Raise Concerns With the FBI and They May Harass You For Years

US GovtUS GovtSyed Abid Iqbal, a Florida resident, may have gotten more than he bargained for when he voluntary talked to the FBI. After tipping the agency off about some concerns, Iqbal alleges that he found himself in an interrogation room for six hours and subject to years of surveillance. He has pressed charges against the agents who he claims violated his Constitutional rights.

On December 2, 2008 Iqbal went to the Jacksonville FBI office to express “concerns about his friends and acquaintances,” according to a document from the U.S. District Court Middle District Florida. Courthouse News writes, “What Iqbal did not know at the time was that the FBI agents believed his concerns were related to their ongoing investigation of a 'planned attack,'” and believed that he might know more than he was letting on and that he sent a suspicious email to the Transportation Security Administration (TSA). Their claim has never been substantiated.

A few days thereafter, the FBI requested that Iqbal return to the office, at which point he met more agents. They requested he take a polygraph test. Agent Terry Wetmore interrogated him, asking about the TSA email. Iqbal denies having sent it, and alleges that Wetmore told him he failed the test and couldn't leave until he admitted to emailing the TSA. Then, Wetmore refused to let Iqbal leave, “subjected [him] to enhanced interrogation technique[s],” while threatening to “charge him with a criminal offense.” This went on uninterrupted for six hours, but Iqbal's problems didn't end there.

The court document details his claims about their actions thereafter:

FBI agents began conducting warrantless electronic surveillance of Plaintiff at his home. The agents monitored Plaintiff’s personal and business phone conversations, emails, and text messages. Plaintiff alleges that the agents additionally used his “personal phone . . . as a transmitter which permitted recordings anytime anywhere Plaintiff was present.” The surveillance lasted until January 2011, and agents confirmed that the information collected included the structure and contents of Plaintiff’s house, the content of his personal and business calls, and his travel information.

The agents' continued harassment allegedly also included threats of violence, revocation of his American citizenship, and deportation. “The physical and psychological pain inflicted by the FBI allegedly led Iqbal to lose his job as an IT professional and enter bankruptcy,” explains Courthouse News.

Judge Roy Dalton Jr. has dismissed several of Iqbal's charges, stating that his claim that excessive force was used against him failed to demonstrate a “specific constitutional right allegedly infringed by the challenged application of force.” According to Dalton, the plaintiff's claim that the FBI violated his Fifth Amendment right to due process falls short because the agents' interrogation techniques were was not so coercive that they could “shock the conscience in the constitutional sense.”

However, the case will move forward. The judge acknowledged that the “alleged warrantless intrusion into that privacy violates the Fourth Amendment” and Iqbal's right to “privacy in conversations and religion practices conducted in his own home.”

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  • sarcasmic||

    On December 2, 2008 Iqbal went to the Jacksonville FBI office...

    Never a good idea under any circumstances.

  • some guy||

    What's the first (and only) rule about talking to the cops?

  • sarcasmic||

    Don't.

  • crazyfingers||

    Hopefully others will learn from this. Do not talk to government agents under any circumstances. If arrested, shut up and ask for your lawyer. They are not your allies. They exist to do you harm.

  • Bam!||

  • Fist of Etiquette||

    ...the agents' interrogation techniques were was not so coercive that they could “shock the conscience in the constitutional sense.”

    Not these days.

  • Tim||

    I for one welcome our new FBI overlords.

  • ||

    Winning hearts and minds, as always.

    I assume this guy learned his lesson. Maybe he can help inform others.

  • CE||

    ...his claim that excessive force was used against him failed to demonstrate a “specific constitutional right allegedly infringed by the challenged application of force.”

    So you have no Constitutional right to not be tortured when you're trying to help defend your country?

  • CE||

    As usual, even a judge forgets the 9th Amendment.

  • WC Varones||

    If you see something, don't say something!

  • Donut-san||

    "Whatever you say, say nothing, when you talk about you know what."

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Pns4Aq-RNs

  • Almanian (sans exclamation pt)||

    was not so coercive that they could “shock the conscience in the constitutional sense

    *facefuckingpalm*

    Jesus mother FUCK this judge sucks balls. Also, I hoped Osama, Jr. learned his lesson, as noted by sarc and others above.

  • Paul.||

    So, he went to the feds, on his own accord, and agreed to return to the station for further questioning and didn't have a lawyer in tow.

    What's the lesson we've learned from this incident today, children?

  • Killaz||

    Snitches get stitches by being the cop's bitches!

  • sarcasmic||

    Not everyone has the coin to pay a lawyer to accompany them for an afternoon?

  • Almanian (sans exclamation pt)||

    +1 can ya spare a brother some change?

  • ||

    Why would you ever talk to the police? Especially if you're some kind of America-hating Muslim terrorist or something.

  • dinkster||

    There is a reason that black neighborhoods put up a wall of silence. Maybe this fella will become a future libertarian.

GET REASON MAGAZINE

Get Reason's print or digital edition before it’s posted online

  • Video Game Nation: How gaming is making America freer – and more fun.
  • Matt Welch: How the left turned against free speech.
  • Nothing Left to Cut? Congress can’t live within their means.
  • And much more.

SUBSCRIBE

advertisement