How Medicaid and Obamacare Hurt the Poor - and How to Fix Them

"Most physicians can't afford to accept Medicaid" patients, says Dr. Alieta Eck, a primary-care physician based in Piscataway, New Jersey. "If you're getting paid about $17 per visit, it won't be long before you can't pay your staff or pay your rent."

Medicaid is the nation's health care system for the poor. It's funded jointly by the federal government and the states. Medicaid is either the first- or second-largest budget item in all 50 states and the program is slated for a massive expansion under President Obama's health-care reform law. Despite the program's huge and growing overall cost, reimbursements to medical providers are so low that many practices refuse to accept Medicaid patients, causing long waiting periods for treatment.

Eck and her husband, Dr. John Eck, are the founders of Zarephath Health Center, a free health care clinic in Somerset, New Jersey, where they each volunteers six hours per week taking care of poor patients. While the Ecks don't accept Medicaid in their private practice, some of the patients that show up at their free clinic are Medicaid recipients who can't find a regular doctor.

"The hardest thing for a Medicaid patient to do is get a doctor's appointment," says Avik Roy, who writes a health care blog at Forbes.com and is a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute. One consequence is that Medicaid recipients show up at emergency rooms at nearly double the rate of the privately insured, often with accute problems that could have been addressed earlier in a doctor's office. They're also more likely than both the privately insured and the uninsured to have late-stage cancer at first diagnosis.

After they've been diagnosed, it's also difficult for Medicaid patients to find qualified surgeons who will treat them. A University of Virginia study found that Medicaid patients were about twice as likely as the privately insured to die in the hospital after surgery. Even the uninsured were more likely to make it out of the hospital alive than Medicaid patients.

Despite the program's failings, in 2014 Obamacare will add millions of new patients to the program's rolls. "All too often, people who claim to care for the poor say, 'I'm going to give you a card that says you have health insurance and my work is done,'" says Roy. "But the hard part is making sure that person gets treated."

Obamacare was designed to expand Medicaid by about 17 million enrollees by 2021, but it likely won't meet that goal because the Supreme Court ruled that states don't have to participate in this component of the law in order to keep current levels of funding. So far, the governors of 19 states have come out against expanding Medicaid in their states.

So what's the best way to provide quality health care to the poor without spending more money that we don't have? Roy says the federal government should take the same money it spends on Medicaid and block grant it to the states so they can experiment with health care plans in which the patient is in control.

"Let them spend it on the doctor of their choice," says Roy. "Let people take the money and get the bureaucrats out of the way, and you'll find there's suddenly a lot more efficiency in the way people actually get health care."

Eck believes charity care could be a big part of the solution, if only the government made it easier for doctors to volunteer their time. She has worked with state Sen. Robert Singer (R-N.J.), who has co-sponsored a bill in New Jersey that would allow the state to cover physicians for malpractice in their private practices as a way of compensating them for volunteering. The bill is currently awaiting consideration by the state senate's health care committee.

"Every doctor I talk to says, 'I would do that in a heartbeat,'" says Eck.

In the meantime, when Obamacare takes full effect next year, charitable clinics like Eck's will be more essential than ever to pick up the slack for a social safety net that's already not working.

"I've been doing this for nine years," says Eck, "and I can honestly say that I come away feeling good that I was able to make a difference."

About 5 minutes.

Produced, shot, edited, and narrated by Jim Epstein.

Scroll down for downloadable versions and subscribe to Reason TV's YouTube Channel to receive automatic notifications when new material goes live.

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  • Fist of Etiquette||

    "A card that says you have health insurance is not health care..."

    By the time a voter figures that out, she's already pulled the lever.

  • UnCivilServant||

    They took away our lever voting machines, now they have very hackable, easily confused electronic machines.

  • meta||

    does the voter machine come with the elctronic magnifying glass to help old people?

  • rihanna568||

    Start working at home with Google! It's by-far the best job Ive had. Last Tuesday I bought a gorgeous Lancia Straton from earning $4331 this - 5 weeks past. I began this 7-months ago and right away started to earn at least $69, per-hr. I use this website,,
    http://goo.gl/4z9pn

  • well||

    If you think Patrick`s story is impressive..., five weaks-ago my son in law earnt $8989 workin 40 hours a month from their apartment and the're neighbor's mom`s neighbour done this for 3 months and made more than $8989 parttime on there pc. apply the guidelines on this site wow65.com
    (Go to site and open "Home" for details)

  • lap83||

    "the symbolism of providing all Americans with medical insurance"

    That sums up the "compassion" of liberalism. They are not at all concerned with the empirical results.

