Manliness Is Next to Joblessness

Daily Markets' Mark Perry declares the Great Mancession in session, with help from a mesmerizing time-lapse chart tracking employment growth by job type since 2008.

Click here to watch the real-time shrinking of majority male sectors in opposition to the growth of two majority female sectors -- education and health care. Perry says this chart helps

tell the story of the Great Mancession of 2007-2010 and how men were disproportionately affected by the recessionary conditions that adversely impacted male-dominated industries (construction and manufacturing), while employment in female-dominated industries actually increased throughout the entire recession.  And according to the employment report yesterday, there is still a 2% male-female jobless rate gap of 10.6% for men and 8.6% for women, so the Great Mancession is not yet close to ending.  

Bottom Line: Maybe it’s not such a good time to be man, now that men are on the wrong side of the jobless rate gap by 2%, the wrong side of the college degree gap (142 women graduated from college in 2010 for every 100 men) and now even the wrong side of the wage gap.

Calculated Risk breaks down unemployment by level of education -- another win for the girls, given their  comparative edu-vantage:

Note that employment for Americans with less than a high school diploma is not only scarcer in percentage terms but considerably more volatile. Until August's overall increase in unemployment, high school dropouts were gaining jobs back faster than any of the other groups.

A few months ago, The Atlantic revived the traditional end-of-men story with an article titled "The End of Men." Moribund masculinity has been a favorite crisis dating back at least to Teddy Roosevelt's war on neuresthenia.

But every data set has noise. Take another look at that unemployment-by-sector chart and you'll see about what you'd expect to see following a vast debt-and-spending bubble, during which real estate was heavily leveraged to obtain loans that were then used to buy more stuff. So you see a big rationalization in construction because it's directly dependent on real estate demand; in financial services because of the unwinding of asset-backed securities; and in retail and manufacturing because, without all that fake real estate value to draw on, nobody can afford to buy anything. (And the gender breakdowns [pdf] in some of these fields -- such as retail -- are not as lopsided as the ones in construction and health care.) The job losses tell you less about gender than they do about the misallocation of resources that preceded the bust.

There may be a crisis in American manhood -- though as the late Simon Monjack taught us all, a useless man can always find some dopey girl to take care of him -- but the Great Mancession isn't proof of it. In fact the most disturbing thing in the job sector statistics is that health care jobs have been growing at such an insatiable rate. Are people sicker than they used to be?

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  • Josh||

    1st!!

    A story about MEN on Labor Day. Finally!

  • Hate-filled Feminists||

    Fuck men. Every problem in the world, is YOUR fault. Every one of you fuckers ought to die a horrible, mangled, slow and painful death.

  • STEVE SMITH||

    STEVE SMITH SYMPATHISE WITH WOMEN PLIGHT! STEVE SMITH SUGGEST FEMINISTS COME FOR RAPING CONSCIOUSNESS MEETING IN CAVE!

  • hmm||

    Hate-filled Feminists|9.6.10 @ 11:15PM|#

    Fuck men.

    Huh?

  • A:||

    They meant figuratively speaking, of course.

  • ||

    no they want to literally fuck men with their huge hairy penis'

  • ||

  • unemployed copy-editor||

    Americans with less than a high school diploma

    Surely there's a better way to phrase that.

  • QuietDesperation||

    Americans with less than a high school diploma

    Surely there's a better way to phrase that.

    Losers? :-)

    And don't call me Shirley.

  • Dr. Rumack ||

    I just want to tell you both good luck. We're all counting on you.

  • Steve McCroskey||

    Looks like I picked the wrong week to quit sniffing glue.

  • Captain Oveur||

    Joey, do you like movies about gladiators?

  • Max||

    You stupid fucking libertarians and your Airplane references! People are dying because there aren't enough Democrats in charge! Suck Ron Pual's dick!

  • ||

    That's some piss poor spoofing! C'mon put your back into it!

  • Ron Pual||

    I thought it was good.

  • Rich||

    Americans with less than a high school diploma

    Surely there's a better way to phrase that.

    "Diploma-challenged" Americans?

  • Hugh Akston||

    Americans with less than a high school diploma

    Surely there's a better way to phrase that.

    High school students.

  • ||

    + 1

  • hmm||

    At least he didn't say high school education. Otherwise we would have to include those with at least two years of college in most instances.

  • SIV||

    Tune in
    Turn on
    Drop out

  • M. Simon||

    Correct order:

    Turn on
    Tune in
    Drop out

  • ||

    Shirley got laid off.

  • ||

    Steve Smith got her pregnant.

  • ||

    The obvious solution is that there need to be more male nurses.

    "Matt Stevers, Male Nurse"

  • QuietDesperation||

    More male wet nurses, I say, and more female proctologists. If Obamacare can not deliver unto me monthly prostate exams from a hot, leather clad proctologist, then the terrorists have already won.

    Note: Firefox wants to correct proctologist to paleontologist. Is Mozilla messing with my head?

