23andMe Gene Test Banned by FDA Is Now Available in the U.K.

A little more than year ago, the genotype screening test offered to consumers by 23andMe was banned by the FDA on wholly specious grounds. As a long-time customer I was happy to get some test results indicating some genetic disease risks and possible reactions to medications. For example, my 23andMe results tell me that I have gene variants that suggest that I have an elevated risk for Type 1 diabetes and that I am at lower risk for Alzheimer's disease. Also, some variants suggest that I am a rapid metabolizer of proton pump inhibitors used to treat heart burn.
As it happens I am not at all diabetic (with rock solid glucose test results to prove it). I also did not suffer heart palpitations upon learning that I carry alleles that indicate a higher risk for developing atrial fibrillation.
In its banning letter, the FDA cited not a single example of harm stemming from 23andMe's tests.
Now the company is evidently being permitted to sell its services and offer its health risks test results to the good folk of Great Britain. From the Guardian:
Genetic testing company 23andMe is launching its personal genome service in the UK after it was banned in the US.
The service allows people to send their saliva in a testing kit to have their DNA screened for genes associated with certain inherited conditions, such as cystic fibrosis or sickle cell anaemia, and other genetic markers relating to parts of their lives and ancestry.
"We can take complicated genetic information and distill it in language that people can actually understand," the 23andMe chief executive Anne Wojcicki said.
"The genome is fascinating, and it's the most exciting scientific revolution of our lifetime. The goal is to keep people engaged with their own genome, so that they know what it means for them and then keep them abreast of the scientific discoveries as they unfold."
The spit kits cost £125 and are sent to the Netherlands before testing in the US. The results, which take approximately six to eight weeks, allow users to both browse the raw code of their genome and use tools to investigate their genetic makeup.
Will some Americans try buying the service from the U.K. now?
In any case, 23andMe will still send you the raw results of your tests that can then be loaded into Promethease for $5 and the system will put together a pretty readable personal DNA report based on the scientific literature cited in SNPedia.
In fact, if you are having a lazy afternoon, click on over to SNPedia where I have put my gene testing results up for anyone to browse through.
Reason is your voice in debates about politics, culture, and ideas. Our annual Webathon is underway and your tax-deductible gift will help us fight against big government, crony capitalism, the drug war, and so much more. For details on giving levels and swag, go here now.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
*browses posted genome...*
BAILEY IS A CYLON?!?!
I thought the whole point of that stupid ending is that everyone's a Cylon, EVEN YOU, SWISS SERVATOR.
I quit watching after season 2.
Can't they just put a "For entertainment purposes only *wink wink*" disclaimer on the results?
They could have maybe done that from the beginning, but after having marketed it as a bona fide scientific analysis it was hard to backtrack.
I was watching this documentary called Your Inner Fish, or something like that, and they showed this experiment with a monkey whose species is genetically colorblind that they added a couple of genes to and now he's not colorblind. I'm sorry, we can cure colorblindness? I'm confused why people remain colorblind.
Because we're better than you! Keep your accurate colors, we have immunity to camouflage, we're not allowed to fly aircraft, and we appreciate black and white films more!
How lacking in perception you are.
There's nothing wrong with my depth perception, you proper-color-viewing bigot! I'm so sick of your condescension! I'm going to go look at a rainbow and have a lot of trouble seeing the indigo!
Do people wearing certain colors just pop up out of nowhere for you?
What part of "immune to camouflage" don't you understand?
(All jokes aside, we are. They used to use color blind people in WWII to spot camouflage covered equipment and encampments from airplanes.)
You've revealed a weakness that I intend to exploit. You know, like Khan's two-dimensional thingee.
If you want to get me, you're going to have to sink to my level. You hear that, ProL? If you want me, you're going to have to come down here!
" You know, like Khan's two-dimensional thingee."
I guess that explains why he was so pissed in that movie.
(All jokes aside, we are. They used to use color blind people in WWII to spot camouflage covered equipment and encampments from airplanes.)
They also used psychics for 'remote viewing and Jonathan Gruber to help craft Obamacare.
Excellent riposte. You can be my Spock in my war with Khanepisiarch.
By mantis shrimp standards, we're all horribly color blind. I want mantis shrimp eyes.
I want pistol shrimp claws so I can make people's heads explode.
I can see in the dark energy band.
"23andMe Gene Test Banned by FDA Is Now Available in the U.K."
So far they have all tested positive for the notorious 'horrible teeth gene'.
If the English are more open to freedom than you, you're doing it wrong.
*nods slowly*
True although stupid medical bans in the UK come about half from the UK and half from the EU.
The FDA continues kicking and screaming down the road into irrelevance.
I'm sure once genetic testing is more refined it will become compulsory.
SIV: Shush! The FDA bureaucrats might hear you!
Gattaca was not an instruction manual.
Gattaca! Gattaca!
*narrows gaze*
We can't have people going around saving lives without permission, can we? What are you, some sort of radical anti-roads anarchist?
Looks like the webathon is only at about 40k so far. I'm not going to donate, but I'll film myself pouring ice water over my head and post it on the internet. That's pretty much the same thing, right? Think it'll help?
Don't be a pussy.
This is how you dump a bucket of cold stuff on your head.
23andme is also available in Canada.
Why? Wouldn't a genetic test show you what everyone already knows: You're Canadian. 'Nuff said.
Hey, we still have to learn how many of us are resistant to polio.
The U.S. House passed a $577.1 billion measure rejecting Defense Department efforts to cut military costs. The legislation would let the A-10 aircraft of the Cold War era keep flying and continue purchases of radar-jamming jets made by Boeing Co. (BA)
The bill passed the House today, 300-119, without any changes. The Senate probably will follow suit next week. The annual defense policy bill sets military policy and spending targets for fiscal 2015, which started Oct. 1.
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/.....-cuts.html
GOP = small government? Hilarious.
Hey, I've got an idea! Why don't you post a snark about Republicans on a libertarian blog, and then expect libertarians to defend the Republicans! Brilliant!
derp
The legislation would authorize $577.1 billion in budget authority for national defense programs, down from $625.1 billion in the previous year, reflecting continued reductions in core defense spending and a decline in funds dedicated to the war in Afghanistan.
Wait what? Gillespie should write an article or something about how we've all been fooled!
Type I diabetes is genetic, but probably requires some sort of triggering event, like fever, disease, car accident, physical trauma, etc. Without that trigger, the immune system doesn't start down the path. It's possible to contract true Type I as an adult, or to contract less common variants that are sometimes misdiagnosed as Type I.
Note also that Type II has a stronger genetic basis than Type I, since it generally manifests without the need to trigger the faulty immune response. Twin concordance studies find far higher genetic propensity for Type II than Type I, even though Type II is popularly misconstrued as a lifestyle disease.