Students With an Undocumented Parent Still Can't Fill Out the FAFSA Form
The updated FAFSA form has been marred with technical problems, leaving many students unable to complete the financial aid form entirely.

Since its "soft launch" in December, the new Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) form has proved to be a logistical nightmare for millions of families who rely on the financial aid form to obtain federal grants and loans. While the streamlined form was intended to simplify the financial aid process, it has instead been plagued by glitches that have made it literally impossible for students whose parents don't have social security numbers to complete the form.
"It's just draining and exhausting," Aaron Dominguez, a high school senior whose immigrant mother doesn't have a Social Security Number told The Chronicle of Higher Education. "I know I have the right to ask for federal aid. But they've just made things so much harder for people like me. It's unfair. The government clearly just sees us like an afterthought."
FAFSA is the most popular tool for college students and families seeking financial aid. The form is necessary to obtain federal grants and loans, and most colleges use the form when deciding how much institutional aid to give students.
In 2020, Congress passed the Consolidated Appropriations Act, which required the Education Department to develop a new, simpler FAFSA form. The updated form, first made available on December 30, cut down the number of questions families had to answer by more than half and relies on data directly from the IRS to further streamline the process.
While the idea of simplifying the FAFSA form was a good one, the Education Department's execution of the legally mandated update has been marred by technical issues and delays. Months into the form's availability, the FAFSA website still lists more than a dozen active issues preventing students from filling out the form, though most list some kind of workaround.
However, students whose parents don't have a social security number—typically because their parent isn't a U.S. citizen or is undocumented—are still completely unable to complete the form. While the website promises a fix to the form sometime during the "first half of March," as of March 11th, the problem persists.
While students can technically submit the form if their parent doesn't have a social security number, the submitted form would be lacking key information colleges—and the government—need to estimate families' expected costs to send their child to college.
Despite technical issues, the Education Department has not extended the June 30 deadline for submitting the form.
Making a popular financial aid form more accessible for students and families is a no-brainer. But the disastrous rollout of the new FAFSA form shows just how badly things can go wrong when the government bungles something as important as college financial aid—and just how easy it is for vulnerable prospective students and their families to get left behind.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Even illegal aliens (not "undocumented immigrants") can get a taxpayer identification number from the IRS which serves the same purpose. Why can't they just use that?
Because it's all bullshit from anti-Western cunts like Emna and the Democrats.
Lobbying for financial aid is the most libertarian thing ever.
Making a popular financial aid form more accessible for students and families is a no-brainer.
This is how you know you're reading a truly libertarian publication.
Little Emma is all in for the illegal invasion.
*Checks libertarian bingo card*
Huh…”Article lamenting how hard it is to get government handouts” isn’t on here? How can that be? No something must be wrong.
*Checks again...*
Ok, so there is "Government shouldn't be funding secondary education."
And there is "Government shouldn't be mass collecting income information of families."
Oh...and there is "Social Security numbers have become a universal identifier, contrary to the assurances of its creators."
But still...I can't find any libertarian angle that thinks we should be making it easier to get handouts from the government. Is Reason playing the same bingo I am?
Playing libertarian bingo like that would require self awareness, something Ms Camp lacks.
Emma is still pissed she gets carded for beer in MD.
In 20 years, her perspective on this will change. Trust me. She'll long for the days when she would get carded because she 'looked young'.
And is Aaron Domguez also an illegal? Little Emma doesn’t address that.
Yeah, this seems like an article much more suited for say The Atlantic or Salon than Reason. Making FAFSA easier is a no brainer? How about the Feds have no right or duty to provide student loans in the first place, the ease of filling out the form is a total non-sequitur.
While it’s not perfect, I would suggest that Ms. Camp take a look at this definition of libertarianism:
https://www.fff.org/explore-freedom/article/libertarianism-defined/
It might help her to understand the anger, and confusion, in the comments at her articles. Or, she can remain oblivious…
Little Emma is also best suited for Salon, or perhaps Rolling Stone.
Breaks my heart it’s difficult for illegals to get free taxpayer money.
To be fair, the student is the one that is having problems getting money, and the student is legal. You may not agree with the birthright citizenship rule that confers that status, but it Diane make the student any less entitled to aid than anyone else.
To be fair to US citizens, birth right citizenship should be revoked. That assumes that birth right citizenship has ever legally existed.
Is he legal? The article doesn’t address that.
Love the libertarian take on government doling out money to individuals.
"Oh, it's just so hard to fill out those forms!"
Geez fuck some people should just go get a job writing for a magazine that matches their progressive values. Like Huffington Post or something.
I hear Deadspin has openings!
Just get them to use stolen or fraudulent identification. Then they will not be undocumented.
"Making a popular financial aid form more accessible for students and families is a no-brainer."
I believe we have misidentified the no-brainer in this situation.
Serves them right for choosing the wrong parents.
Lol. Most of the replies here are libertarian. But not sarc. Freebies for all who cross the border!
Hilarious.
Nothing more libertarian than taxpayer money going to illegals.
