Jeff Taylor | July 27, 2006
Why? From the Hoosier state:
State homeland security officials have warned Vermillion County to stop using electronic emergency message boards to advertise fish fries, spaghetti dinners and other events.
Homeland Security, which bought the 11 signs for $300,000, said the county could risk losing federal money. The county has stopped using the signs for the community announcements, and commissioners plan discuss the matter next week.
The president of the County Commissioners said Homeland Security is interfering with local governing.
"We run the county," Commissioner Tim Wilson said. "We make decisions to run the county on what's best for us. Did we misuse (the signs)? Or did we just run the county as we saw fit?"
Local officials say residents enjoyed the advertisements.
Goddamn.
Help Reason celebrate its next 40 years. Donate Now!
Try Reason's award-winning print edition today! Your first issue is FREE if you are not completely satisfied.
Our phone here in the bowels of Sinincincinnati rang at 2:30 AM
this morn for an "amber alert."
I know it's all about the children, but fuck 'em at that time in
the AM.
The toxicology lab in my state is overcrowded and takes almost a
year to turn around specimens, with dramatic delays in autopsy
reports and forensic investigations as a result.
In the same building is a lab funded by the homeland security
department to perform analyses in case of attack by chemical
weapons. It consists of nine people who sit around all day doing
nothing, and hundreds of thousands of dollars of analysis
equipment, sitting idle.
Just imagine how many emergencies were kept from the public so they could advertise their little fish fries, spaghetti dinners and other events.
AML:
PLEASE tell me you are yanking the wank there -- there just cannot
be that kind of disconnect between actual, real, legitimate
government functions and a homeland security porkfest.
"We run the county," Commissioner Tim Wilson said. "We make
decisions to run the county on what's best for us."
Ha ha ha. When you take the Fed's coin, you dance to their tune.
This is the insidiousness of the Federal assistance
carrot-and-stick game: as soon as you accept the assistance, they
can tell you what to do (*cough* public schools *cough*).
Meaning to say "you" rather than "yoi". And to hell with this
thing that prevents me from quickly correcting my self-inflicted
errors.
n an effort to curb malicious comment posting by abusive users,
I've enabled a feature that requires a weblog commenter to wait a
short amount of time before being able to post again. Please try to
post your comment again in a short while. Thanks for your
patience.
I don't see what's wrong with it, If it's for "Homeland
Security" use only, it will rarely, if ever, be used. No need for
it to just sit there.
If you take the federal handout, they want power over you in
return.
They used federal highway funds to blackmail the state to raising
their drinking age to 21.
They got their hands on the schools systems through funds they
give.
If you take the handout, you owe them. It's like the mob.
If you take the handout, you owe them. It's like the
mob.
Federal money is like heroin!
Well, Vermillion County, Indiana was very high on the target list. But I hear they have signs? Call it off. Curse you again Homeland Security!
These signs are to be used only in emergencies, to notify the
public of threat levels.
If past practice is any guide, that would mean just before an
election.
I'm not sure if either of these premises is true, but I think
both may be:
1. The damaging effects of a disaster will be less if emergency
information is communicated to motorists via these signs.
2. Motorists who are used to seeing advertising on these signs will
be less likely to notice emergency messages (banner blindness, as
web marketers call it).
If both statements are true, why shouldn't Homeland Security
require that they be used as intended?
The framing of the post seems a little hyperbolic. I would save the "hate my country" and "Goddamn" for bigger fish. I mean, if *this* makes you hate your country and swear, I'd hate to see your reaction to, say, an average post at The Agitator. I envision your head exploding in flames.
Not here to defend Homeland security pork but since when does a supposed libertarian publication endorse using $3 Million in federal funds to to advertise fish fries? Have we stepped through the looking glass?
JAT,
Nope, I'm not making it up. They just sit there, calibrate their
machines, and wait for a ricin attack that will never come. To do
anything else would be a misappropriation of federal funds.
eb, the looking glass has stepped through us. You ain't the only one to notice.
You hate your country?!!
Commie, commie! Traitor to our country!
That'll show you Taylor!
Ramon Colombo, director of Vermillion County Emergency
Management, said sponsors of a spaghetti dinner fundraiser and an
elementary school carnival reported larger-than-normal turnouts
after message board ads.
So apparently peopleare reading the signs, not unusual for
community notices in a small town.
And running the notices is a good way to make sure the signs are
working and to maintain the proficiency of the operators.
Otherwise you end up with Fed mandated "This is a test of the
emergency broadcast system" messages, that folks learn to
totally ignore.
[S]ince when does a supposed libertarian publication endorse
using $3 Million in federal funds to to advertise fish
fries?
Well from a libertarian perspective, I'd say, the 3 Million is
already a waste of federal funds, so it might as well be used for
something else. That's my take.
Not here to defend Homeland security pork but since when
does a supposed libertarian publication endorse using $3 Million in
federal funds to to advertise fish fries? Have we stepped through
the looking glass?
