Tort Lawsuit in Quintuple Suicide Case at Truman State University

The parents of two suicide victims blame the university, the ABK fraternity, and an allegedly death-obsessed frat brother

|The Volokh Conspiracy |

Five Truman State University (TSU) undergraduate students killed themselves during the 2016-2017 academic year. Four were Alpha Kappa Lambda (AKL) frat brothers and one was a female victim about whom less is known. The parents of two of the male victims (of death by hanging), have filed a lawsuit in a Missouri state court against the university, the frat, and a frat brother named Brandon Grossheim who appears to have been linked to all five victims. Unlike in the Michelle Carter case in Massachusetts (about which I blogged here, here, and here), no criminal charges were filed against Grossheim for playing a role in the suicides.

The facts are currently somewhat murky. Grossheim appears to have had access to the living quarters of the victims, was in the proximity of some of them around the time of their deaths, allegedly took some victims' items like money or drugs, and had spoken to at least some of the victims about their depression and suicidal thoughts. According to the suit:

Defendant Grossheim had the intent to aid or encourage Mullins and Thomas to commit self-harm in that he "counseled" them and gave "step-by step-instructions to them on how to "deal with their depression," make peace and "do their own free will" thereby implying that he counseled them to commit suicide.

The plaintiffs accuse the defendants of "negligence, misrepresentation, and other wrongful conduct". The lawsuit states in part:

Defendants AKL and TSU had a legal duty to use ordinary care to protect its members, including Plaintiffs from a person, known to be violent, who was present on the premises or an individual who was present who has conducted himself so as to indicate danger and sufficient time exists to prevent injury.

Defendants breached their duty to Plaintiffs by failing to intervene in Grossheim's dangerous behavior and/or failing to warn or protect Plaintiffs.

What role Grossheim played in the suicides and whether TSU and AKL failed to fulfill their duties should become clearer as the facts unfold. At this stage, the plaintiffs likely have a long way to go before they meet their legal burdens.

NEXT: What If Man Is a Killer Ape Beset by Original Sin?

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. How are there no comments yet? I’d have thought a bizarre case like this one would attract some attention.

    Anyway, here’s a style tip for Prof. Manta: try less usage of “frat” and “frat brother,” more of “fraternity.” There is a sentiment held among a large cross-section of fraternity membership that “frat” reflects an attitude of trivializing the experience. It’s not a point of major importance, but it strikes me as good practice not to mildly annoy readers to no gain.

    1. Toga! Toga! Toga!

      Uh, I mean, let us wear togas while reciting passages of Cicero from memory in the original Latin, as our fraternity encourages us to do.

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.