Reason Magazine
- reason.com
- reason.tv
- reason.org
- Donate
- Site Search:
Reason on Facebook
Reason on Twitter
Reason on YouTube
Reason RSSGet Reason E-mail Updates!
Manage your Reason e-mail list subscriptionsadvertisements
When Kites Kill
Reader Thom Burnett points to a new dread menace in Pakistan: killer kites. From Australia's The World Today show:
Every year in India and Pakistan dozens of people are killed by kites, most of them young children. The deaths are caused by special "dog-fighting" kite strings carrying razor-like metal strips and abrasives designed to slice through an opponents string but which can cause severe injury to bystanders and in some cases even decapitation.
In Pakistan alone, five children have died in the last four months and now in Punjab province police have been ordered to treat all such fatalities as murder....
Police in Punjab province have now been instructed to raid shops, which sell the banned deadly strings and make arrests.
Whole thing here.
|1.19.06 @ 9:21AM|#
or maybe it's just the latest tribal weapon to be employed in the fight against Predator drones...
Sandy|1.19.06 @ 9:25AM|#
Decapitation? I'm having a bit of a hard time believing that you can get enough velocity out of a kite to sever the spinal column.
|1.19.06 @ 9:36AM|#
How long before the Department of Homeland Security issues a warning that Pakistanis with kites and lawn darts may be targeting the US?
Unitended Humor Dep't.|1.19.06 @ 9:44AM|#
"This week, he announced that from now on death by kite will be treated as death by an offensive weapon, in other words, murder. "
Warren|1.19.06 @ 9:59AM|#
The mostly Muslim country of Pakistan is hysterical with fear of
jews going around cutting off children's heads. This story is the
sort of grotesque stereo type that...
What? Ooooooh. Well that's different.
nevermind.
|1.19.06 @ 10:39AM|#
I almost creamed someone with a kite once while I was at the
beach. It was unintentional, of course, but I was grateful that the
person was of the forgiving sort (and that she saw it coming in
time).
Be afraid of kites. very afraid.
Dan T.|1.19.06 @ 11:20AM|#
Keeping with my anti-libertarian theme today, assuming this story is true I submit that if people are willing to fly kites using razor-wire string, it proves that the nanny state is probably necessary and freedom is a bad idea.
|1.19.06 @ 11:23AM|#
10 comments so far and nobody has pointed out that "It's for the children". What the hell is happening to this comment board?
|1.19.06 @ 11:35AM|#
I love this idea. When I was a kid, I loved the Foghorn Leghorn cartoon in which the nerdy kid made a paper airplane that shot down Foghorn Leghorn's paper airplane. This is like that idea come to life. Those foreign kids are creative... tell John Stossel that not only are foreign kids doing better in school, it sounds like they are better at having fun, too!
s.m. koppelman|1.19.06 @ 11:39AM|#
Animal-protection groups should promote this in the US as a humane alternative to cockfighting and dogfighting.
Dan T.|1.19.06 @ 11:45AM|#
10 comments so far and nobody has pointed out that "It's for
the children". What the hell is happening to this comment
board?
I was going to offer that as a reply, but I didn�t want to be hit
with 10 responses claiming that the real victim here is the
Pakistani Razor-Kite Wire industry.
|1.19.06 @ 12:44PM|#
I must say: banning kites is asinine, but banning the use of razor wire or barbed wire for kite strings makes sense to me.
|1.19.06 @ 12:50PM|#
I must say: banning kites is asinine, but banning the use of
razor wire or barbed wire for kite strings makes sense to
me.
So you're in favor of the nanny state! This is a slippery slope
which will lead to me not being able to garotte anyone with razor
wire...and...actually that makes sense, I agree.
|1.19.06 @ 12:52PM|#
As a related but peripheral comment--read "The Kite Runner". It's one of the better books I read in 2005, and involves 'kite-fighting'. They made their own razor strings, by taking regular kite string and gluing ground glass to it.
|1.19.06 @ 12:57PM|#
Kite Runner is an excellent book.
