Jacob Sullum | March 30, 2006
Why, the Center for Science in the Public Interest, of course. And the Marin Institute. And the Center for Alcohol Marketing and Youth at Georgetown University. With a little help from the Federal Trade Commission and the National Association of Attorneys General. Maybe.
The New York Times reports that the anti-alcohol industry is indignant about a Bud Light commercial in which "three men climb onto the roofs of their houses, telling their wives that they [are] going to clean gutters and repair satellite dishes. Instead, the men break out the Bud Light and lawn chairs. One man eventually falls through the roof and into his living room." Anheuser-Busch says the spot, which ran during the Super Bowl and the Olympics (which explains why I didn't see it), is a "spoof." Of what, exactly, isn't clear—maybe stupid beer ads. But the main point is that the rooftop high jinks should not be taken seriously, since that would violate an industry rule against ads that "portray beer drinking before or during activities which, for safety reasons, require a high degree of alertness or coordination."
The FTC, however, does take such matters seriously. At least it did back in 1998, when it scolded Beck's North America for a commercial showing people drinking beer on a sailboat. "Respondent has depicted boating passengers as drinking Beck's beer while engaged in activities that require a high degree of alertness and coordination to avoid falling overboard," the commission said. "This conduct is inconsistent with the Beer Institute's own Advertising and Marketing Code and may also violate federal and state boating safety laws."
But the Beer Institute says complaints about the Bud Light commercial are moot because the ad is not running anymore. "That renders the whole process meaningless, given that many beer ads are designed to air for a short time only," complains CSPI's George Hacker. "It's very convenient. When a company is caught, they can simply withdraw the ad, which then eliminates the possibility of review." I don't know about you, but I like to imagine steam coming out of Hacker's ears as he says this. No doubt he's still fuming about the 2000 "Whassup!" ads, which showed Budweiser-drinking men dangling their tongues in a manner requiring a high degree of alertness or coordination to avoid entrapment in the bottle or entanglement in phone cords.
[Thanks to CEI's Christine Hall-Reis for the tip.]
Help Reason celebrate its next 40 years. Donate Now!
Try Reason's award-winning print edition today! Your first issue is FREE if you are not completely satisfied.
"an industry rule against ads that "portray beer drinking
before or during activities which, for safety reasons, require a
high degree of alertness or coordination."
Even if you accept the faulty premise that this should be regulated
by the FCC in the first place, I don't see how they could
reasonably regulate this, unless said commercial portrayed
excessive beer drinking. I can have 1, maybe 2 or even 3
beers (depending on the alcohol content) and still be perfectly
fine (and within the law) to drive, sail, or sit in a chair on my
roof.
But, yet again, I am forced to admit my fault: I'm attempting to
inject logic into a patently illogical debate.
See, I always regarded picking up hot chicks in a nighclub as activities which, for safety reasons, require a high degree of alertness or coordination, which would throw out mot of your beer ads right there.
Speaking of activities that involve a "high degree of alterness or coordination" I guess they won't be allowed to make beer commercials that involve hitting on cuties at the bar.
I don't even like beer, but I'm tempted to buy some and drink some just to spite these idiots.
I'm unclear on this. Can you mention beer in an advertisement within 60 days of a federal election?
I can have 1, maybe 2 or even 3 beers (depending on the
alcohol content) and still be perfectly fine (and within the law)
to drive, sail, or sit in a chair on my roof.
Not by CSPI or any other nanny standards, Evan. The only activity
that may be safely engaged in once one has consumed a single
serving of alcohol is sitting perfectly still in large padded
chair.
I actaully know a bit about this. I went for a job in the legal
department of the BACC which is the British Advertising Standards
Council, to work on alcohol regualtions.
Alcohol rules are HEINOUS! There's about a million. I saw the bud
light adverts that you guys had in the superbowl and they'd have
never aired over here.
Any moving vehicle or perilous activity eg sailboats and roofs -
forget it.
You know, I used to drink six pints* and go do my stats
homework. Could they have showed that in a commercial?