It's bad enough to have spent the $3 mil. The kicker is to spend
the money and never put the toy to use. I'll bet what happens is
that the sign is never actually used to warn of security
emergencies, and is replaced with a bigger, better, costlier system
that will be just as good at never actually warning anyone of
security emergencies.
Hey, by preventing the VFDs from advertising their spaghetti
fund-raiser by using the signs, which are just sitting there, doing
nothing, the Feds are starving our vital first-responders of
the funds they need to do their important jobs!
I know, my fingers almost cramped-up as I typed that.
In other voluntary fundraising by food news, a local district
attorney in Wisconsin is planning on supplementing his dept.'s
budget by holding bratwurst fries. It will probably work. We love
our sausage, even if it's chorizo.
Kevin
"So apparently peopleare reading the signs, not unusual for
community notices in a small town.
And running the notices is a good way to make sure the signs are
working and to maintain the proficiency of the operators.
Otherwise you end up with Fed mandated "This is a test of the
emergency broadcast system" messages, that folks learn to totally
ignore."
How about this, when a county can order up free signs that are
designed for emergency use, and use them to advertise their
fundraisers, perhaps they'll be motivated to request them even
though they really have no need.
Has anybody stopped to wonder where all this money that has been
wasted on unneeded crap with HS has gone? I would guess a lot has
beeen to counties that have Fish Fry signs sitting in the town
square, or their own variation of the same situation.
In a small town near me they used $300,000 of
Homeland security money to build a new social hall. I guess
everyone can run there when the terrorist hoards come running over
the Pennsylvainia hilltops. I can sleep good at night in the
knowledge that I am being "protected" from terrorism by competent
(idiots)security personnel. I hope that they raise my taxes for
more "protection".
So unless there's a gigantic flashing red light on top that
only activates when something important actually happens, they'll
just drive on by without reading it like they do every other
day.
I understand, but state, local, and federal government is like the
boy who cried wolf anyway so even things like Amber Alerts are
pretty much ignored by the populace. A posted message is at best
going to be twenty or thirty minutes behind the emgergency response
personnel anyway. All a sign is going to do is reduce a little bit
of inconvenience. It's like the old civil defense tests on TV years
ago, just a prompt to change the channel. "If this had been an
actual emergency, TV and radio news would have been all over it and
there wouldn't be an irritating sound for 60 seconds."
Vermillion County knows it's all BS, the scary part is the sheer
number of ideological nutjobs in the DHS.
Hit & Run should change it's name to "Mountians & Molehills"...you guys apparently can't tell the difference.
"5 Year Old Tiffany Smith has been abducted by her father and is
believed to be heading for the state line. Looks like she'll miss
out on the buckwheat pancake breakfast at the Elk's Lodge
tomorrow!"
Amber's been pretty successful in smaller states where the route
over the border are limited. Her in CT we've had a few abducters
give themselves up after seeing their car description flash on the
overhead sighs multiple times, and sitting in traffic doesn't help
either.
Troll Dan---
If they can't tell the difference, how would they differentiate in
order to name the blog both words? If you think an apple and an
apple tree are the same, how would you have two words for it?
Oh.
So I guess no one in Libertopia needs to be reminded when and where
to find the government-endorsed weekly fish fry.
You selfish, heartless fucks.
Like many irresposible small towns they see $$$ (grants) and go
after it, "if you don't use it someone else will", grab and run.
Someone probably got kudos for getting the sign. If you extrapolate
that small town to D.C. you would have the same wasteful crap going
on and they would be still saying "we run the countRy". Greed,
quest for power is innate.
The article is void of information and full of drama, even the
title.
yeah. "Thanks" there DanT. Just because it's flat in this part
of the midwest, and a highway off ramp doubles as a "ski resort",
no need to rub it in.
hrumphingly,
VM
Ruthless - are you serious about the amber alert thing? You actually get phone calls from an automated service about this?
Troll Dan---
If they can't tell the difference, how would they differentiate in
order to name the blog both words? If you think an apple and an
apple tree are the same, how would you have two words for
it?
What I'm suggesting is that the H&R bloggers know that both
mountians and molehills exist, they just can't distinguish between
the two.
I think "Osama" has it right. Why the fuck does Vermillion
County have $300,000 worth of DHS money for emergency signs in the
first place?
Here's what your $300,000 is doing: in the event of a terrorist
attack, people will be warned and presumably instructed on where to
drive to get away. I'm guessing the people there know the one or
two roads that lead out of town already, and most probably have
cars equipped with radios. But I could be wrong.
As far as the likelihood of a single life being saved (or rather,
prolonged) among it's 16,500 population, Vermillion county has
Indiana's largest concentration of citizens 65 and over, and
contains such targets as Cayuga, Highland, and Fairview Park.
Info
about the county here Another case where I fear the poor
judgment of my own government more than I do the evil intentions of
the terrorists.
"What I'm suggesting is that the H&R bloggers know that
both mountians and molehills exist, they just can't distinguish
between the two."
Nothing quite like being condescended to by a dumbass.
TERRE HAUTE...INDIANA [Terre Haute melts off of
map]
Aww, and they were just about to get a new public library!
