The School District Is Dead, Long Live the Schools

Oakland embraces the charter school revolution.

Last week the Oakland Unified school district voted to close five elementary schools as part of a restructuring plan as the district grapples with a huge budget deficit caused in part by too many schools and not enough students. In the past six years student achievement in Oakland Unified has improved faster than any urban district in California. The district has operated through a charter-like school-choice process called “Options” where a student can enroll in any school in the district and the “money follows the child” to that school. Yet from a parent’s perspective this charter-like process has not been enough. The district continues to bleed students to charter schools. In 2010, more than 21 percent of Oakland kids were enrolled in charter schools.

The Oakland story is a case in point for the monumental shift in education governance taking place across the United States. For Oakland the school closures come on top of the previous news that the faculty at two other high-performing district elementary schools has voted to split from the district and become charter schools. As The San Jose Mercury News reports, the faculty has “voted to break away from the district and convert their schools into independently run charters, a move that could cost Oakland Unified more than $4 million. Teachers and principals at ASCEND and Learning Without Limits say that as charter schools, they will have far more control over who they hire, what they teach and how, and how they spend their money.”

The growth of charter schools in Oakland reflects a national trend. There are more than 5,000 charter schools enrolling two million children and the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools reports that six school districts have at least 30 percent of their public school students enrolled in public charter schools. Additionally, 18 school districts have 20 percent or more of their public school students enrolled in charter schools and nearly 100 districts now have at least 10 percent of public school students in charter schools.

(Article continues below video.)

The majority of charter schools have started in urban areas with long histories of trapping kids in failing schools and reflect the story line told in the documentary Waiting For Superman, where desperate disadvantaged children vie for their spot in the local charter school. In addition, there has been a larger trend towards low-performing schools being restructured as charter schools, as in the Detroit proposal to convert 41 schools to charters to offer kids higher-quality education and save the school district money. And New Orleans, where 80 percent of kids are now enrolled in charter schools, stands alone as a city that successfully built a charter school Mecca out of the ruins of disaster where the money now follows the kids to any school in the city. In all of these cases the charter school growth has the “hostile takeover” flavor of kids fleeing a failing public school system.

Ascend and Learning Without Limits flip that trend. These high-quality public schools want the charter advantage for themselves. They want relief from collective bargaining, from central office mandates, and most significantly from the huge school district debts that leave less money for the students. And these Oakland schools are not alone. For example, in March 2011, the Los Angeles school board approved the charter petition of El Camino Real high school, which holds the national record for U.S. Academic Decathlon championships and maintains top test scores in the district. This reflects an ongoing trend of Los Angeles schools opting for freedom from district regulations by shifting to charter status. In fact, at 80,000 students, Los Angeles boasts the most charter students of any district in the nation. After the school board vote, former Superintendent Ramon Cortines told the Associated Press that he expects the conversion trend to continue and foresees the day when the district's enrollment of 650,000 will plummet to 400,000.

Even when school districts try to give their schools charter-like advantages they remain constrained by collective bargaining rules and huge financial obligations. For example, Oakland schools are still subject to the destructive personnel churn because of the district’s massive financial deficit that causes teacher layoffs based on seniority. This puts these autonomous schools at risk precisely when they’re building their staff to support school improvement. In 2011, 60 percent of Ascend teachers received layoff notices, while and at Learning Without Limits all but one of the 17 teachers received layoff notices. While many of those teachers ultimately kept their jobs, these schools are not willing to live under such ongoing risk based on the district’s dire financial condition.

The bottom line is that charter schools give school leaders, teachers, and parents much more control over staffing and finances while also freeing them from the economic consequences of belonging to a district that has been in financial distress for decades. A school district may become financially bankrupt, but individual schools can live on through the charter school process. It raises the question: As a nation, should we continue to support large school districts at the expense of individual schools and students? Oakland school district spokesman Troy Flint speaks the truth to power when he says that “ASCEND is a canary in the coal mine, and that fact has shaken people, that's no question.”

