The Rise of Communist Nostalgia

Do east Germans regret the fall of the Berlin Wall?

Cathy Young | November 16, 2009

The fall of the Berlin Wall twenty years ago was one of the most exhilarating events of the 20th Century. No one could fail to be moved by the joy of people who tore down a loathed monument to tyranny. Today, when all that remains of the Wall is a few sections preserved as historical artifacts and graffiti-stained chunks sold in souvenir shops, the collapse of communism in Eastern Europe remains a glorious moment but also, in some ways, a bittersweet one.

There are widespread reports that for many eastern Germans, liberation has turned to disillusionment. The British daily, The Guardian, marked the anniversary with an article by an ex-East German academic lamenting the demise of the communist state—which, she asserted, offered "social and gender equality, full employment and lack of existential fears."

But are these lamentations for a lost workers' paradise anything more than the griping of hardcore ideologues or members of the old communist elites who resent the loss of their own privilege? In a recent Pew Research Center poll, only 16 percent of people living in former East Germany took a negative attitude toward German unification; a positive view was taken by 81 percent, though it should be noted that only 31 percent chose the "very positive" option. Moreover, nearly two-thirds—63 percent—say that unification has made their lives better. That's hardly evidence of communist nostalgia.

Yet other findings show a more nuanced picture. In a poll last July, only eight percent of eastern Germans said that the "German Democratic Republic" (as East Germany was officially known) had mostly "good sides" and a better life than today's unified Germany. However, an additional 49 percent agreed that "the GDR had more good sides than bad sides; there were some problems, but life was good there."

According to an analysis in the German magazine Spiegel, what drives this rose-colored view—shared by many young people who barely remember life under communism—is a peculiar sense of pride and humiliation. Many eastern Germans see communist East Germany, for better or worse, as their home or their parents' home, and its history as their legacy. While critical of the communist state's suppression of freedom, they chafe at the idea that it was an illegitimate regime and that the West was their savior. It's the same syndrome that causes many Russians today to whitewash the Soviet past.

There is similar ambivalence in other Eastern-bloc countries included in the Pew poll. Support for the change from state socialism to a market economy hovers barely above 50 percent not only in Russia but in Hungary, Bulgaria and Lithuania, and stands at just 36 percent in Ukraine; in all these countries, pro-capitalist attitudes have declined sharply since 1991. (The highest rates of approval for the transition to capitalism are found in Eastern Germany, the Czech Republic and Poland, at 82 percent, 79 percent and 71 percent respectively.)

Most startling, attitudes toward the adoption of a multiparty system follows a similar pattern: multiparty democracy is now favored by just 55 percent of Hungarian and Lithuanian respondents and an abysmal 30 percent of Ukrainians.

This is not, as some on the left think, an indictment of capitalist democracy and a vindication of socialism. It is noteworthy that support for markets and democracy is strongest in countries that have made the greatest strides toward the market economy. Partly, as well, the problem is generational, with older people most likely to favor the old order. Nonetheless, far too many countries on the road to freedom have found themselves mired in corruption, mismanagement, graft and political turmoil.

Twenty years ago, the revolt against communism was about as black-and-white an issue as it gets: the human desire for freedom, opportunity, and a good life pitted against a tyranny that erected a wall in the middle of a city to keep people from escaping, and killed those who tried anyway. (Whether a regime makes prisoners of its own citizens is a good litmus test of whether it deserves to exist.) Today, the liberated countries face hard questions of how to build a good society, and shades of gray abound. Meanwhile, the main adversary of Western democracy is no longer communism but radical Islamist terrorism. It is, in some ways, a far more complex conflict that involves an amorphous, diffuse and unpredictable enemy, as well as questions of religious and cultural identity and debates about drawing the line between legitimate religion and religion-based totalitarian ideology. In some ways, the Cold War seems simple by comparison.

Communist nostalgia is overrated. But, recalling the fall of the Berlin Wall, one does feel nostalgia for a time when one could celebrate an uncomplicated victory of good over evil.

Cathy Young writes a weekly column for RealClearPolitics and is a contributing editor at Reason magazine. She blogs at http://cathyyoung.wordpress.com/. This article originally appeared at RealClearPolitics.

Comments

The Lord Giveth and...|11.16.09 @ 7:05PM|#

WASHINGTON — More than 15 million taxpayers may owe the government $250 or more because of how the IRS last spring set up President Barack Obama's tax break that was designed to help consumers spend the U.S. economy out of recession.

Individuals with more than one job and married couples in which both spouses work may have to repay the government $400, either through a smaller tax refund or a larger tax bill, according to a report released Monday by the Treasury Department's inspector general for tax administration. Social Security recipients who also earn taxable wages may have to repay $250.

The tax credit, which is supposed to pay individuals up to $400 and couples up to $800, was Obama's signature tax break in the massive stimulus package enacted in February. The credit has increased weekly paychecks for 95 percent of working families, giving them cash to help boost consumer spending during the worst economic recession in decades.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/200.....dit_pickle

This Is Blatant|11.16.09 @ 7:19PM|#

Is it too late to start building The Washington Wall?

