We Were So Much Younger Then, We're Crueler Than That Now

David Weigel | November 16, 2007

I used to think I was an expert on 1920s Mississippi Supreme Court decisions, but Is That Legal? blogger Shertaugh takes the crown:

In a case called Fisher v. State, 110 So. 361, 362 (Miss. 1926), Mississippi's highest court ordered the retrial of a convicted murderer because his confession was secured by a local sheriff's use of the water cure.

Here's the court:

The state offered . . . testimony of confessions made by the appellant, Fisher. . . [who], after the state had rested, introduced the sheriff, who testified that, he was sent for one night to come and receive a confession of the appellant in the jail; that he went there for that purpose; that when he reached the jail he found a number of parties in the jail; that they had the appellant down upon the floor, tied, and were administering the water cure, a specie of torture well known to the bench and bar of the country.

But Rudy Giuliani disagrees!