I drank five pints* and then went to the review for my advanced
macro class, got an A on the final, would that have been okay to
put in a commercial?
*In about an hour or two.
Doesn't drinking in bars lead to sexual harrassment, and
unintended sex? We should ban it. Texas is a pioneer in this
regard.
Can't drinking at a NASCAR race, without a shirt, lead to
sunburn?
I am just tired of every beer comercial consisting of men acting as beer guzzling morons obsessed about finding beer. Jesus, the schtick wasn't that funny to begin with, when does it end?
I am just tired of every beer comercial consisting of men
acting as beer guzzling morons obsessed about finding beer. Jesus,
the schtick wasn't that funny to begin with, when does it
end?
Excellent point. Maybe beer commercials should show men wearing
tweed jackets with leather elbow-patches sipping beer out of
martini glasses whilst debating whether Pepys' diaries should be
considered literature or history, before segueing into a spirited
but civilized debate about whether Einstein or Hawking is the more
talented physicist. And then the men can read their poetry to each
other.
"Respondent has depicted boating passengers as drinking
Beck's beer ...
The horror!
As a member of the Olympic drinking team, I have to say I agree with these regulations. Beer drinking should only be undertaken by those with proper training and equipment. Don't try this at home!
The only activity that may be safely engaged in once one has
consumed a single serving of alcohol is sitting perfectly still in
large padded chair.
But this will lead to lethargy, diabetes, numbness of the feet,
forgetfullness, antisocial behavior, a fat ass, a lack of interest
in volunteering at the orphanage, anti-civic involvement, red-eye,
blindness, dementia, and finally, death. Banning beer ads is the
only way to avoid this.
Ah fuck it. Let's just ban beer. We'll all be shiny, happy
people.
In the corporate world, we're all wondering why advertising
firms are producing for us these increasingly surreal commercials
that seem to have nothing to do with our products and services. And
why executives seem to be scared to suggest that maybe something
that actually mentions that our products might be useful. From time
to time. I know enough to know that advertiser claims that they
really know what they are doing are at least 50% bull. Just like
claims that psychologists actually understand human behavior.
To be sure, beer commercials can get away with a lot, because
they're just about vaguely stimulating brand awareness. Beer = fun,
albeit stupid behavior + hot women who will do things with
you.
A friend of mine and his wife, both former local news producers,
have similar complaints about marketing folks driving news
coverage. They don't object to marketing being a part of the
process; they object to it being all of the process.
Jennifer: if you drank the kind of beer that I drink/sell, your
sceenario might be more apt. In fact, I have a "quadrupel" in my
fridge right now called "Three Philosophers", so your "tweed jacket
and martini glasses" thiing isn't far off.
And, if you do decide to start drinking beer out of spite, for
fuck's sake, please drink good beer.
John,
"I am just tired of every beer comercial consisting of men
acting as beer guzzling morons obsessed about finding beer. Jesus,
the schtick wasn't that funny to begin with, when does it
end?"
Free market, baby. As soon as the focus groups say so, then it'll
end. I find the commercials rediculous---but I'm a beer snob, so my
ridicule comes from the fact that it's absurd to really think about
people caring whether they're drinking Tastless piss Beer A or
Tasteless Piss Beer B.
All these idiotic commercials where people act like fucking savages
just to protect their cheap, shitty beer make no sense. Oh no.
Someone stole your bud light. So? Raid the couch cushions for
change, and go down to the 7-11 and get another case.
I might get pissed if someone stole my Scaldis Prestige...but a bud
light? Fuck, man, TAKE IT. Be my guest.
"As a member of the Olympic drinking team, I have to say I
agree with these regulations. Beer drinking should only be
undertaken by those with proper training and equipment. Don't try
this at home!"
I have heard a rumor that back in the day, during biathlon
competitions the competitors, when transitioning from the skiing to
rifle shooting, would take a swig or two of beer to slow their
heart rate down.
Whether this was ever actually done in the Olympics, or just back
when it was a friendly competition between bored Scandanavian
soldiers, I couldn't say.
