Short Circuit: An inexhaustive weekly compendium of rulings from the federal courts of appeal
Uncontrolled burns, false claims, and federal highway funds.
Please enjoy the latest edition of Short Circuit, a weekly feature written by a bunch of people at the Institute for Justice.
Victory! Millions of Americans want and need low-FODMAP foods, which are low in certain sugars that can cause debilitating stomach issues, aggravate irritable bowels, and worse. Fortunately, this week (following the Ninth Circuit's revival of our First Amendment challenge), the FDA lifted its ban on producers truthfully labelling their products "Low-FODMAP." Says IJ client Michelle Przybocki, who abides by a strict low-FODMAP diet after nearly dying from digestive complications, "I'm thrilled that the federal government is going to allow companies to start labeling their products as 'Low-FODMAP,' because this makes it easier for me to find foods that I know will not cause me digestive issues." Click here to learn more.
New on the Short Circuit podcast: Fancy some Elevenses? Serving up Eleventh Circuit refreshments in our #12Months12Circuits series. There's excessive bail in Alabama and excessive bar fees in Florida.
- Man has two DUIs decades ago in Massachusetts. He recently moved to New Hampshire and tried to buy a gun but was rebuffed due to the federal ban on felons buying such things. He challenges the ban on him buying and also owning a firearm. District court: Dismissed. First Circuit: Yeah, but he hasn't alleged an intent to possess a firearm that's been in interstate commerce, and, like, maybe a gun or two out there hasn't. Somewhere? Perhaps. So no standing. As for the whole purchasing thing, we guess there might be standing given you actually were told you couldn't buy a gun? So vacated and remanded.
- Cop killer spends 26 years in solitary confinement in Connecticut prison. Cruel and unusual? Jury: No. District court: Oof, that's a miscarriage of justice. Second Circuit: Grant of new trial affirmed.
- Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) regulations allow states to issue commercial driver's licenses to noncitizens as long as they were validly in the country when the license was issued and the licenses expire in no more than eight years. New York issues licenses for an initial period of five years. In 2025, the FMCSA reinterprets its regulations to require that the licenses expire when lawful status expires and withholds $73 mil in federal highway funds from New York. Second Circuit: But you agree that requirement isn't in the regulations, right? FMCSA: Well not, like, literally. Second Circuit: Then you, like, literally lose.
- Another week, another decision involving prediction market Kalshi. This time the Fourth Circuit (per curiam) holds that the Dodd-Frank Act does not preempt Maryland law on sports betting. Concurrence 1: That's because, whether or not these transactions are swaps, there's no preemption. Concurrence 2: No, it's because they're not swaps. Dissent: They are swaps (except for parlays and props), and they are preempted.
- Under the False Claims Act of 1863, ordinary citizens can bring fraud claims in the name of the United States, but the United States (the real one) has substantial flexibility to take over and dismiss the claims. Fifth Circuit: As properly happened in this lawsuit concerning alleged improprieties in Pfizer's COVID-19 vaccine trials. Concurrence 1: Hey, I know we've allowed this for a long time, but these kinds of lawsuits seem to violate at least three constitutional provisions. Concurrence 2: That is a wonderful point and deserves en banc consideration in an appropriate case.
- The district court enjoined Mississippi's online age-verification law as applied to certain websites run by members of the plaintiff trade association. However, the Fifth Circuit tells us, "the district court did not perform the fact-intensive analysis necessary to substantiate why the Act is unconstitutional as applied to each member website." Vacated for a closer examination of those specific sites. (Don't worry district court staff, they're all pretty safe for work. Depending on whom you follow.)
- Does Tennessee's current sex offender registration system violate the Ex Post Facto Clause? Sixth Circuit: Regarding the named gov't defendant, all that official does is say publicly that someone is an "OFFENDER AGAINST CHILDREN." It's not like that's punishment or anything. Now, as for the parts of the law that severely restrict where the plaintiffs can live and who they can talk to, it looks like you sued the wrong guy.
- Man slumped over in driver's seat of running, parked pickup truck is incoherent, scuffles with Sullivan County, Tenn. deputies who try to pull him out. An officer shouts, "Gun!" and fires twice, apparently missing, and then a second officer shoots the man, killing him. The gun was in the man's right pocket, and his right hand was holding the head rest above and behind him when he was shot. District court: No qualified immunity. To trial thus must go. Sixth Circuit (2-1, unpublished): Reversed. (But remanded for some ruminating on state-law immunity.)
- Relying on unsworn tips and boilerplate language, St. Louis detective obtains warrant for no-knock raid. SWAT officers flashbangsmash into home and kill sexagenarian who was partially blind, partially deaf, and reliant on caregivers—and wasn't dealing drugs. Officers say he fired a handgun at them, but that's hotly disputed. Eighth Circuit: Not genuinely disputed, though.
- In 2022, U.S. Forest Service controlled burns in New Mexico become very much uncontrolled, after which Congress passes a law providing expedited compensation to those affected outside normal tort litigation. But does it include compensation for noneconomic damages? Tenth Circuit: Nope, any ambiguity is construed against a waiver of sovereign immunity. Dissent: The law compensates for all "injuries," and that's not limited to the economic kinds.
- Friends, one of our little soapboxes here is that it's wrong and ahistorical that gov't officials who lie on the witness stand are immune from civil liability, leaving the zero chance of a perjury charge as the best chance of accountability. Eleventh Circuit (unpublished): Don't say zero!
- Per the Eleventh Circuit (unpublished), if there's a dead body inside a home, officers don't need a warrant to enter. Which seems okay? But it's tough news for this plaintiff, who could have been shown a little more courtesy by Boynton Beach, Fla. officers after the loss of her daughter, who'd been on in-home hospice care.
- And in en banc news, the Second Circuit (over fiery dissentals) will not reconsider its ruling that three Amish schools in New York need to comply with a state law that nixed religious exemptions from vaccination requirements (on pain of $2k/student/day fines).
- And in more en banc news, the Third Circuit (over an incandescent dissental) will not reconsider its ruling that a church, whose shrine-building plans are seemingly being thwarted in retaliation for its advocacy on abortion, doesn't get a preliminary injunction allowing it to build just yet.
- And in additional en banc news, the Third Circuit (9-3), will not reconsider its opinion that a New Jersey congresswoman indicted for assaulting federal agents at an immigration detention facility is not protected by legislative immunity.
- And in further en banc news, the Fifth Circuit (over a searing dissental) will not reconsider its ruling that it was objectively reasonable for a Houston SWAT officer to shoot a man, who'd already been shot eight times but was still moving, in the back of the neck/head, killing him.
Friends, if a federal official violates your constitutional rights, your options for being made whole by money damages have been all but extinguished in recent years, leaving the feds with something akin to absolute immunity for all kinds of misconduct and misdeeds. But there has to be some avenue for accountability. So here at IJ, we're pushing back, not only on the late-lamented Bivens cause of action, but also on the too-narrowly construed Federal Tort Claims Act. And then, of course, there's the traditional source of accountability that the Founders would have recognized (and that the Supreme Court's Bivens skeptics preferred): state law causes of action, like California's traditional tort system and the state's Bane Act. All of which were on the table at oral argument in the Ninth Circuit this week, where we're happy to report we had an engaged, cross-ideological panel. Click here to learn more.