Is Spending $1 Trillion on Education a Waste of Money? Bryan Caplan Says Yes.
"The Case Against Education" author and economist says "if all we're trying to do is prepare people for a job, why not prepare them with a *job*?"
"It's absolutely true that school makes people show up, sit down, shut up and that these are useful skills for people to have in adulthood," says Bryan Caplan, a professor of economics at George Mason University, a blogger at EconLog, and the author of the new book The Case Against Education: Why the Education System Is a Waste of Time and Money. "So the real question is if all we're trying to do is prepare people for a job, why not prepare them with a job?"
Caplan argues that schools are not only overpriced, but that traditional education fails to prepare students with job skills that reflect the needs of the labor market. Even worse, he says, most school is boring for students.
I sat down with Caplan to discuss his book and what, if any, value he sees in traditional K-12 and undergraduate education.
For a video version of our conversation and a full transcript, go here.
For an audio podcast version, go to iTunes and subscribe to the Reason Podcast, or click below to listen via Soundcloud.
We release three episodes a week, including one that is a rousing roundtable with Katherine Mangu-Ward, Peter Suderman, Matt Welch, and me discussing the news of the day. For a full archive, go here.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
If they spend that trillion dollars to continue the same education system that we have had for 40 or 50 years it will be a waste.
Well since the government shouldn't be involved in education at all I'd say yes.
Bryan Caplan: "So the real question is if all we're trying to do is prepare people for a job, why not prepare them with a job?"
Cathy Newman: "So are you saying you want 5-year-olds to work mining lead?"
Bryan Caplan: "....
What?"
well, yeah...they can get into the real small spaces!
"I sat down with Caplan..."
Obligatory intro; is that one of those 'do not pass go' things in J school?
But I don't see a print version. You expect someone to wade through the 'uh, well's and 'well gee's?
Get back to me when there's something to read.
For a video version of our conversation and a full transcript, go here.
Someone get grandpa some more pudding.
The Follower Factory
Fun fact: everyone is a dirty, pathetic liar.
1) Whoever wrote that article was too down with JavaScript. Calm down, son
2) I feel like they didn't well convey why this matters. It's a whole article that amounts to there be liars and fraudsters online.
Yeah, that was annoying.
they can't convey why it matters because it doesn't
Good Morning, Peantus!
Will Farrell came back to SNL last night to play Dubya and compare himself to the Con Man. Good stuff
Watch it here
https://youtu.be/Ch_hoYPPeGc
Of course you don't mention the musical guests.
You really are useless.
Would have been a better morning without your grumpitis.
Needs guitar solo but pretty good.
You actually watch that crap? No wonder you think you're witty.
I don't prefer to see school as primarily an assembly line for producing cogs for capitalism.
You prefer lots of things. Only statists and little kids hiding under blankets think denying reality somehow changes reality.
So are you for the change or not? Because that's what it is now.
Not really. And I don't trust anarchist weirdos getting their hands on public education anymore than I trust Jesus freaks. When serious people--that would be those whose only agenda is to see that young people get educated--propose reforms, I'll listen.
The only thing an anarchist would do with public education is end it.
Right, you want cogs for socialism.
Well, socialism is the correct answer. Anyone that passed 9th grade knows that. Duh.
Re: Tony,
Putting aside your inaccurate idea of capitalism, the point is that schools don't prepare children for many things in life that are important.
Don't you have some illegals to fellate?
Re: Reality,
Only after you've done yours.
Why would anyone care what you think?
Ask Mark Zuckerberg.
I think this is a pretty good decision to put more money in education than to waste money on military sector.
Never! I mean why it should be? I've received an article from ca.Paperell about the ways of education developing. IMHO I cannot agree with this Brayan.
Do you have any idea on how to start a persuasive essay about our modern education system? I would be very grateful for a clue.