Midnight in Myanmar
A few news outlets and some friends from Yangon say Suu Kyi has been moved from her home, where she was under house arrest, to the notorious Insein prison. Insein is the favored metaphor for a country run like a cell block, and Suu Kyi is obviously Myanmar's most revered celebrity.
The explanation for the regime's hesitance to respond to the protests until today had been China's influence; China was supposedly preventing an ally and neighbor from causing regional embarrassment prior to the Olympics. This was indirectly a way to claim the West held some moral suasion in its ability to blame China for the behavior of Burmese generals. But that storyline ignored most of Myanmar's recent history: The generals now in power have never actually shown themselves much vulnerable to pressure from the outside, even when that pressure comes from the few friends they have.
This story has replayed itself consistently over the past five years, through many supposedly imminent freeings of Suu Kyi, the capital city's move north, the sham constitutional convention: Policy experts ascribe some action or failure to act on the part of the junta to international or regional pressure, and the junta then acts contrary to expectations, apparently unperturbed by its reputation as a brutal dictatorship. It seems extremely difficult for outsiders to acknowledge that they cannot influence the actions of a few secretive Burmese thugs.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Which leads to two questions:
Who do they think they are fooling?
Who are they trying to fool in the first place?
Insein indeed.
it's the stopover point after One Night In Bangkok.
Does anyone really refer to the country as "Myanmar," beyond the military junta and journalists?
Confused Reasonoids?
Just think of Ted Haggard and Bill Donahue and Pat Robertson marching demanding the United States Government introduce price-controls on gasoline.
This is very sad news. Perhaps the monk marches represent the begining of a real revolution. In the mean time, clearly the thing to do is to invite the generals in charge over there to give a speech at Columbia so the President Bollinger can give them a stern talking to about their behavior.
Call it Burma. That's it's name.
Call it Burma. That's it's name.
That would be "its," not "it's." There is a difference.
I have met one person from there, and he called it Burma. Thus I call it Burma.
(Luckily he got out of there and is studying violin in Austria.)
Remember when this Burmese Radical was agitating against intellectual property rights?
This could all be solved if they staged a jello wrestling match between Suu Kyi and Kerry Howley.
Who could fight when that's going on?
I've been using Myanmar because I've been talking to Burmese friends, and they--like everyone outside the UK and US--are using "Myanmar." I usually switch back and forth; it's not meant as a political statement on my part. In Burma I would have said "Myanma," the Burmese word everyone--including the NLD--accepts.
the junta then acts contrary to expectations.
Is there anyone who expects anything from the junta other than brutal oppression? The monks taking to the streets is inspiring. It shows a lot of courage from a lot of people. But they should know the risk they're taking. The junta has shown itself to be less tolerant of political dissent than the Chinese for instance. Another case of protest evaporating when the bullets start flying. If everyone taking to the streets of Burma this time around isn't prepared to stop a bullet they should have never walked out their front door to begin with. We know it is going to come to that.
refer it to assumption of risk. Volunteer non fit injuria
Just think of Ted Haggard and Bill Donahue and Pat Robertson marching demanding the United States Government introduce price-controls on gasoline.
You call yourself a troll. If you had real skillz you'd be hittin' us with the Burma/Selma connection, where religious leaders were leading protests for better public transportation. Get your head in the game.
Just think of Ted Haggard and Bill Donahue and Pat Robertson marching demanding the United States Government introduce price-controls on gasoline.
I see nothing wrong with the named individuals exercising their 1st ammendment rights to influence the direction of the US government.
Of course, I would disagree entirely with the sentiment, but they would be well within their rights to seek what you suggest they seek.
The junta has shown itself to be less tolerant of political dissent than the Chinese for instance. Another case of protest evaporating when the bullets start flying.
And yet, Warren, repressive, evil regimes have been toppled from within. We can only hope and root. For you theists, hope and pray.
Burma.
Its capital city is Rangoon.
Anyone who disputes these facts supports the murderous regime which currently abuses Rangoon, Burma.
Rangoon, Burma.
Just call BURMA.
As, a Burmese I think it is inappropriate to call Myanamr.
Rangoon, Burma not Yangon, Mynamar.
Let's not go abroad seeking monsters...
But anyway, regimes like the one in Myanmar flourish in isolation. We should be threatening them with a free trade agreement, not sanctions.
Kerry:
actually shown themselves much vulnerable
I think you mean "much less vulnerable," but I'm not sure.
Does anyone really refer to the country as "Myanmar," beyond the military junta and journalists?
Yes, my weird liberal friends.
First Pepperpot: Burma!
Second Pepperpot: Why did you say Burma?
First Pepperpot: I panicked.
tee
right on!
Rangoon, Burma!
Are Burmaese allowed to buy a gun like here in America?(except DC, New Jersey, Mass. and Illoinois)
What kind of monks are these? Certainly not Kung Fu monks or they would've kicked ass by now.
Policy experts ascribe some action or failure to act on the part of the junta to international or regional pressure, and the junta then acts contrary to expectations... It seems extremely difficult for outsiders to acknowledge that they cannot influence the actions of a few secretive Burmese thugs.
Or worse - the junta acts contrary to expectations to prove they will not be influenced by outsiders.
Does anyone know were to find this poem or speech that goes something like" were will they find the feet to trample us down if not from us...etc." It's about how the powers that be can't control us unless some of us become the stormtroopers.
Suu Kyi Suu Kyi, five dolla?
Yes, I'd like to send this letter to the Prussian consulate in Siam by aeromail. Am I too late for the 4:30 autogyro?
de stijl, I'm afraid the 4:30 autogyro has left. Perhaps you could "transmit" your letter by "wireless"? It works via the promulgation of electrical waves through the aether. It's the latest thing. I think that Edison chap had something to do with it.
Someday this marvelous invention will transform the earth into a kind of "global village," make it as easy to communicate between Rhodesia and Formosa as between next-door neighbors!
Is your wondrous "wireless" set available for transmissions to Peking?