Their parents shouldn't be in this country. They shouldn't be in this country. They are foreign nationals and should have already been deported, not offered taxpayer money. Fuck off with this bullshit. If you want to support open borders then you can't support giving government funds to immigrants. That's just shitting on citizens
Truth!
>>the new Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) form has proved to be a logistical nightmare for millions of families who rely on the financial aid form to obtain federal grants and loans.
yes, this is how your Ruling heroes speak from both sides of their mouths.
A lot of words for the libertarian position: end FAFSA.
Simple. Have all the undocumented parents with no SSNs come to temporary Social Security offices to apply for one, then round them up and deport them.
free Yankees tickets!
A great way to do this is to pay the people rounding them up on a commission basis.
Something else that Camp forgets to mention, around 40-50% of high school graduates attend university, but only about 10-20% of jobs really should require a university degree. Part of the outrageous costs of universities today is the fact that about 80% of the student body shouldn't be there and would be better served receiving some form of vocational training rather than a four year degree. But because we've pushed everyone to go to the university. Schools still measure success based on how many graduates attend an university after graduating highschool and often count students entering the workforce (even for apprenticeships), vocational or military as failures. Go to trade school or do an apprenticeship, you'll likely be down in under 2 years, and often making more than those with a sheepskin BA that they overpaid for (and because we're pushing everyone to go to college, the universities are watering down their course work while inflating grades, meaning a bachelor's today is less rigorous than it was ten, twenty or more years ago. And all financial aid funded by the government does is insure that we continue to subsidize substandard education that isn't needed (and often isn't even wanted by the students themselves, who only attend because their teachers and parents told them they had or they'll never do anything but flip hamburgers).
So, in the end, like most governmental programs, what we subsidize becomes more expensive and of lower quality.
>>80% of the student body shouldn’t be there and would be better served receiving some form of vocational training
dude we're trying to overthrow a patriarchy here ...
Persons With Vaginas can be patriarchs.
Deport the illegals. And send the democrats along with them.
"I know I have the right to ask for federal aid."
No, grasshopper, you do not.
Yes. Yes he does. HE’S legal. His parents are not.
yeah - he has the right to ask ... its the right to free speech.
he has no right to federal aid - so if its a tough process or filled with caveats and catch-22's well... tough!
The article doesn’t address his status. And I don’t trust Emma. How do we know he’s legal?
my father many many years ago refused to fill out the FAFSA contending it was an invasion of privacy.He was also an immigrant-albeit a legal one.I still can't figure out how the gubmint thinks they can tell people how much they can contribute to a college education.I declared my self an emancipated minor and applied for loans,etc. that way.It can be done. And no,little Miss DACA is not entitled to any federal money-your mother did not pay taxes so bugger off
Emancipation now still requires FAFSA for loans.
Holy shit, Reason expects us to pay for this garbage? Lolol
Yet another article from Emma about the problems with the new FAFSA Form and with its roll-out, and not one mention that nowhere in the list of enumerated powers found in Article I Section 8 of The Constitution of The United States is education or its funding listed as a power of the federal government.
^THIS^ +1000000000000000
Democrats want to make things up as they go along.
There is nothing so libertarian as begging the government for free stuff.
--Reason
Oh, don’t be silly, diarrhea. They’re not begging.
They’re demanding.
Fair.
>”I know I have the right to ask for federal aid.
1. No, you don’t have a right to ask for federal aid.
2. Your mother is an illegal working under the table, not paying taxes – otherwise she’d have an ITN. But you want *me* to pay for your college?
3. Why are you upset that this kid can't get the federal government to steal money from me and give to him but you're not upset that the federal government is stealing money from me?
"Aaron Dominguez, a high school senior whose ILLEGAL immigrant mother"
Left a word out there, Emma.
I doubt Emma even appreciates the cognitive dissonance. It's a trademark feature of leftists everywhere.
"I support X. But society says I need to support Y. Therefore I support Y, even though it contradicts X."
I've been trying to keep the hierarchy straight. As best as I can tell it goes:
A) Illegals - sacred above all else. Doesn't matter if they kill a coed or engage in brazen interstate crime sprees. Also, ignore their trafficking, rape trees, and sheer numbers.
B) Gays/Abortion - Moloch will not be satisfied until all the kids are dead, trans'd, or served up to pedos. Questions and/or criticism about ANY of this is 100% verboten.
C) Blacks - they exist, you're not one of them, so you're a racist. Forever. Nothing you can do can fix this. Ever.
D) Muslims - important, but they hate the gays (except when it comes to genital mutilation) so... we'll just pretend they don't. Their genocidal antipathy towards Jews/Christians, however, you can support.
E) Gaia Cult - annoying, but you have to support them because you loathe humanity and love being lied to. Right? RIGHT?!
I think that's the order it goes, insofar as their Marxist supremacy Frankfurt School anti-human extinctionist critical theory garbage goes.
And if you're a leftist pretending to be a libertarian, like our friend Emma here, you'll quickly replace anything A-E above any "libertarian" "principle" you might ever try to assert.
Right Emma?