Reason Magazine

Site Search

A Tank of Trouble

A large reservoir of ill-will has built up in response to a 1992 federal mandate that decreased the maximum water-holding capacity of new household toilets from 3.5 gallons to a mere 1.6. The problem: Completing the task often takes 3 gallons or more.

"Let's get the government out of our bathrooms," says Rep. Joe Knollenberg (R-Mich.), who is sponsoring a bill to flush the federal mandate. Soon after the 1992 law passed, Knollenberg says his constituents started complaining that their new toilets weren't up to the job. He got a sense of the problem's scope when a plumber told him of a developing black market in contraband commodes. After it was featured on a couple of radio talk shows, the issue burgeoned.

Just ask humorist Dave Barry. After devoting a column to low-flow toilets in July 1997, he was deluged with letters, "some far more detailed than I would have liked," he wrote in a follow- up piece. He also got a call from a contractors' association eager to demonstrate the efficiency of a brand new 1.6 gallon model. Barry purchased the toilet and couldn't be happier. "If there's [something it] can't handle in one flush, I have not personal knowledge of it," he wrote.

So has the columnist been bought off? "They ought to repeal their dumb-ass law," he says. "The federal government should have nothing to do with toilet sizes. Nothing. Zero. Ever."

Help Reason celebrate its next 40 years. Donate Now!
Send this article to:

More Articles by Michael W. Lynch

Related Stories (Congress, Environment)

  • Christmas in October
    The secret history of the bailout bill Michael Flynn (10/2)
  • The Rational Environmentalist
    Bjorn Lomborg on the priorities that should come before global warming Ronald Bailey (10/1)
  • Bailout Bums
    Libertarian-minded Republicans are caught with their pants down as Wall Street panics the Capital City David Weigel (9/25)

Latest Articles on Reason Online

LATEST POSTS ON REASON'S HIT & RUN