'd certainly encourage them to look into homeschooling or private school.
No, it's not a 1st amendment issue. It's just retarded.
"It's just retarded."
No argument here. The point I was trying to make is that, often, libertarians focus on the ridiculous aspects of government run organizations, but completely miss the boat advocating for alternatives.
I'm actually one of those blasphemers that think there is a place for publicly funded education, but it should be scaled way back and private actors should play a much larger role in society (according to the choices and efforts of those constituents).
Exactly that. Kids choose the goth look because they are already depressed, not to become depressed.
Another argument for school uniforms.
Clothing bans will continue until morale improves.
I'm willing to lay some pretty high odds no Texas schools will be clothing-optional anytime this century.
California will be, at least for drag queen story hour days.
Black is slimming, and I'll be damned if I'll let those little fatties hide their girth from Presidential Youth Fitness Program evaluators.
And you don’t wear color with black. A makes the color look cheap, and the black look boring. And judging by the aesthetic choices of most school administrators, they are the last people to make fashion choices for anyone. If anything I should go down there and set fashion codes for the school employees. As my observation on is that most teachers shop from the same thrift stores.
Leave it to Grand Goblin Greg's Ku-Klux Texas to ban priestly smocks and penguin nuns' habits. White sheets with peaky hoods were dress code at State Fair klanbakes in the roarin' lynchin' twenties. So I believe the Texas Statehouse ought to at-gunpoint force every child enrolled in government school to wear rainbow outfits. In theory that would get the vote out for libertarian candidates. But under Jesus Caucus management, libertarian candidate in Texas means mostly Mormon, Beatles-Burning and Landover Baptists. Enjoy. https://www.youtube.com/watch?app=desktop&v=byEZzxa7SwM
Shouldn't Nick Gillespie have written this article?
Nick should have also written about a hundred articles by now protesting every aspect of the J6 arrests and prosecutions. But none of that is happening either.
Just because clothing is not the cause of, does not mean that a correlation is necessarily meaningless. It is entirely possible that kids who are experiencing certain types and/or causes of depression may be drawn to certain looks, such as goth, emo, or the idolization and dressing like Columbine shooters (they wore all black, iirc), etc.
If there IS any sort of correlation, one would think we would be better off if we used that in order to be able to better watch and help some kids rather than just banning and masking the behavior and signs.
Of course, if we were to do that, we'd likely be back here in a couple years debating whether clothing-profiling makes a person a fasionist or not.
This rule is definitely treating a supposed symptom not a cause. It's superficial and looks only at the surface. I'd expect nothing more from bureaucrats.
Many police officers, especially on SWAT teams, wear black uniforms. Those officers must be depressed and have a tendency toward criminality.
I've advocated that our local police go back to blue uniforms. They don't like the idea.
I was going to say something similar. It’s obviously a dumb “recommendation” that attempts to treat an effect rather than a cause.
But that is different than saying it is a “meaningless” correlation. I think the emo/goth look does tend to suggest some sort of anti-social worldview (isn’t that the point?), which itself has correlation with mental health issues, etc. Obviously, anti-social worldview shouldn’t be punished in and of itself, but the correlation is there, and I don’t think it is meaningless.
Gillespie’s shark jumping jacket faces stiff competition from Soave’s David Brooks Brothers shirts .
To be fair, anyone wearing all black clothing outside of the months of October to March in Texas does have mental health issues. Or just never ever goes outside when the sun is up.
It's B. My relatives in the desert southwest assure me that they do not leave the house for half the year.
I guess there will be no Antifa club at the school, time to burn it down!
Black Clothes Matter.
[takes off plain, black t-shirt]
[leafs through black Megadeth, Metallica, KMFDM, Rammstein, etc., etc., etc. shirts]
...
[decides to go with much more cheery blaze orange t-shirt since it's the weekend]
This could all be solved without prejudice by banning clothing altogether.
At least for the hot chicks.
The goth kids are the last ones you should be concerned about. They ALWAYS phase out of that before they're 20.
It's the one waving pride flags and calling themselves the wrong pronouns that you should be rounding up and putting into serious counseling. But, like, actual counselors. Not alphabet people or any other groomers.
They ALWAYS phase out of that before they’re 20.
Nope. I have a goth friend in NYC who is in her mid-50s. She is not unique
Well, sure - NYC.
They aren’t wrong in the observation, but I don’t see how banning the expression solves the cause?
Being, indeed, a wisenheimer, if I had been a student in that school I would have moved heaven and earth to come up with a ‘Punisher’ black with skull motif shirt.
Back in my day all the wannabe depressed kids wore commemorative Kurt Cobain t-shirts. Of course I said at the time, if you wanted to be really dark, disaffected, and controversial, you'd really be wearing a t-shirt with one of the Kurt Cobain post mortem photos printed on it.
Texas missed the #1 argument for the ban: Kids who dress in all black grow up to write for Reason. Shudder.
Have any True Goths with 100 % head-to- toe black tattoo coverage bee spotted in Texas schools?
They should try banning wet streets on weekends, so we can always have sunny weekends!
Next they'll be saying "it's that darn rock & roll music music they listen to."