Excellent point. Maybe beer commercials should show men
wearing tweed jackets with leather elbow-patches sipping beer out
of martini glasses whilst debating whether Pepys' diaries should be
considered literature or history, before segueing into a spirited
but civilized debate about whether Einstein or Hawking is the more
talented physicist. And then the men can read their poetry to each
other
Jennifer,
I couldn't agree more. May I suggest the following to everyone. The
Tweed revolution is upon us:
www.thechap.net
Jennifer: if you drank the kind of beer that I drink/sell,
your sceenario might be more apt. In fact, I have a "quadrupel" in
my fridge right now called "Three Philosophers", so your "tweed
jacket and martini glasses" thiing isn't far off.
I know. My boyfriend mostly drinks micro-brews with names like
"Pretentia-Brau".
I have a "quadrupel" in my fridge right now called "Three
Philosophers", so your "tweed jacket and martini glasses" thiing
isn't far off.
Is that the one from Ommengang Brewery? It's outstanding! If you
can find it, I recommend the Thomas Hooker's Liberator
Doppelbock.
Jennifer,
Granted, beer will never be conac, but image does mean something in
marketing. Even allegedly higher end import beers like Heiniken
exclusively portray their customers as mentally deficiant
trogledytes. I just can't see how that helps image and sales in the
long run.
Jennifer: So he can get "philosopher stoned". I sense a new movement. Any time you mix pretension with a fad, you'll do well.
Beer snobs always strike me as those same type of people that insist on saying "I don't watch T.V." every chance they get.
I love microbrew beers. I don't even buy the macro stuff any
more.
Mmmmmmm...Laughing Lab...
Even allegedly higher end import beers like Heiniken
exclusively portray their customers as mentally deficiant
trogledytes
John,
I think it helps because most people are mentally deficient
trogledytes.
"Beer snobs always strike me as those same type of people
that insist on saying "I don't watch T.V." every chance they
get."
I only watch Adult Swim.
Even,
There seems to be a rule in marketing, the worse your beer tastes
the more obsessed the people in the commercials are about the
beer.
but image does mean something in marketing. Even allegedly
higher end import beers like Heiniken exclusively portray their
customers as mentally deficiant trogledytes. I just can't see how
that helps image and sales in the long run.
It hasn't seemed to hurt so far. Perhaps one reason for the "stupid
party dude" image is that beer is, in fact, the cheapest alcohol
you can buy (except for things like Mad Dag which have a definite
Skid Row connotation). If you're a frat boy and want to buy enough
alcohol to get your thirty or fifty or a hundred party guests good
and drunk you're going to buy beer, not cognac or whiskey or
anything else.
The fact that beer makes its drinkers burp a lot might have
something to do with its reputation, too.
"I just can't see how that helps image and sales in the long
run."
Who said anything about the long run? As long as you can convince
the swaddling hordes to drink your swill tomorrow, what else
matters?
"Beer snobs always strike me as those same type of people that
insist on saying "I don't watch T.V." every chance they
get."
Please. I watch lotsa teevee. And those anti-TV twats are typically
very smug about their choices. No smugness here, just offering up
thoughts. Drink all the bud light you want. I pass no
judgment---just explaining why these "get yer mitts of my beer!"
commercials are stupid.
"There seems to be a rule in marketing, the worse your beer
tastes the more obsessed the people in the commercials are about
the beer."
Well, sure, what are they gonna market it on...taste? Image is all
they have.
"If you're a frat boy and want to buy enough alcohol to get
your thirty or fifty or a hundred party guests good and drunk
you're going to buy beer, not cognac or whiskey or anything
else."
I can't believe that they don't have the same commercials for
Aristocrat vodka. "Get yer hands off my 'crat!"
"Beer snobs always strike me as those same type of people that
insist on saying "I don't watch T.V." every chance they get."
No, its not the "I don't watch TV" guy who annoys me. It is the "I
don't own a TV" guy who I really hate.
Just think how much better off and more interesting our society would be if these mommy-state twerps actually went out and did something productive with their time. It's pretty bad when third-world shitholes start to look like beacons of freedom simply because they let a guy drink his beer and smoke a cig in peace.
