Obama Puts a Happy Face on a Federal Mess
Aside from that, Mr. President, how did you like the play?
â€œWhat we know,â€ said President Obama to a business group a few days ago, â€œis that our â€" our fiscal problems are not short-term deficits. Our discretionary budget, that portion of the federal budget that isnâ€™t defense or Social Security or Medicare or Medicaid, the entitlement programs, is at its smallest level in my lifetime, probably since Dwight Eisenhower. We are not lavishly spending on a whole bunch of social programs out there.â€
You could call this Obamaâ€™s version of the old joke: â€œAside from that, Mrs. Lincoln, how did you like the play?â€ Saying â€œwe are not lavishly spending on a whole bunch of social programsâ€ â€" aside from Social Security and Medicare and Medicaid â€" is like saying the Titanic had a great voyage, aside from the iceberg. We spend so much on those three social programs that, if current trends continue, outlays on them plus interest on the national debt will consume every last federal dollar in a little more than a decade.
But then it isnâ€™t really just those three programs, is it? From 2000 to 2012, federal spending on food stamps increased 400 percent. Not double. Not triple. Four hundred percent. So aside from the big three plus food stamps, weâ€™re not lavishly spending on a whole bunch of social programs.
Federal housing assistance has grown from less than $30 billion (in constant dollars) in 2000 to nearly $60 billion today. Aside from that, though, weâ€™re not lavishly spending on a whole bunch of social programs.
The federal government has 79 different means-tested anti-poverty programs providing food assistance, educational aid, housing, cash transfers, utility assistance and other social services. Aside from that, though, we are not lavishly etc. etc.
There are 47 different federal job-training programs. But aside from that. . . .
Obama also mentioned defense spending. Adjusted for inflation, defense spending rose 64 percent from 2002 to 2011. But â€" well, you know.
The president says discretionary spending is at the smallest level â€œin my lifetime, probably since Dwight Eisenhower.â€ (Obama was born only a year and a half after the Eisenhower administration ended.) Discretionary spending might have fallen as a share of the budget, but that is only because so-called mandatory spending â€" i.e., spending driven by formulas Congress can change if it chooses â€" has grown so rapidly. It certainly isnâ€™t smaller in real terms.
Using constant 2005 dollars, defense discretionary spending in 1962 was $52.5 billion. Last year it was $670.5 billion.
In 1962, non-defense discretionary spending was $19.5 billion. Last year, it was $615.5 billion.
Aside from that, though, the president was absolutely right.
Obamaâ€™s aside-from-that approach extends well beyond fiscal analysis. When insurance companies began canceling policies that did not meet new requirements under the Affordable Care Act, critics pointed out that the president had said people could keep their insurance if they liked it â€" not just once, but dozens of times.
Fed up with being quoted accurately, Obama tried to weasel out of his repeated promise by saying: â€œWhat we said was, you can keep [your plan] if it hasnâ€™t changed since the law was passed.â€ (PolitiFact gave him a pants-on-fire rating for that howler.) Translation: Aside from that, you can keep your plan.
Back in the spring, Obamaâ€™s Director of National Intelligence, James Clapper, was asked during congressional testimony if the NSA collects â€œany type of data at all on millions or hundreds of millions of Americans.â€ Replied Clapper: â€œNo sir.â€
We now know the NSA collects metadata about millions of Americansâ€™ telephone calls. Also, millions of contact lists from personal email accounts. Also, millions of buddy lists from instant-messaging services. Lots of audio and video chats, photographs and documents, too. It even had a test project to collect data on American citizensâ€™ cell-phone locations.
Aside from that, though, it doesnâ€™t collect a thing.
â€œThe President does not have power under the Constitution to unilaterally authorize a military attack in a situation that does not involve stopping an actual or imminent threat,â€ Obama told The Boston Globe in 2007. Aside from the occasional attack on Libya, that is.
Obama â€œis a disciple of the pay-as-you-go approach to federal spending that helped produce a budget surplus in the â€˜â€™90s,â€ said the Detroit Free Press when it endorsed him in 2008. This will be the first fiscal year the deficit has come in under $1 trillion. Aside from that, though, the statement was pretty accurate.
â€œWeâ€™ve restored Americaâ€™s standingâ€ in the world, the president-elect said in 2009. With the exception of Japan and Russia, Americaâ€™s favorability ratings across the world have dipped since then, according to a 2012 Pew survey of global attitudes. The â€œMuslim public remains largely criticalâ€ and in China, â€œconfidence in the American president has declined by 24 percentage points and approval of his policies has fallen 30 points.â€ But aside from that. â€¦
â€œSea Level Rise Accelerating Faster Than Initial Projections,â€ reported Climate Central last year. Aside from that, Obama was correct to claim his 2008 clinching of the Democratic nomination marked the moment when â€œthe rise of the oceans began to slow and our planet began to heal.â€
According to Esquire, â€œ20 years from now, weâ€™re going to look back on this time as a glorious idyll in American politics, with a confident, intelligent, fascinating president riding the surge of his prodigious talents from triumph to triumph.â€ According to MSNBCâ€™s Chris Matthews, Obama has â€œnever done anything wrong.â€ According to Newsweekâ€™s Evan Thomas, the president is â€œstanding above the country. Above â€" above the world. Heâ€™s sort of God.â€
Set against such puffery we have the rather damning record of the past five years. But aside from that, itâ€™s completely true.