On the bright side, at least the kites don't spray corn syrup
:)
|1.19.06 @ 1:05PM|#
Let us not be cultural imperialists. Whatever liability solutions our culture's deathsports that risk spectator injury employ (to wit, NASCAR; even baseball - I was present once when a man was concussed and evacuated from a fly ball) should provide analogs in Pakistan. At the very least given this new legal enforcement, kite competitors should move to wide areas of unoccupied ground, and notice is on them to either collect or imply releases from spectators; or manage their own attractive nuisances.
|1.19.06 @ 1:40PM|#
Cultural imperialists? Keith, I'm not suggesting we invade Pakistan and force them to fly kites the American way; I'm saying that a ban on kite-string razor wire sounds sensible to me.
Warren|1.19.06 @ 1:49PM|#
I was present once when a man was concussed and evacuated
from a fly ball
ROFL funny
|1.19.06 @ 2:28PM|#
I'm not seeing the anti-libertarian (maybe anti-anarchist, but who cares?) aspect of, say, a law banning waving the equivalent of hundred-foot-long blades in the air in public places. If someone injures or kills somebody else with such a kite, handle it as any other sort of injury or death (murder, manslaughter, etc. determined by circumstances).
R C Dean|1.19.06 @ 2:30PM|#
banning the use of razor wire or barbed wire for kite
strings makes sense to me
Since both razor wire and barbed wire are made out of metal, both
are far too heavy and inflexible to be used as kite string.
Whatever is going in Pakistan, I doubt it involves people being
beheaded by kites flown with razor wire.
|1.19.06 @ 2:33PM|#
RC, did you read the article? They'd put razors on their strings in order to hopefully cut the strings of their opponent's kites.
|1.19.06 @ 4:00PM|#
Dog-fights with kites has been going on for a long time, even with the razors. But I can't imagine how the kids are being killed by them--hurt, yes, but killed?
|1.19.06 @ 4:06PM|#
Larry--it depends on where exactly the razor cut them. Hit the right vein or artery, and it wouldn't take long for even the smallest cut to make a child bleed to dedth.
R C Dean|1.19.06 @ 5:51PM|#
I glanced at the article, Jennifer. It didn't say anything about
people using razor wire or barbed wire to fly kites, so I'm not
sure why you are calling for this practice to be outlawed.
There is a big difference, BTW, between kite string with a shard of
straight razor on it and barbed wire or razor wire.
|1.19.06 @ 7:15PM|#
RC--I said "razor wire" when I should have said "string with razors." Either way, I'd think a ban like that makes perfect sense, but banning kites altogether is insane.
|1.20.06 @ 10:00AM|#
Kite fighting in India and Pakistan has been around for a long
long time. The object is to cut your opponent's line thus knocking
his kite from the sky. Traditionally, the line near the kite was
coated with ground glass (the last 10 - 20 feet, not the whole line
'cause it would cut your hands while flying the thing). It appears
that lengths of razor wire have replaced the ground glass.
Kite fights take place anywhere and eveywhere including in crowded
cities. One person will send up a kite as a challenge and others
will respond.The competeors do not have to be standing near each
other. They can be blocks away and unable to see each other. All
that matters is that the kites are visable and have enough clear
air to maneuver. The kites are capable of moving very rapidly,
depending on wind conditions. The fliers control the movements by
slacking and then pulling on the lines. The kites were
traditionally made of tissue paper on split bamboo frames, but now
nylon, plastic and other materials may be used.
Having suffered a deep and painful cut on my left index finger from
the friction of a normal (unglassed, no razor witre, etc.) dacron
kite string while flying a small kite in a stiff breeze (I still
have the scar 12 years after it happened), I can easily understand
how bystanders could be cut and injured by these fighting kites.
Decapitated? Doubtful, as the kites are too small to exert that
much force. Now, if we're talking about Japanese fighting kites,
that's an entirely different story. People have gotten killed while
flying them (they get wrapped up in the lines and strangled or
lifted off the ground and dropped), but they're much bigger and
more powerful than the Indian fighters.
Site comments/questions:
Media Inquiries and Reprint Permissions:
(310) 367-6109
Editorial & Production Offices:
3415 S. Sepulveda Blvd.
Suite 400
Los Angeles, CA 90034
(310) 391-2245