Maybe 2016 Will Be the Year Voters Elect an Openly Gay Republican to Congress
Sheriff Paul Babeu wins primary, focusing heavily on border fears.


In 2014 America came so close to electing an openly gay Republican to Congress. Two candidates on opposite sides of the country, Carl DeMaio in California and Richard Tisei in Massachusetts, landed their party's nominations, but lost in the general election.
It's a trend worth noting because a success here serves as an indicator of Republicans and conservatives further turning away from an attitude that there's something bad or wrong about being gay and a push away from government policies that are influenced by sexual orientation. Also, Tisei and DeMaio both had some libertarian-friendly positions in their platforms (DeMaio had previously worked with the Reason Foundation as an independent contractor on pension reform).
As of Tuesday night's Arizona primary, we now have Paul Babeu, the Republican sheriff of Pinal County in Arizona. He won last night's primary and will be facing Tom O'Halleran, a Democrat and a former Chicago police officer, to replace Ann Kirkpatrick as the representative for Arizona's 1st District. Kirkpatrick, a Democrat, is challenging Sen. John McCain for his seat in November.
If elected, Babeu would not be the first gay Republican to serve in Congress. Steve Gunderson of Wisconsin and Jim Kolbe, also of Arizona, both came out of the closet while serving. Babeu would be the first to actually be elected as an openly gay man. Kolbe, incidentally, has endorsed Babeu.
As a candidate, Babeu is a bit of a mixed bag for libertarians. He is a hardcore border security and control advocate and is very vocal about saying America has "complete lawlessness" on immigration enforcement. He holds President Barack Obama responsible for any crimes committed by illegal immigrants within the United States.
He's also a hardcore drug warrior and promotes on his campaign site the fact that his sheriff's office was responsible for the largest drug bust in Arizona history. These two positions appear intertwined. In May he warned hikers and campers to be wary of "Mexican drug assassins" operating his county. When Vice News investigated, they couldn't find much evidence that there was a serious problem.
On the other hand, much of his economic platforms are pro-innovation and pro-freedom. He's against the Enivornmental Protection Agency's and the Obama administration's meddling in coal power operations, but also supports the development of renewable energy. He's very critical of EPA regulatory overreach, which is a hot-button issue in a state like Arizona with a lot of federal land. He's pro-gun rights, and anti-Common Core.
Babeu's public coming out story is also tied to his strong immigration positions due to an odd scandal from 2012, the first time he attempted to run for Congress. He came out of the closet publicly following accusations from an ex-lover who also happened to be an illegal immigrant from Mexico, claiming he was threatened with deportation after the relationship turned sour. An investigation by Arizona's Attorney General's office cleared Babeu of any wrongdoing, but he nevertheless dropped out of the race for Congress. This will be his second attempt, and it appears as though he's going to be heavily focused on getting out votes on the basis of immigration, energy, and local control issues.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Worrying about how many openly gay politicians we have is a tempest in a French Press.
Scott avoids the question everyone is wondering.. would you?
No message from Crusty, so that means "would".
"Carl DeMaio in California and Richard Tisei in Massachusetts, landed their party's nominations, but lost in the general election."
Let the record show that the Republicans wanted them in Congress, but the homophobic Democrat voters in the general election kept them out.
eh so what, politicians are the sort that will visit the park bathrooms at night anyway while thinking they arn't cheating on their wife.
Sorta like how Utah is the top consumer of porn per population, even though they are the most conservative. All these 'family values' politicians are probably getting some on the side by guys and girls...
"Wide stance in airport bathroom" = career ending scandal for a Republican.
"Boyfriend running escort service" = meh for a Democrat (Barney Frank)
True. The sooner the GOP grows up on the gay stuff, the sooner their politicians will be able to get away with stuff that shouldn't have been an issue in the first place.
It's a good thing for double standards, otherwise you wouldn't have any standards at all.
Ewwwwwwwwwwwww a gay politician.
What's your opinion on conversion therapy for politicians?
Let's leave Gabby Giffords out of this, shall we?
How can't you support converting them into non-politicians?
THAT'S WHAT I'M ASKING!11!!!1!
Would converting them to fertilizer count?
Drug warriors cannot be small government. They are now incongruous positions. I don't want him to win. I don't want his opponent to win, either.
They have always been incongruous positions. You can't have a drugwar without widespread invasion of privacy and that requires ubiquitous police and snooping and narcs.
Why can't we make politics more like T-Ball where no score is kept and everyone wins?
Politics is t-ball.
The politicians are the batters, and the citizens are what sits on top of the tee.
He's very critical of EPA regulatory overreach, which is a hot-button issue in a state like Arizona with a lot of federal land. He's pro-gun rights, and anti-Common Core.
Jesus, just come out and call him Donald Trump already!
Scott on alt-text:
How long before the AZ Sheriff's office goes full Tom-of-Finland?
I came to compliment the Love Shack's alt-test, as well.
+1 Red roof. Rusted.
Ack, alt-text, not test.
I haz a John.
Really, gays were the minority scapegoat du jour for the 2004 election cycle. If anything Republicans are a decade late to finally dropping and losing interest in that particular chew toy. The minority scapegoats this season are Mexicans. (Black, as we know, is always in style.)
Honest question: does it bug you when people who theoretically are supposed to be on "your side", politically, shill for the other team?
Are you talking about gay Republicans?
Yes. Particularly a fellow like this, hardcore anti-immigration and drug warrior.
I've spent a little time in DC. You can't toss a floppy dildo without hitting a closeted Republican. Gays can have dumbass political beliefs too.
And only two years later the GOP had an openly gay candidate running in an LA congressional district. I happened to know the treasurer(?) of his campaign.
Babeu is a drug warrior and of course he's for illegal immigration for the same reason - to abuse and exploit the most vulnerable. Total scum.
Total scum.
You would know...
Why do you hate me, kb? What have I ever done to you? Do I not put enough youtube links in my comments? Well, you don't either.
Hitler's never done anything to me either, but he's still total scum. Like you, but not quite as bad.
So what, we've already had a gay President.
Too bad he was waaaay too into whips and chains.
He is a hardcore border security and control advocate and is very vocal about saying America has "complete lawlessness" on immigration enforcement.
He's not wrong. Whether or not the law is bullshit, it's also not enforced in good faith by the executive branch.
A "token" gay. How interesting.