  • Lady Bertrum||

    Most liberal policies are based on the Field of Dreams philosophy. It doesn't need to have a basis in reality - just as long as it manifests as the appropriate appearance so they masterbate over their own awesomeness.

  • grey||

    Symbolism has always been important to the fascists. It's the marketing, not the results.

  • forestgombosi39||

    Peyton. if you, thought Jessica`s comment is super, on thursday I got a new Lotus Elan since I been bringin in $8898 this-past/month and-over, ten/k last month. this is definitely the nicest job I've ever had. I started this 8-months ago and pretty much straight away startad bringin home more than $69, per/hr. I use details from here wow65.com
    (Go to site and open "Home" for details)

  • Rhino||

    So you could say Medicaid is working if the plan is to kill off the poor.

  • JWatts||

    And break the taxpayers. It's a twofer.

  • RightofCenter||

    "I've been doing this for nine years," says Eck, "and I can honestly say that I come away feeling good that I was able to make a difference."

    About 5 minutes.

    The "It's a video so here's the length" comment always catches me off guard. I thought they were saying she feels good for about 5 minutes and then runs for the liquor cabinet to take away the pain.

  • Logical 1||

    "She has worked with state Sen. Robert Singer (R-N.J.), who has co-sponsored a bill in New Jersey that would allow the state to cover physicians for malpractice in their private practices as a way of compensating them for volunteering."

    If the state were to compensate you then you wouldn't be volunteering!

  • sarapaxton755||

    upto I saw the paycheck ov $7368, I have faith ...that...my sister was like actualie receiving money in their spare time online.. there neighbour had bean doing this 4 less than eighteen months and recently cleared the dept on their home and purchased a top of the range Lancia. this is where I went, http://www.app70.com

  • Moridin||

    I work for a personal injury attorney so I'm constantly exposed to the medical field (and the government unfortunately) and the medicaid patients I've seen all receive a shit ton of medical care. Is that a state thing maybe? I don't know.

  • richamor||

    We need a better system to help the poor

  • SQRLSY One||

    “We need a better system to help the poor”… If you believe in Government Almighty as a solution, maybe simply saying, “poor person accessing Government Almighty forfeits right to sue medical provider. Or must pay costs differential out of pocket to subsidize lawyer’s (lion’s) share of the kill”. Very simple step; slash costs, empower doctors, stop the waste of endless “defensive medicine”, as in, we must run endless series of tests before we pop that zit. But as for me personally, I don’t believe in medical care or even in FOOD for that matter, I believe in the Spiritual Power of taking care of my EFFIGY, where I may still retain some religious freedoms. Please see http://www.churchofsqrls.com/ to learn the Good News about Scienfoology…

  • blak53||

    up to I looked at the draft that said $9889, I didnt believe that my father in law actualie earning money part time from there pretty old laptop.. there moms best frend has been doing this for less than 1 year and recently repayed the mortgage on their mini mansion and got themselves a Chevrolet. I went here, http://www.wow92.com

  • Polo Ralph Lauren outlet||

  • tamamfuadi||

    Great explanation about this topic and i am new guy to this job thanks to sharing the wonderful articles Peluang bisnis vsi yusuf mansur

  • Federale||

    How about making the lazy poor work for their free medical care?

  • mynet sohbet||

    merhaba degerli tubidy şarkı indir kullanınıcıları; geçtigimiz günlerde sizlere tubidy sitesini tanitmiştik bu yazımız da sizlere tubidy mp3 indirme işlemini anlatacagiz. son günlerde bircok tubidy sitesini görmemiz kacinilmaz bazilari amötorce bazilari da ne kadar profesyönelce olsada indirme işlemi için sitelerini duyurup malesef indirme işlemi yapamiyoruz tubidy müzik indirme sitesi

  • GLK||

    Gee, I wonder where all the Mercedes, BMW, and Lexus driving Medicaid recipients will go for care? I'm very concerned for them.

Click here to follow Reason on Instagram

GET REASON MAGAZINE

Get Reason's print or digital edition before it’s posted online

  • Progressive Puritans: From e-cigs to sex classifieds, the once transgressive left wants to criminalize fun.
  • Port Authoritarians: Chris Christie’s Bridgegate scandal
  • The Menace of Secret Government: Obama’s proposed intelligence reforms don’t safeguard civil liberties

SUBSCRIBE