Criminal Justice

Alabama's Out-of-Control Prison System Is About To Go on Trial

A Justice Department lawsuit alleging unconstitutional violence in Alabama prisons is set to go trial at the end of November.

|


After years of mounting evidence of rampant violence and unsanitary living conditions, Alabama's deadly prison system is about to go on trial to determine whether it's operating in defiance of the Constitution.

A federal trial in a U.S. Justice Department lawsuit against the state of Alabama over alleged unconstitutional conditions inside Alabama Department of Corrections (ADOC) prisons is scheduled to begin on Nov. 30. The trial represents a significant threat to state control over the ADOC, which could be subject to court-ordered reforms or even put under the control of a court-appointed receiver.

Civil rights advocates say the trial will force Alabama to confront evidence of systemic violence and misconduct documented by numerous reports and investigations. Those reports have shown that the ADOC is continuing to rack up brutality lawsuits, but rather than improve its oversight mechanisms or fire problem officers, it's settling the vast majority of suits, costing state taxpayers tens of millions of dollars in legal fees.

"This trial puts a spotlight on what families, advocates, and experts have been warning us about for years: Alabama's prisons are in full-blown crisis, and thousands of incarcerated people are trapped in dangerous conditions with nowhere to turn for help," said Alesha Judkins, senior campaign director at FWD.us. "The upcoming trial is a long-overdue moment of accountability. State leaders have a serious responsibility to stop defending a broken system and start protecting human lives."  

The Justice Department's Civil Rights Division filed a lawsuit in 2020 alleging that Alabama's prison system for men is overcrowded, unsanitary, and deliberately indifferent to the frequent and often deadly assaults against inmates, violating the Eighth Amendment and the 14th Amendment of the Constitution.

The suit followed a 2019 report by the division that detailed disgusting living conditions, "an excessive amount of violence, sexual abuse, and prisoner deaths," and indifference by staff toward the lives of their wards.

The Justice Department put the state on notice again in 2020 with another report that documented allegations of excessive force against inmates by staff, including two incidents that led to deaths. An earlier 2014 department investigation accused Alabama officials of fostering an environment of widespread sexual abuse at the Julia Tutwiler Prison for Women, where officers allegedly forced women to engage in sex acts to obtain basic sanitary supplies.

Media investigations also documented the wanton violence inside Alabama prisons.

The biggest spotlight on the ADOC has been The Alabama Solution, a 2025 Oscar-winning documentary that used footage captured by incarcerated men on contraband cellphones to show dysfunction and violence inside state prisons. The film investigates the death of Steven Davis, an incarcerated man who died after being beaten by several correctional officers in 2019.

But neither a Justice Department lawsuit nor a prominent documentary was enough pressure to force Alabama to radically reform its state prisons. Deaths have continued to surge. Two of the four officers named in a lawsuit over Davis' death, which was settled in 2024 for $250,000, are still employed at the ADOC. 

Christopher Izor, a producer and researcher for The Alabama Solution, has continued to investigate the ADOC. He co-published a report in April with investigative reporter Beth Shelburne showing that since 2020, the ADOC has spent $68 million defending state prisons, including $20 million exclusively defending individual officers accused of excessive force.

The most-sued ADOC correctional officer was one of the guards involved in Davis' death, Lt. Roderick Gadson. The report found that Gadson had been a named defendant in 11 excessive force lawsuits, costing the state nearly $1 million in total legal fees. 

Since the report was published, Gadson has been named in two additional lawsuits.

"It goes to show that these are not old stories," Izor says. "These are the same stories that keep happening over and over."

The report found that the cost to Alabama taxpayers for legal claims of excessive force against ADOC officers has increased nearly fivefold compared to the prior five years. Overall, ADOC lawsuit settlements accounted for 63 percent of all spending from Alabama's General Liability Trust Fund.

Although Alabama lawmakers have failed to agree on comprehensive prison reforms, they did green-light a pilot program to independently audit state prisons through the Alabama Department of Examiners. The first audit under the pilot program was released on Nov. 6. The audit was only supposed to cover a single prison, but investigators expanded their scope to the main ADOC headquarters after encountering significant problems with record-keeping and a culture of secrecy at the agency that required them to subpoena some information. For example, investigators were given three conflicting counts of how many inmates had died at the prison they were supposed to audit.

Alabama officials' solution to the state's prison problem so far has been to attempt to build their way out of it. In 2021 Alabama approved a $1.3 billion funding package, including $400 million from federal COVID-19 relief aid, to build three new huge prisons. However, those projects have been dogged by delays.

New prisons could solve some of ADOC's persistent problems with overcrowding and filth, but they won't change the culture of the correctional officers who staff them. Izor says the Justice Department's reports "made very clear that changing the physical building doesn't address some of the issues with corruption or drug-trafficking, or issues with the use of force or pervasive violence."

"What we've seen is that Alabama's solution so far has been wholly inadequate," Izor says, "and that's why the DOJ is bringing the state to trial."