David Weigel | May 17, 2007
Isaac Chotiner's post about the looming immigration compromise is short enough to quote:
I did enjoy Mark Krikorian's take on the issue:
The logic behind this claim is simple: If we legalize a lot of people, some of them will likely be terrorists. Anyway, I think Krikorian's logic should be extended to all sorts of public policies. For instance, lawmakers who support clean air laws should realize that they are really just voting for terrorists to breathe clean air!If the Senate is going to repeat the 1986 "grand bargain" (amnesty up front for promises of enforcement in the future), every senator needs to understand that he is voting to give legal status to terrorists.
I'd add that Krikorian's theory was beaten with lead pipes and tossed in an unmarked grave by the two GOP frontrunners at the last debate. John McCain:
My friend, the people that came -- that almost attacked us at Fort Dix -- thank God they did not -- those people didn't come here across our borders, they came with visas that were expired. So we've got to enforce our border. That's our first and foremost priority. But we also have to have a comprehensive solution and it has to be bipartisan.
Rudy Giuliani:
The reality is, we've got to be sensible about immigration. If we do the kinds of things that some of the people here are talking about, this country's going to be in greater danger; it is going to be more insecure; we're going to face a situation in which terrorists like the Fort Dix people, three of whom were illegal, can find a big underground to hide in.
Farewell, "terrorists will sneak across the Rio Grande an' nuke us!" theory. We hardly knew ye.
Help Reason celebrate its next 40 years. Donate Now!
Try Reason's award-winning print edition today! Your first issue is FREE if you are not completely satisfied.
Mock this all that you will, but I understand that some terrorists pay taxes. How can lawmakers continue to support taxation?
Ron Paul responds articulately to the Giuliani campaign of
lies.
http://digg.com/2008_us_elections/Video_Ron_Paul_blows_away_Rudy_s_lies
If Krikorian is going to support war in Iraq to keep America safe, he needs to understand that he supports keeping terrorists in America safe.
Terrorist productivity and short-term memory is also improved since they're banned from smoking pot. Legalize it, and the next 9/11 dies in the addled mind of Abdul Chong.
those people didn't come here across our borders, they came
with visas that were expired. So we've got to enforce our
border.
Wait...what?
Considering the latest screaming about how Cigarettes Are Evil,
maybe we should just ship the "terraists" a crate of Marlburos and
wait for all of them to die of cancer.
Just whenever I think I can go back to the Democratic party, the
nanny-staters pull something like this and I have to bang my head
against the desk again.
What does FAC mean?
Federal Audit Clearinghouse
Forward Air Control
Frequently Answered Concerns
?
Hugh,
I had that same reaction. Shouldn't the conclusion be that we need
to enforce our immigration policies and deport those who have
expired visas?
Obviously we need to take away everyone's air, then. If we make an exemption for the terrorists we make an exemption for everyone, therefore no exemptions.
Grumpy Realist,
maybe we should just ship the "terraists" a crate of Marlburos and wait for all of them to die of cancer.
Yes! Like
General Tapioca did to the Picaros!
Hugh,
You dowdified that McCain quote. Keep reading: That's our first
and foremost priority. But we also have to have a comprehensive
solution and it has to be bipartisan.
Politics based on 30 second soundbites is bad, but politics based
on 15 second summaries of those 30 second soundbites is worse.
Wow, I'd never expected a Politician, Republican, or anyone named Giuliani to come up with a response that cogent. I hate the man, but Rudy's response to this particular question was nothing short of Presidential.
I don't hate Rudy (Yikes - I just typoed that as 'rUday' - I really hope that isn't precient) as much as some of the other also-rans (anybody who doesn't believe in evolution gets a 'dude it's 2007' award) but, it is refreshing to hear that kind of sense coming from ANYWHERE in the current gaggle of candidates (and I probably need one more parenthetical remark - there we go).
Wide angle crane shot. Nightime. Heavy rainstorm. Intermittent
lightning flashes illuminate the broken and bloody body of the
undefined acronym FAC laying in a pool of
rainwater mixed with blood at the backdoor of
WEIGEL's warehouse hide-out and undefined acronym
stash.
DE STIJL enters from bottom right, filthy and
staggering from the beating he's just taken. He approaches
FAC's body and slowly falls to his knees and
throws his head back into the falling rain throwing his arms out
into a anguished Christ-like pose.
DE STIJL: WEIIIIIIIIGELLLLLL!
Slow zoom in during scream. Slow fade out.
Highway,
If you mean FAQ, that's not a typo on a QWERTY keyboard. Q and C
are pretty far apart.
A false homophone then?
But that doesn't explain the misusage of a FAQ where you list, you
know, questions that many people have asked about
the topic before and then provide an answer.
Q: Are terrorists human?
A: Terrorists, being terrestrial, breathe air just like everyone
else.
Q: I heard that illegal aliens are always mean.
A: Whoever told you that was a total liar. Just like other mammals,
illegal aliens can be mean OR
totally awesome.
Site comments/questions:
Media Inquiries and Reprint Permissions:
(310) 367-6109
Editorial & Production Offices:
3415 S. Sepulveda Blvd.
Suite 400
Los Angeles, CA 90034
(310) 391-2245