A Magical World Where Government Discriminates Against the Nonmagical
The anime Mashle: Magic and Muscles offers an absurdist metaphor for politically driven discrimination.

What if human rights were dependent on magical ability?
That's the premise behind the popular anime Mashle: Magic and Muscles. The series takes place in the Magic Realm, a fantasy world where one's social standing is solely defined by magical abilities—and more magic means more political power. In the Realm, almost everyone is born with magical powers, but those with superior magic skills hold positions of authority. Status is demarcated by distinctive markings on people's faces: An average person bears only a single line; three lines signify god-like powers.
A small portion of the Realm population, however, is born without any magical ability at all. Known as lackmagics, they are outcasts in the Magic Realm. Lackmagics are excluded from society and deemed unworthy of human rights. They face constant persecution and even threats of death, as the Realm's government is intent on keeping humanity as magical as possible.
The show is funny and frequently absurd, but it's also a pointed political metaphor. Beneath the humor, Mashle is a story about a broken society where magical ability defines one's place in the world, and government-ordered discrimination not only results in the killing of innocents but also a society-wide disregard for nonmagical talents and abilities. It's a show about rejecting top-down discrimination and learning to appreciate people for their individual abilities, even when those abilities don't conform to social expectations.
The series follows a young man named Mash Burnedead, one of the detested lackmagics. He was born without an ounce of magic and raised in secret by an adoptive father who found him abandoned as a baby.
But his peaceful adolescence ends when he sneaks into town to buy cream puffs—his favorite dessert—and sparks an uproar when the townsfolk take notice of his unmarked face. Mash is confronted by a police officer determined to apprehend him, but his muscle power overwhelms the officer's magic. Faced with this unprecedented scenario, the officer proposes a deal: Mash can protect his life if he enrolls in a magic academy and becomes a divine visionary, a title bestowed upon exceptionally gifted students.
With no magic ability or powers whatsoever, Mash survives using the only means available to him: his muscles. His workout routine of 4.6-ton bench presses, side crunches, and a protein shake allows him to pass tests of magical ability using nothing but his wit and gains, often in the silliest, strangest ways.
In a game where players are required to fly on brooms and score by throwing balls through hoops, Mash defies the laws of physics by using his legs to kick so fast that he essentially flies. Mash's methods are unconventional, but they're effective enough to fool everyone into thinking he can use magic.
That sounds a lot like the flying-broom sport Quidditch from the Harry Potter series for a reason. At its core, Mashle is simply a protein-induced parody of J.K. Rowling's wizarding world, complete with a Hogwarts-looking castle, a Dumbledore-esque headmaster, and schoolhouses with animal sigils. Some scenes are effectively absurdist reimaginings of scenarios from the Harry Potter series, including a unicorn skeleton that decides which house students belong to, acting as an analog to Hogwarts' sorting hat, and a visit to a wand shop where the wand chooses you.
Since its debut in spring 2023, Mashle captured the hearts of anime watchers, but it was its second season that skyrocketed its popularity (partly thanks to the viral TikTok dance sparked by its opening song). Yet this second season is definitely more complex, delving deeper into the world's systemic discrimination and Mash's struggle against anti-lackmagic prejudice.
Eventually Mash's secret is discovered, and he finds himself facing trial before the world's most powerful magicians. "Magical powers are a gift from God, and those without them should be excluded," says one of the top magicians.
Yet a select few within the council believe that Mash has the potential to "change how people perceive the world." Historically, lackmagics have been treated as inferior, but as the headmaster points out, "Our values change alongside history."
Over time, Mash's feats of strength begin to shift the initially hostile public perception, challenging deeply ingrained biases. He defeats the school's strongest magicians and even protects them against outside threats with his unnatural strength. For example, when the school is threatened by a gigantic multihead monster immune to magical attacks, the only one capable of fighting it is Mash, who beats it after engaging in a ridiculous tug-of-war game that sends it flying.
Mash is a stoic figure of superhuman strength, whose head is filled with nothing but exercise routines and cream puffs. He is so obsessed with the pastry that he always carries one in his coat and goes out of his way to protect it during battles, treating it with as much importance as his own life. (Again, it's quite absurd.) Despite his emotional detachment, his loyalty to his friends is unwavering; he always helps them with reality-defying exercise stunts—and a little help from his muscles, which he's named Kevin, Tom, and Mike.
Mashle's premise gives it a veneer of political drama. But it's so amusing it hardly feels like a lecture. Mostly, the show leaves viewers laughing at the absurdity of Mash's muscle-induced action. Mash's struggle is both personal and societal, as he struggles to make his way in a world that doesn't appreciate his abilities. It's a series that teaches us that true power isn't only about force and physical strength but also the ability to change hearts and minds.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
For real? Anime now? This is a stretch. There's nothing political about Mashle. It's a bog standard shonen power fantasy.
There’s nothing political about Mashle. It’s a bog standard shonen power fantasy.
Sounds a little like, once again, a Japanese story writer was able to effectively, originally, and creatively “borrow” 1997’s X-Men TV show for a product of a different name better than a retarded, domestic, activist, fan was able to generate a sequel titled X-Men ’97.
Japan – What if… an unseen society has this entrenched power structure and the protagonist outsider has to go on a journey, incurring losses, expanding his understanding, and building his power, in order to topple, or not, the whole affair? Ultimately succeeding, or not, on the sum total of his efforts and will? [‘Libertarians’ across the pond wind up writing articles on the story’s success.]