See, I always regarded picking up hot chicks in nightclubs as activities which, for safety reasons, require a high degree of alertness or coordination, which would throw out most of your beer ads right there.
RC,
What? You mean being a groping slobbering drunk with slurred speach
doesn't attract the hot chicks?
I am proud to note that Schlitz and PBR don't advertise. Old Style does, but it's a strictly Chicago thing.
"Just think how much better off and more interesting our
society would be if these mommy-state twerps actually went out and
did something productive with their time."
Bodily throwing themselves off of the highest point of the Grand
Canyon would be a fantastic start.
I am proud to note that Schlitz and PBR don't
advertise.
Neither does Milwaukee's Best, the consumption of which at a
teenage beach party made me the non-beer-drinker I am today.
Milwaukee should sue.
Sorry for the goofy delayed double post. I blame beer-swilling
server squirrels.
And wouldn't that make a good name for a band?
Neither does Milwaukee's Best, the consumption of which at a
teenage beach party made me the non-beer-drinker I am
today.
There are ads for The Beast. I have seen them fairly recently here
in Texas. Something about "men should act like men and beer should
taste like beer"...which is a true statement, but patently
misleading when used to imply that The Beast tastes anything like
beer.
Didn't anyone else see the reports recently that because beers
(especially the bad American ones) are losing major market share to
hard liquor and wine? And their response, supposedly, is going to
be to give their beer a more mature and classy image. Miller is
already moving that direction. With any luck, we may actually see a
shift away from fratboy beer stupidity.
One thing always made me wonder about beer commercials. I guess I'm
on a feminist kick today but, did it ever occur to you that:
1. Beer commercials are especially prevalent during televised
sports shows
2. Beer commercials are blatantly sexist, with fat ugly idiots
getting the hottest chicks in the world (remember the Swedish
bikini team?)
3. Who the hell does most of the grocery shopping in this
country?!! WOMEN! Some of the companies eventually figured this
out, but I've always been amazed that it took so long. First rule
of advertising/sales/marketing is to make sure you're dealing with
the real decision maker!
There are ads for The Beast. I have seen them fairly
recently here in Texas.
That's a public-serive attempt to dissuade illegal immigrants from
coming into the country. "I don' wanna live in a country with this
goddam gringo beer!"
Beer can also lead to hot chicks wrestling in fountains, but
only when Bob Guicionne becomes president.
Guicionne 2008.
That's a public-serive
Public SERVICE. Damn, I'm typing like a beer drinker today.
Linquist,
That is what I was talking about above. Beer is loosing market
share to hard liquer. I think the ads and the image have something
to do with it. Yes, most mass market beers suck, but a lot of
people like them, yet are still drinkng hard liquer.
I can say that Mexican piss beer is better than Beast, Bud, etc, because at least you can add a lime to Corona or Dos Equis and have it taste mostly okay. Still prefer a good heff for a hot summer day, though.
Yes, most mass market beers suck, but a lot of people like
them, yet are still drinkng hard liquer.
Because the main purpose of alcohol is to get your drunk, and
getting drunk off of hard liquor is more cost-effective than
getting drunk off of beer.
By the way, did y'all hear what Eric Idle (I think) said about
American beer? It's like making love in a canoe--fucking close to
water.
It's like making love in a canoe--fucking close to
water.
I first heard that said about Coors shortly after I moved to
Colorado almost 25 years ago.
I first heard that said about Coors shortly after I moved to
Colorado almost 25 years ago.
Well, Idle is old enough that he might have been the one who first
said it, perhaps. I had a crush on him when I was a little girl,
and was rather upset to learn that all those Python episodes had
been filmed before my parents had even met, let alone had me, which
meant Idle was either way too old for me, or dead.
I drank Milwaukee's Beast for a semester or so in college. It's
some nasty stuff, let me tell you. Then again, I was considered a
high-end beer drinker because of my preference for Bud and the
occasional Michelob. Needless to say, imports were reserved for
formal gatherings.
