CPS Is Investigating an Influencer Because Her Son Flinched in a Video

Hannah Hiatt isn't the first parent to face child welfare investigations sparked by an internet mob.

Social media influencers who post their children online often face their share of criticism. But now, if their audience disapproves of their parenting decisions, they could also find themselves being investigated by child protective services (CPS).

The latest parent to face a CPS investigation for showing innocuous footage of her children is Hannah Hiatt, an influencer who has built an audience of half a million followers for videos detailing her life as a nurse with two young children. Last month, Hiatt posted a video in which her toddler-aged son appeared to flinch slightly as his father walked toward him to hand him a box of ice cream mochi. While most wouldn't think much of the clip, many viewers seized on the moment, arguing that it was proof that Hiatt and her husband were abusing their children.

The now-deleted video went viral, with many users making videos of their own debating the meaning of the clip. Angry internet users also found another video of Hiatt, in which her husband flicked her son's hand away from some french fries, again claiming that this too was evidence of physical abuse. 

"The flinch breaks my heart," one TikTok user commented.

"Why are people like this allowed to procreate," posted another.

An Ogden, Utah Police Department spokesperson told People that an investigation had been opened against Hiatt and her family following "numerous reports through Child Protective Service and police."

While the investigation is ongoing, and it remains unclear whether Hiatt will be found guilty of any wrongdoing, she is far from the first person to face a CPS investigation after upsetting an internet mob. In April, influencers J.D. and Britney Lott faced a child welfare investigation after Reddit users became convinced that the newborn was being medically neglected—though a medical examination confirmed that the child was healthy. And in 2021, a father who tweeted jokes about his daughter's struggles to use a can opener ended up getting a visit from CPS after an enraged internet mob reported him for alleged child abuse.

Anonymous child abuse hotlines make internet outraged-induced reports like these more likely to happen. Designed to help authorities catch more abuse, anonymous reporting hotlines can end up attracting vindictive bad actors. Concerns about false reports have led states like Texas and California to remove their anonymous reporting mechanisms.

Impassioned internet users often argue that they're trying to protect vulnerable children by reporting their parents to CPS, but it's hard to believe them when the evidence of alleged abuse is so minor. More often than not, these mobs are driven more by the rush of seeing someone they dislike lose their kids than by any genuine concern for protecting a child.