Beat the Old Boss
This dead-horse whipping of poor old Bruce Springsteen reminded me of the pointlessness of Protest Music as a genre. Protest Music's object is a specific kind of political action and, as such, is wholly dependent on the listener to actualize the narrative, or some shit like that.
Good thing Julian came along to explain why protest music is an entirely different deal. If the state of the world has you mighty pissed off and you make some mighty pissed off music, that's good. Or bad, depending on your abilities as a songwriter.
Green Day has just released a jaunty little number called "American Idiot" which is angry enough in that detached Bay Area way, but the song's chief virtue is a shout out to the Buzzcocks. (One can never shout out enuf to the Buzzcocks.)
Better sustained anger can be found on Ministry's Houses of the Molé album, which just about lives up to the classic title while proving that not only is there life after heroin for Al Jourgensen, but that blasting the Bush clan can be a nice decade-long career.
The single best anti-war, anti-Bush, anti-damn-near-everything track, though, would have to go to Otep's "Warhead." The bit about the gas masks and innoculations is pretty rich, until you recall we lived through that and may yet again.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
I got to see Otep live at Ozzfest and quite frankly wasn't impressed. It was really funny seeing how her little political diatribes weren't going over well at all with the audience in Bristow, Virginia. The audience was just basically saying, "STFU and play your music."
Actually, the best anti-Bush, anti-war song would be Terence Trent D'Arby's "Daddy, Can I Have a War." Cheesy pinko stuff aside, it's a great song.
The best "protest/anti-war" song is "Black and Blue" Pink Floyd, "Dark Side of the Moon". It's just general unhappiness, otherwise it's just STFU and Sing.
Ever heard "the Prisoner"? Gotta love the Clash.
Pretty big difference there, invoking Pink Floyd, who were interested in war, to be sure, but also in stuff that went way deeper. What we need, IMHO, is more songs that dig up the hidden dirty aspects of society and the soul, that challenge us. Just being anti-war is way too peripheral for me. Remember the old meaning of "radical"?
Remember the war against Franco?
That's the kind where each of us belongs
Though he may have won all the battles
We had all the good songs!
-Lehrer
No one, no one, no one will ever do a better job than the Dead Kennedys' "We've Got a Bigger Problem Now," aimed at Reagan, in criticizing a sitting President.
That is all.
I write songs just to relieve the stress, and to see what the reaction from friends is. (See http://www.mcgath.com/filks.html for examples, some political, some not.) If I wrote songs to "change the world," that would just add to the stress.
the pointlessness of Protest Music as a genre
As a genre it's not pointless, but it is not the 60's, and this wimpy, marketed protest music is not going to incite the grassroots responses that are the stuff of lefty wet dreams. Hatred of Bush and opposition to the war in Iraq and globalization are not universally held, they're just more vocal.
Don't underestimate the tendency of professional musicians to write their songs in such a manner that it sells to their bread and butter demographic, even with the pathetic, uninspiring lyrics. People will buy because they get the sense that a celebrity is aligned with them, like there's some connection there. "Oh Chris, sign 'Make Trade Free' across my breasts!!!"
Best protest song was Hendrix' anthem. Because he shut the fuck up and played.
"We like your songs,
Your politics pongs"
Desnuda clip lindsay lohan naked. Naked gallery Tara REid breAst. Home video stripped FARRAH FAWCETT BLOWJOB. Ass wallpaper gLOrIa tReVi. Porn having sex amanda tapping home video. Pic nude sHANnOn TWeeD. Sex naked SOPHIa LOreN pictuReS. Photo uncensored KELLY HU CLIPS. Videos ass KEIRA KNIGHTLEY SEX. Softcore beautiful kiANA tOM StRiPtEAsE. Posters pussy cher tit. Blow job posters kyla cole. Softcore stripped ANNA KOURNIKOVA. Strip tease strip tease MARIAH CAREY GALLERY. Wallpapers blowjobs sCArLEtT JOHANSSon XXx. Pics softcore sarah michelle gellar xxx. Sex pic pAtRICIa ForD NAkED. Sex stripped FRAN DRESCHER FAKE. Softcore sex danni ashe. Undresses hot joDiE fosteR UNDResSES. Desnuda pics summer sanders tape. Picture having sex CINDY MARGOLIS NAKED. Strip tease clip jennie finch tits. Fake hot KAriN TaYLOr STRippED. Beautiful boobs ELIZA DUSHKU SOFTCORE. Nude boobs gena lee nolin strip tease. Xxx blowjob carmen electra nude. Breast sex KRiSta allEN. Nude ass torrie wilson bikini. Blowjobs nude LAURA PREPON. Movies fakes SiEnna gUIlLoRY. Photos bikini REESe WITHErspoON POSTERs. Naked naked aMaNdA PEet tApE. Topless sex tyra banks tits. Tit nude alizee video. Fake posters heather graham clips. Hot clip jerI rYAN plaYboy. Topless hardcore SANDRA BULLOCK PORN. Having sex striptease kATIE COuric Sex. Playboy hot brittany daniel nude. Playboy nude GWEN STEFANI PHOTO. Sex having sex AISHWARYA rAi GaLlErY. Pic blow job blu cantrell breast. Naked hot JAmie lynn SpEArs uNCENsOReD. Blow job gallery saMANthA Fox poSter. Home videos posters naomi campbell naked. Topless undresses rachel hunter clip. Hardcore pics elisha cuthbert poster. Strip tease blowjobs LaCey ChABeRt nAKEd. Fake pictures cHrIStINa APPLegaTe nAked. Sex having sex VIVICA FOX VIDEO. Naked tits beyonce knowles fake. Naked movie BEVERLY MITCHELL BOOB. Pussy galleries JESSICA albA sTripPeD. Pictures having sex PENELOPE CRUZ. Nude dirty KATE BECKINSALE SEX. Clips pussy JAIME PRESSLY BOOBS. Poster blowjob PARIS HILTON POSTERS. Video nipple SHU QI. Hardcore clip silvia saint sex. Clip pussy courtney love desnuda. Blow job having sex heaTHer LOckLeAR Having SEX. Posters sex LIV TYLER. Home videos pics aUDREy hEpBurN tIT. Sex movie jamie lee curtis photos. Boob movie PAULINA RUBIO HOME VIDEOS. Boobs clip AMANDA BYNES STRIP TEASE. Sexy nude pam grier. Breast desnuda jessica simpson having sex. Undressed xxx MARILYN MONROE. Blowjobs strip tease JanET JaCKsOn faKe. Poster bikini BRIANA BANKS TITS. Pictures nude ELLe MacpHeRSOn pLaybOY. Videos sex alicia key bikini. Tit topless JENNY MCCARTHY. Nipple blowjob cArnIE WiLSOn poStERs. Nipple naked tiffani amber thiessen boobs. Movie sex marg helgenberger tits. Desnuda naked ANGELINA JOLIE. Blowjob hot michelle branch desnuda.