Free Trade

Repealing Trump's Tariffs Could Save More Than $1,100 Per Household

How Congress could score an easy win for affordability and constrain executive power all at once

|


If Democrats are serious about making life more affordable for Americans, there is one obvious place to start: Repealing the myriad tariffs that President Donald Trump has imposed during his two terms in office.

A new report from the Tax Policy Center, a left-of-center think tank, shows that a full repeal of those tariffs could save the average household about $1,100 next year and could cause prices to fall for a wide range of products. Items that are subject to some of the highest tariffs—like furniture and textiles, as well as a wide range of industrial inputs—could decline in price by as much as 5 percent if the tariffs are removed, according to the Tax Policy Center's model.

One catch: The tariffs that would be the easiest to repeal politically would also deliver the smallest benefit for most Americans.

That's the tariffs on Canadian goods, which Trump imposed earlier this year, as he escalated a trade war with America's northern neighbor and major trading partner. Those tariffs are deeply unpopular—some Republican candidates even ran ads criticizing them during the midterm campaign—and have been challenged in court as an unlawful use of Section 338 of the infamous Smoot-Hawley tariff law.

Whether they end up being struck down by Congress or the courts, however, the relief for consumers will be limited. Those tariffs apply to a narrow set of goods, and repealing them would save the average household only $30 next year, the Tax Policy Center estimates.

FIGURE 1

Of course, they should still be repealed. Sen. Ron Wyden (D–Ore.) is leading the push to do exactly that, and to strike down the law that Trump used to impose those tariffs in the first place. "Congress must take away the president's ability to unilaterally and arbitrarily impose tariffs," Wyden told The Wall Street Journal earlier this month.

He's exactly right about that, and taking swift action against the Section 338 tariffs could build momentum for other trade bills in Congress.

To achieve meaningful savings for Americans, Congress will have to go bigger. The Tax Policy Center model shows that knocking down two other sets of tariffs should be the ultimate goal.

First are the Section 232 tariffs that Trump has imposed on steel, aluminum, copper, semiconductors, cars, and other products. Some of those tariffs date back to the first Trump administration (and were left in place by President Joe Biden), but the second Trump administration has ratcheted them higher. These tariffs apply to about 21 percent of all American imports.

There are also the Section 301 tariffs, which Trump ordered in July as a replacement for the "emergency" tariffs that had been struck down by the Supreme Court earlier in the year. Those tariffs range from 10 percent to 12.5 percent and apply to nearly all imports from 60 countries. (Officially, these tariffs are meant to combat "forced labor" but that's a laughably thin pretext.)

Repealing those tariffs—and the laws that Trump used to impose them—ought to be the priority.

Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D–N.Y.) has introduced a bill to repeal the Section 301 tariffs. In the House, a group of Democrats led by Rep. Don Beyer (D–Va.) and Suzan DelBene (D–Wash.) has sponsored a bill to kill the Section 232 tariffs and require congressional approval for future tariffs.

And Democrats are saying a lot of the right things, so far. "We will pass a bill to stop the stupid Trump tariffs jacking up prices on Americans," Rep. Ted Lieu (D–Calif.), the incoming chair of the House Democratic Caucus, told reporters last week.

The biggest hurdle, obviously, is that Trump can veto any bill undoing his tariffs or placing new restrictions on presidential tariff authority. It remains to be seen whether there is a bipartisan consensus for reducing tariffs, as Democrats will be unable to override a veto on their own.

But after an election where the cost of living was a major issue, lawmakers on both parties should be eager to deliver. Are Republicans really going to defend the politically toxic tariffs, just to give Democrats even more fodder for the 2028 campaign? The ads practically write themselves: "We tried to lower costs by $1,000 for your family, but Republicans decided the president's bizarre fascination with tariffs was more important." That's the path to a 60-seat Democratic majority in the Senate.

The experiment with protectionism has failed. It's time for Congress to put money back in Americans' wallets by getting government out of the way.