Reason.com
Phones and the Fourth
Post-arrest searches
According to a January decision by the California Supreme Court, police can search your mobile phone without a warrant after taking you into custody. Like many blows to the Fourth Amendment, the case involved the victimless crime of drug dealing. In People v. Diaz, the court ruled that police did not violate the rights of Gregory Diaz, a suspected Ecstasy dealer, when they read his text messages.
U.S. Supreme Court precedents such as U.S. v. Robinson (1973) and U.S. v. Edwards (1974) imply that police may search anything on an arrestee's person, both to protect officer safety and to find evidence of a crime. But another precedent, U.S. v. Chadwick (1977), seemed to support Diaz's position that the search of his cell phone required a warrant.
In that case, the Court declared that a search of luggage in the trunk of a suspect's car more than an hour after his arrest was too far removed from his person and the time of the arrest to be legally valid. By contrast, the majority in Diaz decided that the cell phone was "immediately associated with [the defendant's] person" and therefore searchable.
Dissenting Justice Kathryn Werdeger argued that a mobile phone, particularly a smart phone, which is essentially a portable computer, is qualitatively different from a jacket pocket or pack of cigarettes. In 2009 the Ohio Supreme Court likewise decided that the sheer amount of information available from modern phones distinguishes them from a small container on one's person.
Various federal district courts have agreed with the California Supreme Court that a cell phone search "incident to arrest" is constitutional. It seems likely that the question eventually will be resolved by the U.S. Supreme Court.
More Articles by Brian Doherty
- Is the Ron Paul the Best Hope for Progressives?, Brian Doherty, May 25, 2012
- How Pat Buchanan Conquered America, Brian Doherty, May 17, 2012
- Ron Paul Is Not Ending His Campaign for Liberty, Brian Doherty, May 15, 2012
Most Popular Stories
- St. Louis Cops Worry That In-Car Cameras 'Are Being Used Against Them' (5.23)
- Here Are the 15 Senators Who Voted to Stop Armed FDA Agents From Conducting Warrantless Raids on America's Farmers (Not One of Them is a Democrat) (5.24)
- Reason "Hero of Freedom" Larry Flynt's Latest Stunt? Photoshopping a Penis into Mouth of Conservative Pundit S.E. Cupp (5.24)
- Plastic Bag Ban Will Put Los Angeles In Landfill (5.23)
- When Government Privileges Trump the Rights of Citizens (5.25)
Reason RUPE: Public Opinion Survey
- Reason-Rupe: Wisconsinites Favor Increasing Public Union Retirement Contributions to Address Budget Deficit (5.25)
- Reason-Rupe Poll Finds Support for Public Union Reforms (5.25)
- New Poll: Obama Leads Romney In Wisconsin, But Gary Johnson Could Impact the Race (5.24)
- Wisconsin Recall: Walker Leads Barrett 50-42 Among Likely Voters (5.24)
- Reason-Rupe Poll: Walker Leads Barrett 50-42, Obama Leads Romney 46-36 (5.24)
advertisements
Get Reason E-mail Updates!
Manage your Reason e-mail list subscriptionsSite comments/questions:
Media Inquiries and Reprint Permissions:
(310) 367-6109
Editorial & Production Offices:
3415 S. Sepulveda Blvd.
Suite 400
Los Angeles, CA 90034
(310) 391-2245
Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment or disable your ability to comment for any reason at any time.
Nomic|5.4.11 @ 2:01AM|#
Next big cell feature? Encryption, baby!
|6.5.11 @ 8:16PM|#
This is good news! What if the phone being searched was used to view obscene websites? We can't let that happen; by searching everything anyone does/has we will save this country's morals! hehe.
nike shox|8.1.11 @ 9:25PM|#
is good
xiingguan|1.10.12 @ 2:19AM|#
This movie has some nike sb skunk dunks for sale of the same flaws I saw in another attempt at a faithful adaptation of a work of fantastic literature long thought unfilmable, Zach Snyder’s 2009 version of Watchmen...That is, it kobe 7 for sale struck me as a series of filmed recreations of scenes from the famous novel