Modern Problems
Reader Honest assures us that s/he is no conspiracy theorist, but that this story of the 9/11 air traffic controllers' taped statements seems mighty suspicious. Six controllers taped their recollections immediately after the attack, but one Kevin Delaney, a manager at the New York Air Route Traffic Control Center in Ronkonkoma, N.Y., destroyed the tape a few months later, without turning it over to authorities. A detail in the Reuters story suggests the destruction of the tape (which naturally was "of minimal value" to the 9/11 investigation) may have been a strongman stunt by Delaney that got out of hand:
[Delaney] destroyed the tape months after it was made. He crushed the single audiocassette in his hand, cut the recording strands into small pieces and threw the debris into different trash cans at the center, [Transportation Department Inspector General Kenneth] Mead said.
Mead finds Delaney and center manager Mike McCormick misconstrued an FAA directive from headquarters to save all data related to the attack, though a quotation from that directive ("If a question arises whether or not you should retain data, RETAIN IT") leads this reasonable observer to wonder what there was to misconstrue.
At the risk of searching for the inevitable Reason angle in this story, it's notable that McCormick apparently withheld the tape because he'd agreed with the air controllers union to destroy it once a transcript had been made. Tempting though it is to bring Ronald Reagan out of mothballs to crush that union all over again, the manager in fact went beyond his agreement by not even making the transcript.
But rest easy, America: McCormick is now in Iraq, working for the FAA to set up an air traffic control center.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
It was rather heavy handed to stomp on the tape, but really, they sent in written accounts that became the official record later. Ever been in a crisis and discussed the details immediately afterwards? You end up with a bunch of confused, muddled accounts most of the time. Then again, details are best recorded while fresh. In any case, it just sounds like standard CYA stuff.
Maybe McCormick was having a bad hair day.
It happens, you know.
5 to 10 in Leavenworth will teach him to disregard the law.
Once Civil Servants decide that their convenience is the reason their job was made, the public is lost.
They “misconstrued” a directive? This is a surprise? These are the folks who keep you from carrying tweezers on board an aircraft.
Is this some sort of joke, or is it a set of links conveniently brought by a regular poster to satisfy H&R’s seemingly infinite need for pr0n?
Really Cool Blog, Thank you for such a wonderful job.
Singapore Singapore 1 Singapore 2 Singapore 3 Singapore 4 Thailand Thailand 1 Thailand 2 Thailand 3 Thailand 4 Japan Japan 1 Japan 2 Japan 3 Japan 4 Hong Kong Hong Kong 1 Hong Kong 2 Hong Kong 3 Malaysia Malaysia 1 Malaysia 2 Malaysia 3 Taiwan Taiwan 1 Taiwan 2
East Asia Hotels East Asia Guide Euro Asia Hotels Come to Asia Hotels plus Tours My Europe Hotels
Hotels in London Paris Hotels Rome Hotels Athens Hotels Hotels in Istanbul Barcelona Hotels Munich Hotels Cannes Hotels Madrid Hotels Oslo Hotels Budapest Hotels Lisbon Hotels Amsterdam Hotels Athens Hotels Barcelona Hotels Paris Hotels Istanbul Hotels Madrid Hotels Rome Hotels Milan Hotels Munich Hotels Oslo Hotels Budapest Hotels London Hotels Lisbon Hotels Santorini Hotels Shanghai Hotels Hotels in Thailand Hotels in Bangkok Chiang Mai Hotels Hotels in Pattaya Phuket Hotels Hong Kong Hotels Hong Kong Island Kowloon Hotels New Territories Hotels Outlying Island Hotels China Hotels Beijing Hotels Shanghai Hotels Guangzhou Hotels Guilin Hotels Tianjin Hotels Xian Hotels Japan Hotels Chubu Hotels Chugoku Hotels Hokkaido Hotels Kanto Hotels Okinawa Hotels Shikoku Hotels Tokyo Hotels Singapore Hotels Chinatown Area Hotels Eastcoast Area Hotels Little India Hotels Marina Bay Hotels Orchard Road Hotels Sentosa Island Hotels Malaysia Hotels Northern Region Hotels Eastern Region Hotels Kuala Lumpur Hotels Southern Region Hotels Sarawak Hotels Penang Hotels
Discount Singapore Hotels Singapore Hotels Singapore Hotels Discount Singapore Hotels Online Sentosa Hotels Singapore Thailand Hotels Bangkok Hotels Pattaya Hotels Phuket Hotels Chiang Mai Hotels Japan Hotels Tokyo Hotels Kobe Hotels Osaka Hotels Okinawa Hotels Hong Kong Hotels Discount Hong Kong Hotels Kowloon Hotels Hong Kong Hotels Online Malaysia Hotels Malaysia Hotel Kuala Lumpur Hotels Penang Hotels Taiwan Hotels Taiwan Hotel Taipei Hotels Indonesia Hotels Bali Hotels ?stanbul Hotels Shanghai Hotels Barcelona Hotels Paris Hotels Amsterdam Hotels London Hotels New York Hotels Discount Bangkok Hotels Discount Kuala Lumpur Hotels Discount New Delhi Hotels Discount Barcelona Discount London Hotels Discount Madrid Hotels Discount Paris Hotels Discount Rome Hotels Discount Jakarta Hotels Discount Singapore Hotels Discount Pattaya Hotels Discount Bali Hotels Discount Athens Hotels Discount Hong Kong Hotels Discount Shanghai Hotels Discount Tokyo Hotels Discount Beijing Hotels Discount Istanbul Hotels