  • Firey Fox||

    Calling you old is what.

  • ||

    Steve(n) Smith went to school for proctology, you know. It came naturally to him, but he dropped out to pursue his dream of traveling across Europe raping backpackers. Maybe he could don a gimp mask and give you the exam?

  • STEVE SMITH||

    STEVE SMITH LIKE FRENCH WOMEN! STEVE SMITH AND FRENCH WOMEN SHARE GROOMING HABITS! STEVE SMITH MISSES REASON WHILE BACKPACKING! STEVE SMITH SEND POSTCARD!

    STEVE SMITH WISH YOU WERE HERE! SO STEVE SMITH COULD RAPE YOU!

  • Fred Garvin, Male Prostitute||

    Hey is for horses, young lady. No ifs, ands or buts about it - you're spending the night with Fred Garvin, Male Prostitute.

  • ||

    Are people sicker than they used to be?

    What about all those rat-bagging teafuckers?

    Do they count?

  • SFC B||

    They're not people.

  • jtuf||

    P Brooks and SFC B, those are rather hateful things for you to say.

  • QuietDesperation||

    "...real-time shrinking of majority male sectors..."

    Woops. I blinked. Was that subliminal advertising for an erectile dysfunction product? Remember, boys, if you majority male sectors expand for more than four hours, call your procto-atrix.

  • Irrational Hater||

    Apparently men are underemployed (and underpaid) because they don't douche:

    http://adweek.blogs.com/.a/6a0.....1f4970b-pi

    Someone tell Bernanke.

  • Summer's Eve||

    It's got what pussies crave. It's got electrolytes.

  • Bee Tagger||

    Allow me to be the only one appreciative of an Idiocracy reference

  • Jason||

    "Great job in the XXX project."

    LOL

  • ||

    Obama says his critics "talk about him like he is a dog"

    http://www.nytimes.com/2010/09.....amp;ref=us

    WTF? I guess Obama has one last card to play; the agrieved, proud black man.

  • ||

    If i was an insurance company lobbyist after all the goodies Obama gave me with Obamacare i would call him my bitch as well.

  • ||

    I don't see what the point of saying that is. It just makes him look weak and petty. It is not like it is going to convince anyone to agree with him.

  • ||

    Well he has lost the independent voters and won't get them back.

    He is doing it to try to get his base to the polls.

    The demscan be screwed in two ways. One involves the lefty base not going to the polls and the other involves the lefty base going to the polls.

    The one involving the lefty base not going to the polls means he loses the senate and the house rather then just the house.

  • ||

    Also Obama is not Clinton.

    He will not and cannot slither his way to the center. It is not in his character to do it.

    I have a feeling that 2011 and 2012 will destroy the man...that which cannot bend breaks as they say.

  • ||

    Obama has neither the intellectual or political depth to slither to the center. Clinton was slimey. But it is no small feat to be both slimey and believable to all but partisans on the other side. That takes really knowing the issues and which ones to appropriate without alienating your own supporters or appearing to be too unbelievable. That takes knowledge and understanding as well as shamlessness.

    Obama has none of that. He really seems to have gone through his life and never been intellectually challanged. You know that he is the only editor of Harvard Law Review never to have published an article in the publication? He really is a completely shallow human being.

  • Tony||

    Clinton was slimey

    And Bush was a retarde drunke who did his best to destroy the countrie. What a selective snob you are. Obama edited the Harvard Law Review in an insufficient manner! That makes him worse, I gather, than the man who would have failed at community college if not for the nepotism, which allowed him to fail in a consistently spectacular manner from the Ivy League to the presidency.

  • Brandon||

    I think you're drawing the wrong conclusions. Sure, Clinton was slimey. He was still better than Bush or Obama. In fact, I'd say that sliminess was an endearing trait in him.

  • ||

    In fact, I'd say that sliminess was an endearing trait in him.

    In terms of relative results I have to agree.

    Still in no way was it by design. If he had his way he would have been as bad as Obama. The republican house forced his hand.

  • ||

    Hmmm...and instead of taking a high paying corporate job he works for a not for profit.Yeah thats pretty shallow.

    That makes you?

  • MWG||

    "Hmmm...and instead of taking a high paying corporate job he works for a not for profit."

    ...which he leveraged to launch a career in politics. Hardly the benevolent servant.

  • M. Simon||

    "Hmmm...and instead of taking a high paying corporate job he works for a communist not for profit."

    FIFY

  • The RZA||

    Smith Barney? Bunch of bitches!

  • ||

    Also if i was a lobbyist for a wall street bank i would call him my bitch.

    Ditto for the GM union lobby....lobby for the union boss, the workers actually got screwed.

  • Tony||

    Yes John you've always talked about the current president in a measured, detached way.

  • ||

    Off topic:

    here is a video of a guy getting tazered 3 times by cops because he fell down some stairs near his house.

    http://www.ebaumsworld.com/video/watch/81087138/

    No idea how recent this was.