U.S. – What if… I made more of the characters queer like me?
[Disney quietly puts up a sign encouraging bystanders to avert their eyes and plug their noses as they walk by the smoldering crater where a beloved piece of drama/nostalgia once stood.]
You are way overthinking it. It's literally just "what if One Punch Man went to Hogwarts".
He never overthinks anything. Don't let the grandiose verbiage fool you.
🙂
😉
Goodbye, Cruel World! Kick me out, Reason, whenever you're ready!
🙂
😉
It’s literally just “what if One Punch Man went to Hogwarts”
Sure. It also actually sounds a *lot* more like My Hero Academia except with magic rather than quirks or Naruto with magic instead of tailed-beasts... but my point was it's the same Hero's Journey formula, if not with the typical more typical Japanese De Jure caste ranking and/or video game flare, which has been ripped off endlessly and is so popular and endlessly relatable we talk about the nth iteration of it here in America.
Whereas with modern, woke, Western culture/drama, we take "We fight against our annihilation and the annihilation of all mankind." X-men and turn it into "We fight to see other faces in the room who look like us, you know, diversity." X-men that doesn't even make sense and resonate in its own culture.
I would compare it more to Black Clover which involves a society that is ruled mainly by the people with the most powerful magic, the bottom of society are those with little or no magic power and the main character is a person who ( at least in the beginning) has no magical abilities and must use his physical capabilities to advance in that society.
Nice try weebs, I still ain't watching no anime.
It is a simple deduction.
Do you believe liberty, and human rights, are the birthright of every human being? Yes or no?
For libertarians, the answer must be 'yes'.
But for most other people, the answer is 'no'.
And if the answer is 'no', then liberty and human rights are allocated according to some type of hierarchy. Those at the top of the hierarchy get the most liberty, those at the bottom get the least.
In this anime show, apparently (I have not watched it), the hierarchy is defined by magical ability.
In the real world, Team Red and Team Blue define the hierarchy differently.
Team Blue defines the hierarchy of liberty according to utilitarianism. That is, if a person is using his/her liberty in a constructive fashion (benefits outweigh the costs), that person is entitled to continue using that liberty. But if a person is using his/her liberty in a destructive fashion (costs outweigh the benefits), then that person ought to be prohibited from further exercise of that liberty. The problem here of course is that how the costs and benefits are defined is very much a subjective matter.
Team Red defines the hierarchy according to moral worth. Those who are most morally worthy are entitled to more liberty, but those who are least morally worthy are not entitled to much (if any) liberty. The problem here, of course, just like with Team Blue, is that deciding on 'moral worth' is fundamentally subjective.
We libertarians ought to reject the hierarchy of liberty and embrace the Enlightenment concept from our Declaration of Independence that *all* human beings are endowed with inalienable rights.
Team Read definitely… And Team Blue also, in imitation of Team Red, in order to secure votes… BOTH define one’s worth by whether or not one was born on “Magic Soil”… If one was NOT born on “Magic Soil”, then the next step, ***IF*** allowed to, by Magic Government Almighty, is to secure some Magic Papers, often after waiting for decades. Lacking either of these kinds of Magic, one is forever a sub-human at best!
"We libertarians"
Give us a break jeff.
REAL Libertarians Orally Stimulate Orange Penis!
The Meeting of the Right Rightist Minds will now come to Odor!
Years ago by now, Our Dear Leader announced to us, that He may commit murder in broad daylight, and we shall still support Him! So He Has Commanded, and So Must Shit be Done!
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/jan/24/donald-trump-says-he-could-shoot-somebody-and-still-not-lose-voters
And now, oh ye Faithful of the Republican Church, Shit Has Become Known Unto us, that Shit is also in His Power and Privilege Ass Well, to murder the USA Constitution in broad daylight. Thus He Has Spoken, and Thus Must Shit Be Done! Thou shalt Render Unto Trump, and simply REND the USA Constitution, and wipe thine wise asses with shit! Do NOT render unto some moldering old scrap of bathroom tissue! Lest we be called fools, or worse!
https://www.cnn.com/2022/12/03/politics/trump-constitution-truth-social/index.html
Proud Boys, STAND with TRUMP, and stand by! And if ye don’t agree 110%, then we don’t need you polluting our world, because all who disagree with us in ANY way are LEFTISTS!!!
There, I think that’s a wrap! I’ve covered shit ALL! You can take the rest of the day off now.
(You’re welcome!)
But for most other people, the answer is ‘no’.
Who the hell decided that YOU get to say what people think?
OT Post:
https://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/columnist/2024/04/05/moon-time-zone-white-house-nasa-conspiracy/73207815007/
Over-the-Moon Lunatic liberals!!!
Liberals in the White House want a time zone for the moon? Forget it, nerds!
Swoll Potter: The Boy Who Lifts. It’s a fairly funny anime, but it is certainly one note most of the time. A lot of anime style “EHHHH?!?!?” reactions to whatever crazy feat the MC pulls off.
Supernatural strength that allows someone to fly by kicking air isn't magical? Seems the "non-magical" person still only succeeds by being stupidly powerful. How can you possibly twist that into a political knot?
Well, um... yeah.
Not going to bother watching that either. It sounds like Invader Zim where the aliens place in their society is based on how tall they are. Their leaders are known as "Tallest".
A Magical World Where Government Discriminates Against the Nonmagical
Sooooo...Every Theocracy that ever existed in humsn history? Not entertaining! Hard pass!