Antitrust

No, Google Is Not Forcing Schools To Adopt AI

Antitrust hawks think the tech firm agreeing to disable AI features in schools is a ploy to “coerce schools into adopting AI.”

|


Google recently announced that it will disable search and AI features by default on K–12 student accounts. Access to Gemini, its general AI chatbot, Gemini Notebook, Gemini in Classroom, and Google Search "will be entirely off for K-12 student accounts until school administrators explicitly turn them on," according to the company.

This decision follows a late-October letter to Google CEO Sundar Pichai coauthored by Sens. Richard Blumenthal (D–Conn.) and Josh Hawley (R–Mo.) in which the senators expressed concern about Google's integration of AI in Google Classroom and Chromebooks, Google's low-cost laptops that run Google's web-based operating system and are used by 93 percent of U.S. school districts. The senators were also concerned about the inability of educators to disable AI features, such as AI Overviews in Google Search.

While the company has disabled its Gemini suite and Google Search for student accounts by default, it will not allow educators to disable AI within Google Search because the two are "deeply integrated." In a June 2025 interview with Semafor, Elizabeth Reid, Google's vice president and head of Search, rejected the distinction between AI or Search, "AI enables search to do more of the things it always wanted to do," which is, "organize all the world's information." AI Overviews accomplishes this by allowing users to ask one complex question "rather than breaking [their] question[s] into multiple searches," according to Reid.

U.S. District Judge Amit P. Mehta's recent dismissal of Penske Media Corporation's (PMC) tying claim against Google reinforces the argument that Google Search and AI Overviews are interrelated features of the same product. Mehta rejected PMC's allegation that they are two separate products and found that "the more plausible inference is that Google Search and AI Overviews have the same use case: providing answers to users' search queries."   

Nevertheless, critics are furious. Shortly after Google's announcement, former Federal Trade Commission Chair Lina Khan accused Google of "using its search monopoly to coerce schools into adopting AI," a point echoed by New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani almost verbatim. Similarly, Blumenthal told Education Week that Google is "blocking schools from using Google Search unless they opt into their AI overview."

But this criticism confuses a preference for a different product with an antitrust violation. Herb Hovenkamp, an antitrust legal expert and professor at the University of Pennsylvania, is right to note that "antitrust is not a tool for making firms redesign products in order to satisfy each buyer's wishes." Firms generally have discretion to decide how to design and package their products; the fact that some customers would prefer a different version does not, by itself, establish an antitrust violation. For example, despite its market-leading position in the cola market, Coca-Cola is not obliged to offer a version of Coke without carbonation simply because some consumers might prefer one.

While Google does not allow users to disable its AI features in Google Search, educators can give students an AI-free search experience by allowing them to use rival browsers and search engines, even on ChromeOS. Google's Chromebooks come with Chrome preinstalled and set as the default browser. However, users can install and set any browser listed on the Google Play Store—including Mozilla Firefox and Microsoft Edge—as the default.

Users can also easily choose one of four alternative search engines in Chrome: Microsoft Bing, DuckDuckGo, Brave, and Ecosia—the last three of which permit users to disable AI features. Indeed, Brave advertises its search engine on precisely this basis: "Google says that if schools want to use Google search, they need to use its AI too….Brave Search makes it easy to turn off AI answers." Educators who don't want students to see AI Overviews can leave Google Search restricted and permit students to use one of the search engines that allows AI features to be disabled.

Google is integrating features like Guided Learning—its AI-powered personal learning companion—into Google Search because it wants to help students learn to solve problems, not just give them the answers. A recent study found that the tool produces substantial and statistically significant positive learning outcomes. In effect, Google is democratizing access to expensive tutoring services. It's not, in the words of Blumenthal, "putting profit ahead of young peoples' best interest."

AI detractors may be unhappy about AI's growing adoption, but antitrust law should not become a tool for slowing down technological progress simply because some customers prefer yesterday's products.