Obamacare

Six Months Later, Kathleen Sebelius Is Resigning Because of Shitty Obamacare Rollout

|

For months critics of Obamacare's disastrous October rollout insisted President Obama show he was serious about holding his underlings accountable by firing someone for messing up. He didn't. But now, six month later, Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius has submitted her resignation. She cited Obamacare's roll-out as the reason, displaying what it means to "move at the speed of government."

Although Sebelius' departure removes one prominent target for Obamacare critics, Reason's Peter Suderman notes it's not all, or not just, her fault:

Maybe—probably—Sebelius doesn't deserve all or even the majority of the blame for the administration's health law screw-ups. But regardless of her impact, as the most visible official associated with the law aside from President Obama, she deserved to be shown the door—or at least be given the opportunity to show herself out.  Suderman notes that Sebelius was merely the face or "front person" for Obamacare, and while she may have been its "worst flack," others are to blame for the Obamacare disaster too. Most of them have escaped accountability. For example one official largely responsible for the administrative effort related to Obamacare was able to quietly leave for a cushy lobbying job in January.

Over at Time magazine, meanwhile, Reason's Nick Gillespie explains how Sebelius' incompetence helped fuel mistrust of government and skepticism about how much power it should wield. Sebelius famously compared her efforts to launch Obamacare to Apple's product launches. Despite the federal government spending more than $667 million on the design and implementation of Obamacare Sebelius claimed she had fewer resources than Apple for the Obamacare launch. Gillespie concludes:

Sebelius's abrupt resignation, then, is the fitting capstone of a cabinet tenure that did nothing to inspire feelings of competency and trust in government in a century that is so far replete with revelations of bipartisan secret surveillance, financial mismanagement of the nation, and failed foreign policy.

We deserved better than Kathleen Sebelius. And we should demand more from our public officials with the same vigor we do when buying, say, Apple products. Gillespie also flagged the reaction of Ezra Klein, the columnist who is now heading Vox.com, an effort at non-ideological "deep journalism." Here's Klein's explanation of why Sebelius, who said she was resigning because of the botched Obamacare rollout, actually resigned:

Obamacare has won. And that's why Secretary of Health and Human Services Kathleen Sebelius can resign…

The evidence has piled up in recent weeks that the strategy worked. Obamacare's first year, despite a truly horrific start, was a success. More than 7 million people look to have signed up for health insurance through the exchanges. Millions more have signed up through Medicaid. And millions beyond that have signed up for insurance through their employers.

Healthcare.gov isn't perfect, but it works. We don't yet know how many young people signed up in March, but it's clear that there are enough of them to keep premiums stable in 2015. It's clear that insurers are going to stick with the program in 2015, and compete hard to sign up next year's wave of young, healthy applicants. The White House's announcement on who would replace Sebelius, Suderman noted, was also a veiled criticism of the outgoing health secretary:

Even the statement by White House Chief of Staff Denis McDonough on her replacement, current Office of Management and Budget Chief Syliva Burwell, sounds more like a knife in the back than a fond farewell. "The president wants to make sure we have a proven manager and relentless implementer in the job over there, which is why he is going to nominate Sylvia," McDonough said on Thursday.

The clear implication here is that Sebelius was none of those things. And certainly, judging by last October's botched launch of the federal health insurance exchange, it's an easy and obvious judgment to make about her work for the administration. The Wall Street Journal calls Burwell "one of the most experiences officials in Obama's White House" and reports that she's spent the last several months as budget office chief "trying to slowly repair frayed relations between the White House and congressional Republicans on tax and spending policy."

Advertisement

NEXT: Vid: From Guns to Pastries—How 3D Printing Will Change the Way We Make Practically Everything

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. “Obamacare has won.”

    Translated:
    ‘We pushed those goal posts over to near the football and we’re calling that a score!’

    1. It reminds me somewhat of parents negotiating with toddlers over how many “bites” of vegetables they have to eat.

    2. Actually, I think this is an early method of dealing with the fact they do not in fact have 7 million enrollments. Sebilius would have to explain why she lied a few months from now when the reality of the Obamacare numbers continue to come to light. The next Sec of Health can just say “That was Kathleen’s number, no idea where it came from, but let’s spend a couple billion more to fix this important program…for the children and shit.”

    3. The only thing “deep” about Ezra Klein’s journalism at Vox.com is the bullshit.

  2. “Even though we won the world series, the team’s record in the month of April was 10 and 20, so we have to fire the coach.”

      1. I must say, I am surprised that Ezra was this quick to go full partisan on his new site. Seems like that is not a good business decision. Or maybe it is; stake your ideological territory sooner rather than later.

        The water carrying for ACA is truly on a scale I have never seen before.

        1. You don’t understand. Ezra is “non-ideological” now.

  3. “Obamacare has won.”

    I hadn’t realized it was a competition.

    Take that and that…and that and that…stoopid people who lost their insurance that was shitty in the first place.

    1. “I hadn’t realized it was a competition.”

      Yeah, Obo and Sebilius decided to play Calvinball and we got to pay for it.

  4. “‘The president wants to make sure we have a proven manager and relentless implementer in the job over there, which is why he is going to nominate Sylvia,’ McDonough said on Thursday.

    The clear implication here is that Sebelius was none of those things.”

    It certainly is a shame that such an unqualified person was put in charge of implementing President Obama’s Big Fucking Deal. I wonder who gave Kathleen Sebelius that job.

  5. We deserved better than Kathleen Sebelius.

    We live in a world where not giving is taking, taxation isn’t considered theft and special costumes place you in separate moral category with legal privileges.

    No Nick, the vast majority people get the HHS Secretary they deserve, if anyone deserves an overlord at all.

    1. Sebelius: You either die a hero, or you live long enough to see yourself become the villain.” I can do those things, because I’m not a hero, not like Obama. I botched the rollout, that’s what I can be.

      Carney: No, you can’t! You’re not!

      Sebelius: I’m whatever America needs me to be. Call it in.

      McDunno: They’ll hunt you.

      Sebelius: You’ll hunt me. You’ll condemn me, set the dogs on me.

      Because that’s what needs to happen. Because sometimes… the truth isn’t good enough. Sometimes people deserve more. Sometimes people deserve to have their faith rewarded.

      Carney: Sebelius? Sebelius! Why is she running, Denis?

      McDunno: Because we have to chase her.

      Carney: She didn’t do anything wrong.

      McDunno: Because she’s the hero America deserves, but not the one it needs right now. So, we’ll hunt her, because she can take it. Because she’s not our hero. She’s a silent guardian. A watchful protector. A Dark Knight.

  6. “Healthcare.gov isn’t perfect, but it works. We don’t yet know how many young people signed up in March, but it’s clear that there are enough of them to keep premiums stable in 2015. It’s clear that insurers are going to stick with the program in 2015, and compete hard to sign up next year’s wave of young, healthy applicants.” Yeah… it could be better. urgent care north las vegas

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.