Hmmm. I recall that sometime in 1987 or thereabouts, Stroh's was
offering $5 rebates on cases of beer. Since it cost about $8 a case
back then, the rebate ushered in a Renaissance of beer drinking. I
mean, $3 a case? I've had single mugs of the frothy stuff for more
than that!
The full statement said the ad was a spoof on the way men
act.
Which would imply that the marketers finally figured out their real
target audience is women. :-)
Poor Jeff P. Another victim of Python Lust.
Believe me--every bit of that lust dissipated once I saw how Idle
had aged. Yeeek.
It's a good thing they disallowed those Beck commercials with
the boating beer-drinkers, because if it hadn't been for those
commercials, no one would ever have started drinking while
sailing.
Funny how the anti-TV snobs who make a point of declaring their
aversion to toob culture always seem to know what's going on with
various shows.
if it hadn't been for those commercials, no one would ever
have started drinking while sailing.
Yeah, drinking beer while sailing is reckless and irresponsible.
Everyone knows that only rum can give you the nerves of steel and
liver of coal required for nautical adventures.
lunchstealer, Gilliam's arguably improved with age, 'cause he
was just frightening back in the 70s.
Jennifer, there's always Michael Palin. When I was very young, I
used to confuse him and Idle all of the time. Anyway, he's aged
better than Idle (I watch his travel shows pretty religiously). And
he's hung out with the Dalai Lama, which gives him karma cred.
I would like to make a point of announcing I don't even own a
TV. You may all feel free to hate me now. And if I know what's
going on with various shows, it's BECAUSE THE REST OF AMERICA WON'T
SHUT UP ABOUT THEM!
Jennifer - when I read your comment about "men wearing tweed
jackets with leather elbow-patches sipping beer out of martini
glasses" I thought of this:
Mulder: Mr. Simpson, we want you to recreate your every move the
night you saw the alien.
Homer: The evening began at the gentlemen's club, where we were
discussing Wittgenstein over a game of backgammon.
Scully: Mr. Simpson, it's a felony to lie to the FBI.
Seriously, though, it's hard for beer to get any respect when all
of popular culture, including commercials for beer, seems
devoted to portraying beer drinkers as Neanderthals.
Seriously, though, it's hard for beer to get any respect
when all of popular culture, including commercials for beer, seems
devoted to portraying beer drinkers as Neanderthals.
I think the beer drinkers themselves bear some responsibility for
that. When was the last time you saw a guy show off his ability to
crush a cognac bottle with his forehead?
"If you're a frat boy and want to buy enough alcohol to get your
thirty or fifty or a hundred party guests good and drunk you're
going to buy beer, not cognac or whiskey or anything else."
Actually, Jen, the cheapest thing to do is fill a trashcan full of
Kool-Aid and dump in several bottles of grain.
Come to think of it, it would've been even cheaper (and made more
sense) if we simply just threw bricks at each others' heads.
Beer commercials are blatantly sexist, with fat ugly idiots
getting the hottest chicks in the world (remember the Swedish
bikini team?)
Actually, most of the commercials I see (the Coors ones are the
best this way) portray scenes full of young, hard-bodied people of
both sexes partying hard with their American Piss Beer. Which
conveys the message to the Average American Beer-Swilling Slob (I
obtained my membership card in 1988) that "if I drink (Miller,
Coors, Bud) I will magically transform from a 250lb. lardass into a
hot stud whom the girls can't avoid." Pretty good image-marketing,
I'd say.
I think the beer drinkers themselves bear some
responsibility for that. When was the last time you saw a guy show
off his ability to crush a cognac bottle with his
forehead?
There is exactly one beer worth drinking that comes in a can.
There is exactly one beer worth drinking that comes in a
can.
Really? Which one?
A 6 pack of ice cold Keystone Light is yummy on a 105 degree July afternoon after mowing the yard.
Timothy might be thinking of Guiness. For years Guiness in a bottle sucked. I think they might have fixed the problem though.
What's striking to me is that these commercials aren't even
aimed at children, the ones who the FTC is supposedly trying to
protect with content restrictions like this. They involve guys
sitting on roofs to get away from pesky wives and sitting around on
boats, things which obviously will not get any reaction out of
teenagers.