Hugh Akston|11.16.09 @ 7:26PM|#

(Whether a regime makes prisoners of its own citizens is a good litmus test of whether it deserves to exist.)

Well said.

It Can't Happen There|11.16.09 @ 7:28PM|#

for many East Germans today, liberation has turned to disillusionment

Sounds familiar. Ambitious corporals! Eastern Germany needs some inspiration.

Fist of Etiquette|11.16.09 @ 7:37PM|#

If they're disillusioned, I suggest airing their grievances in the comments over at www.reason.de.

|11.16.09 @ 7:55PM|#

People do seem to be really fixated on that old stuff!

Jess
www.online-privacy.at.tc

|11.16.09 @ 8:54PM|#

we should pay attention- people want more socialism! Clearly, this is the correct course. Full speed ahead, Captain Obama!

monk|11.16.09 @ 9:28PM|#

Can't blame them... same type of Corrupt rulers with no guarantees of security.

Pingback| 11.16.09 @ 10:13PM

Cathy Young At Reason: The Rise Of Communist Nostalgia « Chris Navin links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…sp;Nostalgia Filed under: Communism, Current Events, Economics, Media, Philosophy, Politics, Public Debate — chr1 @ 8:13 pm Tags: Cathy Young, Communism, Ideology, Political Philosophy, Reason Full article here. Young suggests that for some East Germans recalling Communism: “According to an analysis in the German magazine Spiegel, what drives this rose-colored view—shared by many young people who…

|11.16.09 @ 10:59PM|#

Whether a regime makes prisoners of its own citizens is a good litmus test of whether it deserves to exist

Well, be careful about throwing that dictum around in the USA. We incarcerate our citizens at a pretty high clip.

Rimfax|11.17.09 @ 12:37PM|#

That fact reinforces, rather than undermines, her dictum.

Kryton|11.16.09 @ 11:06PM|#

Don't conflate normal well adjusted human beings with Grauniad columnists.

|11.16.09 @ 11:12PM|#

People who lived there are bound to have some good memories. Being isolated form anything else, most people born under these systems would view it as "normal life" and perhaps be a little nostalgic no matter how bad it was.

Rimfax|11.17.09 @ 12:41PM|#

The dead aren't around to argue with them.

Beezard|11.16.09 @ 11:28PM|#

I think the Sex Pistols already dealt with this topic about 13 years before the wall came down.

The Libertarian Guy|11.17.09 @ 12:17AM|#

"The fall of the Berlin Wall twenty years ago was one of the most exhilarating events of the 20th Century"... except for our president, who wasn't really all that hot about it.

Pingback| 11.17.09 @ 1:25AM

The Rise of Communist Nostalgia - Reason Magazine | Germany today links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…Republic” (as East Germany was officially known) had mostly “good sides” and a better life than today’s unified Germany . … See the original post: The Rise of Communist Nostalgia - Reason Magazine Tags: a-poll-last, a-show-day, cast, good-sides, talk-about Today Leave a Reply Name (required) Mail (will not be published) (required) Website Germany Headlines angela-merkel…

Pingback| 11.17.09 @ 2:48AM

About berlin wall, west, east, fall | Find me About links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…20th Century. No one could fail to be moved by the joy of people who tore down a loathed monument to tyranny. Today, when all that remains of the Wall is a few … Read Original Story: The Rise of Communist Nostalgia – Reason Online After only a year on the ground in Europe as a young twenty-something correspondent, I was thrust into coverage that one knew was not only historic but would have grand…

|11.17.09 @ 7:15AM|#

Can't blame him--they wouldn't let him make a campaign speech from the Brandenburg Gate...

|11.17.09 @ 9:44AM|#

I recently met some Serbians who looked fondly back to the days of Tito, sort of. They all said that they were richer under Tito, and that freedom doesn't mean much to somebody who can't afford to eat. I reminded them that they aren't so poor (they're traveling around the US for chrissakes). It reminded me of similar rationalizations in Spain regarding Franco, but at least then the argument came from actual poor people.

|11.17.09 @ 10:44AM|#

While critical of the communist state's suppression of freedom, they chafe at the idea that it was an illegitimate regime and that the West was their savior. It's the same syndrome that causes many Russians today to whitewash the Soviet past.

And some southerners to claim "Secession wasn't about slavery!"

;-)

|11.17.09 @ 11:58AM|#

I recently met some Serbians who looked fondly back to the days of Tito, sort of. They all said that they were richer under Tito, and that freedom doesn't mean much to somebody who can't afford to eat.

Did you ask them when the last time was that they missed a meal?

Or, apparently, an international flight?

Rimfax|11.17.09 @ 12:47PM|#

Bruni de la Motte isn't a communist-apologist. She's an unreformed Communist. She writes booklets for what's left of the British Communist Party.

She lost her own playground, complete with human dolls, kept in with a 5 km perimeter of blunderbuss-shaped anti-personnel mines and razor wire. Of course, we should feel sorry for her.