  • Jonathan||

    Does Balko know of this?

  • Nipplemancer||

    he linked it on theagitator

  • hmm||

    It happened at the end of June.

  • hurly buerhle||

    All you need to know about masculinity in 2010 is that the album of the year is from Rufus Wainwright.

    Nothing against Rufus; his music is really lovely. But yeah, Rufus is what kicks ass in 2010.

  • Max||

    Yes, Tim, People--specifically Americans--are sicker than they used to be, and you aren't helping with your steady stream of right-wing drivel.

  • ||

    Hey, no one knows more about streams of drivel than Edward. And streams of urine and diarrhea as well.

  • jtuf||

    Max, I suggest you see a health care professional. Your illness have biological causes. They are not the result of words.

  • Max's Mom||

    Max, honey, did you remember to take your pills? I can't deal with another of your "episodes." I just can't.

  • STEVE SMITH||

    STEVE SMITH CALL BULLSHIT ON MAX! QUALITY OF STEVE SMITH RAPE AND STEVE SMITH FOOD ONLY GET BETTER OVER PAST DECADES! STEVE SMITH NOT GET SICK FROM ILL HIKERS IN LONG TIME! MAX KNOW THIS WHY STEVE SMITH NOT LIKE RAPE MAX! MAX NOT HEALTHY RAPE!

  • Max||

    Which can only be cured with a steady stream of left-wing drivel!

  • Max's Mom||

    Honey, you're having an episode. Come to Mommy's room and play "find the man in the little boat". You'll feel better.

  • National Lampoon Radio Hour Ad||

    "And by the way, you're sleeping with your mother tonight. It's my turn with your sister."

  • Shorter Max||

    derp

  • hmm||

    The Timpocolypse does not abide the holiday day off tradition.

  • jtuf||

    I think the root cause of this trend is female dominated government education. The hand that rocks the cradle rules the World.

  • Fatty Bolger||

    Are people sicker than they used to be?

    No, just older.

  • Paul||

    a useless man can always find some dopey girl to take care of him

    Do tell.

  • hmm||

    It's called getting married and pursuing a PhD.

    MUHAHAHAH She fell for it.

  • Paul||

    In fact the most disturbing thing in the job sector statistics is that health care jobs have been growing at such an insatiable rate. Are people sicker than they used to be?

    Practically everyone I know works in healthcare.

  • hmm||

    Healthcare Bubble?

  • hmm||

    God knows there an artificial inflation of prices.

  • tr0n||

    2 percentage points, Tim. Come on.

  • CBBTOO||

    If men are on "the wrong side of the college degree gap" than it's a very good time to be a man.

  • ||

    Healthcare Bubble?

  • ||

    Hi, allow me invite you to my community:The site named --SugarMommyDate-- (where mature women and men who like cougar find love). Best Cougar dating site in the world! It's where cougars and younger men can meet(Cougar is the slang for woman who is mature, experienced and want to date with a younger man). No matter you are looking for a NSA or serious relationship, please do check it out!And also you may find yourself more compatible with young men. For young men, dating an older woman has numerous advantages. You can sometimes learn valuable advice from her on how to conduct himself in a difficult situation. She is your best listener and supporter.Join us and contact tens of thousands of cougars and cougar admirers!It's where mature women and men who like them can get fvcked.

  • Johnny Longtorso||

    I blame the chemtrails.

  • Joshua||

    I highly recommend Perry's personal blog as well. http://mjperry.blogspot.com/ He's an economics professor at UMich & I think he has some intro Econ classes & he works some simple freedom issues into his blog.

  • ||

    No, people aren't sicker, but the game has changed. Health care is increasingly being taken over by hospitals, and hospitals have created legions of administrators whose goal is to farm numbers for reimbursement. That is, hospitals are reimbursed by code numbers, and if a hospital can get a number "upcoded" to a more lucrative code, it gets more money.

    In addition, hospitals are increasingly making themselves the judge of what a patient needs. By the time a doctor sees a patient, standing "quality of care" orders authorized by nurses, etc. often results in patients being seen by physical therapists, social workers, nutritionists, pharmacists, speech pathologists, respiratory therapists, etc. This is whether or not the patient actually needs to see them.

    Biggest conflict of interest in health care right now is that hospitals are directly employing physicians, making their economic livelihood tied to their employer, and not the patient. Woe is you if you want to try to fight what the hospital has already decided is in their best interest...er, I mean, the patient.

GET REASON MAGAZINE

Get Reason's print or digital edition before it’s posted online

  • Progressive Puritans: From e-cigs to sex classifieds, the once transgressive left wants to criminalize fun.
  • Port Authoritarians: Chris Christie’s Bridgegate scandal
  • The Menace of Secret Government: Obama’s proposed intelligence reforms don’t safeguard civil liberties

SUBSCRIBE

advertisement