In the rural area where I live, the volunteer fire departments
depend for hose and Nomex money on fish fries, spaghetti feeds, and
of course the world-famous Redwood Coast Fire Deparment Pig and
Lamb Roast.
In other words, those community events could well be contributing
to emergency readiness.
Hoake, Crimethink, you get major props for that reference. One
of the best movies. Ever.
(points appreciatively in recognition of a great play)
Wouldn't the obvious raison d'etre for the Vermillion County
signs be to direct a horde fleeing a Sears Tower collapse (or St
Lawrence cargo ship suitcase nuke) from the Chicago area?
Why did DHS let the county have control of these signs when it
seems like either the state Dept of Transportation or a multistate
consortium such as: www.i95coalition.org would be both more logical
as well more focused on the goal?
Um, Keith - I see from your email that you're in Western NY. I
am a Hamilton grad, so I think I know where you're coming
from.
Newport, Indiana is nowhere near Chicagoland. It is about 150 miles
away or so. It's on I 74 (or thereabouts). ("About three hours away
by car")
And, similarily, Newport (and Vermillion County,Indiana) is nowhere
near the Lake.
It would be a good westward-ho evac route out of Indianapolis,
since it's around 80-100 miles away. It's also close to Chambana
(about 50 miles or so, max), so horny Illini could swarm to the
hooters in Indy! Or Gen Con!
It's also about 150 miles from our capital in Springfield,
so...
(The Authorities would like to assure you that the Moose has been
beaten with a beenie baby as a result of his glib posting.)
Finally, looking at the last line in the article, "The Cayuga
volunteer fire department, where Wilson is chief, used the messages
to promote its fish fry." I can assure that it's a different Cayuga
that you're used to.
(The Authorities wish to assure you that we've now bludgeoned him
severely with his blow-up Noam Chomsky Doll, and we've taken away
his leather-bound copy of "Heather Has Two Mommies" (the edition
with the sweaty pillow fight scene on page 69. He will behave
henceforth!)
But the original point is this: Vermillion County, Indiana is no
where near any evac route from Chicagoland.
(signed)
A Whomped Moose
What I'm suggesting is that the H&R bloggers know that
both mountians and molehills exist, they just can't distinguish
between the two.
Again, this makes no sense; how can you know that two separate
things exist and not be able to distinguish between the two? If I
am looking at both and am unable to distinguish between the two,
then I would call them the same thing.
A little nitpick. The signs were funded by the Chemical Stockpile Emergency Preparedness Program (CSEPP) which is a DoD Program, not a Homeland Security (DHS) Program. The program predates DHS by at least a decade. They are there to alert resident if there is an emergency at Newport Chemical Depot.
"We run the county," Commissioner Tim Wilson said. "We make
decisions to run the county on what's best for us. Did we misuse
(the signs)? Or did we just run the county as we saw
fit?"
I'd have a lot more sympathy with the guy if his main argument
weren't, "But we're the government! How can anyone question what we
do?"
Perhaps a better justification would be something like this:
"Holy crap, what's with these guys? They spent $300 grand on
emergency signs in Sleepy McPodunkville, and they don't want us to
put them to use in between the once-in-a-blue-moon emergencies.
It's not as if we're going to advertise fish-fries when the nukes
are dropping, is it?"
Blue moons (two full moons in the same month) are considerably more common than homeland security emergencies.
Well, in terms of terrorist homeland security issues, you're right, but I figure these things are also tied into the Emergency Broadcast System, which goes off all the time for weather alerts.
For me, the best thing about these forums is that they sometimes bring me news I might otherwise never hear about, and provoke thoughts and perspectives outside the ordinary. This thread has got me thinking, really, really seriously, about fried fish for supper tonight.
"We run the county," Commissioner Tim Wilson said. "We make
decisions to run the county on what's best for us."
Sorry, Indiana, but that's MY sign you're screwing around with. Not
yours. Where do I live? Seattle. That's why it's MY sign.
However, if we want to sit down and have a civil debate about
whether or not the signs should have been bought in the first place
(they shouldn't have ) I'm happy to discuss that, too.
Local officials say residents enjoyed the
advertisements.
So what? Local residents here in Seattle are probably going to
enjoy a $4 billion(scratch), $6 billion(scratch), $10
billion(scratch), $15 billion tunnel project called:
Big Dig II, The Big Dig Goes to Washington... on the backs of
people in Indiana. Does that make anyone in Indiana feel any
better?
reminds me of the simpson's episode, where they get the sign
telling the nuclear reactor's condition...
"the jokes on them, if the plant goes nuclear, there won't be any
electricity to power the sign!"
I hope this letter finds it's way to you. (Maybe they could put
it up on the message boards?) Forgive me love for the shame I've
put you through, and all the tears. Hang on, love, to the memories
of those happy years.
Red lights are flashing around me.
Good Lord! It looks like they found me!
Indiana wants me, Lord I can't go back there.
Site comments/questions:
Media Inquiries and Reprint Permissions:
(310) 367-6109
Editorial & Production Offices:
3415 S. Sepulveda Blvd.
Suite 400
Los Angeles, CA 90034
(310) 391-2245