By pursuing penalties in these cases, the FTC is saying that not
only are your kids too stupid to see destructive activity on TV
without repeating it, but so are you.
Zero,
Guiness outside of Ireland and a few pubs in the US that serve a
lot of it, it well neigh undrinkable. I hear the cans with the
exploding carbination thing in the top has helped the taste some,
but once you have had the real thing in Ireland, the states stuff
never tastes the same again. I hate to be a snob about it, but its
true. I wish it weren't.
Timothy might be thinking of Guiness. For years Guiness in a
bottle sucked. I think they might have fixed the problem
though.
There are plenty of beers that use that draught-can technique
besides Guinness, though. I have no idea what he's talking
about.
"if it hadn't been for those commercials, no one would ever
have started drinking while sailing."
"In Western Australia they don't even know how to make that vital
piece of sailing-boat equipment, the gin and tonic." -P.J.
O'Rourke.
Sorry for the goofy delayed double post. I blame
beer-swilling server squirrels.
And wouldn't that make a good name for a band?
No, but it sounds like a good idea for a beer commercial...
Well, Idle is old enough that he might have been the one who
first said it, perhaps. I had a crush on him when I was a little
girl, and was rather upset to learn that all those Python episodes
had been filmed before my parents had even met, let alone had me,
which meant Idle was either way too old for me, or dead.
That's from the "Bruce's Philosophers' Song" skit, from "Live at
the City Center", which, IIRC, came out at least 30 years
ago.
So if they said it about Pete Coors some 25 years ago, they must
have got it from Eric Idle.
I always liked Carol Cleveland meself....
...the states stuff never tastes the same again. I hate to
be a snob about it, but its true. I wish it weren't.
John, many imports have a problem with freshness. The stuff just
ends up sitting in warehouses or on store shelves to long. I think
this might be what motivates some to license to North American
breweries.
The problem is that a significant part of a beer's flavor comes
from the local water, so no matter how great a beer might be in
Japan, Germany or Australia* it just doesn't taste the same when
made with LA, St Louis or Toronto tap water.
*but even in 'strylya Fosters is just another word for piss.
Well, Shiner's exactly halfway decent, and it comes in a can.
Modelo Especial's kinda ok, and it comes in a can. I think
Yuengling comes in cans, and it's alright. Then there's the
Murphy's, Boddington's, Old Speckled Hen, Guiness crowd, many of
which are good.
I think Guiness Extra Stout is better than the 'draught in a
bottle' version, but I don't really like Guiness that much.
Murphy's is more my style.
Still, no really beers are really great from a can.
Well, Shiner's exactly halfway decent, and it comes in a can.
Modelo Especial's kinda ok, and it comes in a can. I think
Yuengling comes in cans, and it's alright. Then there's the
Murphy's, Boddington's, Old Speckled Hen, Guiness crowd, many of
which are good.
I think Guiness Extra Stout is better than the 'draught in a
bottle' version, but I don't really like Guiness that much.
Murphy's is more my style.
Still, no really beers are really great from a can.
Well, Shiner's exactly halfway decent, and it comes in a can.
Modelo Especial's kinda ok, and it comes in a can. I think
Yuengling comes in cans, and it's alright. Then there's the
Murphy's, Boddington's, Old Speckled Hen, Guiness crowd, many of
which are good.
I think Guiness Extra Stout is better than the 'draught in a
bottle' version, but I don't really like Guiness that much.
Murphy's is more my style.
Still, no really beers are really great from a can.
But this will lead to lethargy, diabetes, numbness of the
feet, forgetfullness, antisocial behavior, a fat ass, a lack of
interest in volunteering at the orphanage, anti-civic involvement,
red-eye, blindness, dementia, and finally, death.
Seven down, five more to go.
Site comments/questions:
Media Inquiries and Reprint Permissions:
(310) 367-6109
Editorial & Production Offices:
3415 S. Sepulveda Blvd.
Suite 400
Los Angeles, CA 90034
(310) 391-2245