Lisa Snell is director of education policy at the Reason Foundation.

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  • Paul||

    If Oakland's school heirarchy is as entrenched as Seattle, there's be blood in the streets after closing the schools. And my bet is they'll reopen them in a couple of years because Oakland will "find" 200 more students in the school district, justifying the reopenings.

  • l0b0t||

    Dear Reason
    your recent advertising partnership with Tubemogul.com is fucking awful!! Every time I try to read an article at H&R, my browser is bombarded with dozens upon dozens of cookies from Tubemogul. PLEASE MAKE IT STOP!!!!

  • Colin||

    Get adblock. I haven't seen an internet ad in ages. It's like the web has been reborn.

  • DEFUND Sacramento||

    Joined in the streets by Gubment Skool Teechers, Occupy Oakland may get into the "BURN CHARTER SCHOOLS!" mode.

  • Paul||

    OT: Federally backed mortgage limit drops from $567,000 to $506,000. Causes "puzzling" drop in median home price.

    http://seattletimes.nwsource.c.....les04.html

  • pmains||

    Dear Reason
    I use adblock and was unaware of the Tubemogul.com ad campaign.

  • x,y||

    #OccupyMonocleSchools

  • Colin||

    This will probably be one of the first things Occupy will destroy when they take over.

    For Marx never mentioned charter schools.

  • Paul||

    Children taught in Charter schools become capitalist roaders. Their destruction will not be missed.

  • ||

    Charter schools are a tame step, not a revolution. A real revolution would be when parents and teachers demand full autonomy from the State.

    Two million home-schoolers have discovered something which neither the State nor the educational profession is yet willing to admit: the fewer regulations, the more freedom, the better the outcomes.

    Government schools suffer from an inherent and inescapable conflict of interest; when the child's interests are in conflict with the government, the child's interests always lose.

  • ||

    vouchersvouchersvouchersvouchersvouchersvouchersvouchersvouchersvouchersvouchersvouchersvouichers

  • Tim||

    Even when school districts try to give their schools charter-like advantages they remain constrained by collective bargaining rules and huge financial obligations. For example, Oakland schools are still subject to the destructive personnel churn because of the district’s massive financial deficit that causes teacher layoffs based on seniority. The Lord of The Ring: http://www.aimengsilver.com/th.....-p-18.html

  • ||

    I like grapples.

  • ||

    Hopefully the next prez will seriously use the bully pulpit to get the unions broken down, and by the way...

    The Carpenters and Pipefitters union here in Chicago have training facilities for their apprentice programs; they pay for it with dues. Maybe the teachers unions could divert dues from politicians and try to put out a good product also. Because right now the product stinks!!
    All teachers are not bad, but enough are to drag down most school districts of any large size.

  • Denny||

    your recent advertising partnership with Tubemogul.com is fucking awful!! Every time I try to read an article at H&R, my browser is bombarded with dozens upon dozens of cookies from Tubemogul.

    http://www.aimenggem.com/Whole.....e_c17.html

  • Marc by Marc Jacobs Handbag||

    Mr. Marc Jacobs is a legend

  • Mulberry Bayswater Bag||

    I do love the manner in which you have presented this concern plus it does provide us a lot of fodder for thought. On the other hand, through what precisely I have personally seen, I just simply trust as the commentary stack on that folks continue to be on point and not start on a soap box regarding the news du jour. Still, thank you for this exceptional point and although I can not necessarily go along with the idea in totality, I respect your point of view.

  • cheap jordan 2U||

    good

GET REASON MAGAZINE

Get Reason's print or digital edition before it’s posted online

  • Video Game Nation: How gaming is making America freer – and more fun.
  • Matt Welch: How the left turned against free speech.
  • Nothing Left to Cut? Congress can’t live within their means.
  • And much more.

SUBSCRIBE

advertisement