Surveillance

A Tribunal Confirms the U.K. Issued a Secret Surveillance Order to Apple. But the Privacy Fight Is Not Over.

The confirmation comes more than a year after reporters revealed the U.K. government ordered Apple to let the U.K. access users’ encrypted data.

|


A U.K. tribunal has finally confirmed something privacy advocates have long known: The country's Home Office gave Apple a secret order, which reportedly demanded backdoor access to encrypted user data.

On Thursday, a tribunal said that the U.K. government issued Apple a technical capability notice (TCN). These orders compel "companies to build and/or maintain technical capabilities to respond to lawful requests for data."

According to The Washington Post, which first exposed the order on February 7, 2025, the TCN targeted Apple's Advanced Data Protection (ADP) feature, an opt-in setting which largely protects users' iCloud data with end-to-end encryption. 

As the Post's Joseph Menn noted at the time, the order had serious privacy implications for users beyond the U.K. 

"If the U.K. secures access to the encrypted data, other countries that have allowed the encrypted storage, such as China, might be prompted to demand equal backdoor access, potentially prompting Apple to withdraw the service rather than comply," Menn wrote.

Menn also reported that a cybersecurity consultant advising the U.S. said it was "shocking that the U.K. government was demanding Apple's help to spy on non-British users without their governments' knowledge."

Two weeks after the Post article, Apple confirmed that it was no longer offering its ADP feature for new U.K. users. Later, in August 2025, former Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard posted that the U.K. "agreed to drop its mandate for Apple to provide a 'back door' that would have enabled access to the protected encrypted data of American citizens and encroached on [Americans'] civil liberties." But in September 2025, the U.K. Home Office issued a second TCN to Apple, reported the Financial Times. This time, the order only applied to British citizens' data, according to the outlet.

Although the U.K.'s original demands were widely reported on and even cited by U.S. lawmakers, including Sen. Ron Wyden (D–Ore.) and Rep. Andy Biggs (R–Ariz.), who referenced the first order in a letter to Gabbard, the U.K. Home Office neither publicly confirmed nor denied the existence of a TCN to Apple, keeping in line with its national security policy.  

But in this week's judgment, the U.K. Investigatory Powers Tribunal found that revealing the existence of the TCN would not damage national security. The tribunal noted that "there was extensive media coverage both before and after that decision to the effect that a technical capability notice had been given," and "that coverage was consistent with public statements made by the US Director of Intelligence and with statements attributed to the President of the USA."

As the judgment notes, in August 2025, Gabbard made public statements about the matter and outlets including the Financial Times had already published information about an order to Apple. "There may be some information that could be disclosed publicly without damaging national security. It is not, however, practical to determine the precise boundaries now," the tribunal noted. 

Still, Akiko Hart, director of the U.K. civil liberties group Liberty, which brought a claim against the Home Office over its secret order alongside Privacy International and two individuals, called the judgment a "victory for transparency."

"Encryption protects the things that matter most to us – including our family photos, personal messages, bank details and health records," she added in a statement. "At a time of growing cyber threats, governments should be rising to the challenge to strengthen digital security protections rather than opening the door to hackers and hostile actors."

This week's judgment is a small victory for privacy advocates, but ideally, the U.K. Home Office would not seek backdoor access to users' encrypted data in the first place. The U.S. is not a perfect defender of privacy, but the U.K. government, which regularly arrests its own citizens for social media posts, is in no position to ask companies to erode users' privacy. Liberty will continue to challenge the U.K's TCN in court, and a final hearing is expected in 2027.