Reason.com

Print|Email

New at Reason

Jonathan Rauch joins the chorus calling for strongman government in Iraq.

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment or disable your ability to comment for any reason at any time.

|6.11.04 @ 1:20AM|

The comparison to Japan doesn't work. They had no experience with democracy, either, but they had one major incentive to tow the line and do things the way MacArthur told them to -- the atomic bomb.

The old joke goes if you want to get the mule to do what you tell it to, first whack it in the head with a two-by-four, just to get its attention. Pulverizing (literally) two major cities with nuclear bombs got their attention; after that the citizens were much more inclined to behave as instructed.

Maybe the problem in Iraq is we haven't been fierce enough. Instead of negotiating over Falujah, perhaps we should have flattened it with daisy cutters, just to "get their attention." Then the democratization of the rest of the country might have fallen into place much more readily. At the least, the so-called insurgents would think a lot harder about their chances for long-term success.

Of course, we may also have ignited a serious Middle East war . . .

Jim Henley|6.11.04 @ 1:49AM|

Japan did have a Democratic tradition. What Japan had that Iraq doesn't is a plausible alternative fear to American control - the Sovs were perched on the Sakhalin Islands and right across the straits, and it was understood that but for American occupation there'd be a Soviet one and nobody wanted that. Cf. Western Germany.

There's no bogeyman that consoles Iraqi nationalists that "it could be worse."

I have an ironclad precept called the Jimmy Johnson Principle, after the retired football coach. The JJP is that anyone who says that "my problem is I've been too nice" is ALWAYS mistaken.

|6.11.04 @ 4:37AM|

Also, "What Japan had that Iraq doesn't is" a direct attack on the United States, but nobody in the thick of all the shoulda-woulda-coulda-bombed-their-asses rhetoric wants to hear that anymore.

Karl Gallagher|6.11.04 @ 5:49AM|

So we'll get a nice, stable strongman in Iraq, like the Sauds and Mubarak, who produced the 9/11 highjackers? Hardly solves the problem we went there for. Trying to keep a nice stable status quo got us Al Qaeda.

Sam Grove|6.12.04 @ 1:41AM|

All this talk of government, democracy, etc. and so little talk of markets.
Markets rule!

|6.12.04 @ 10:01AM|

Jonathan Rauch's piece manages the near-impossible: he only quotes neocons and their fellow-travelers on the Middle East, and yet manages to pull sense out of their advice. True acrobatics.

|6.12.04 @ 10:01AM|

Jonathan Rauch's piece manages the near-impossible: he only quotes neocons and their fellow-travelers on the Middle East, and yet manages to pull sense out of their advice. True acrobatics.

|6.12.04 @ 11:19AM|

"strongman" = "our dictator"
didn't we trty this already? isn't turning out very well...

|6.13.04 @ 1:50AM|

Well, we might just have to tolerate a strongman government due to regional realities. With Iran on the verge of going nuclear, and Saudi Arabia a mess, a pro-American presence in the region is crucial, even if it means tolerating a government that doesn't respect the rights of its citizens.

I mean, look how well it worked in the 80's when we used Saddam Hussein as a counter-weight against Iran! Oh, wait a minute...

OK, OK, I've got it: Remember how well it all worked out in Afghanistan when we gave weapons to any religious zealot eager to fight the Soviets? Sure, Afghanistan didn't evolve into a free society after the Soviet withdrawal, but at least no threats to US security ever emerged in Afghanistan. Right?

Um, ok, never mind.

elle macpherson picture|11.4.04 @ 7:54PM|

Wallpapers nude pamela anderson photo clip. Video softcore ashlEe SimpsoN PictuRE StRipPed. Undresses pussy ShIRlEy tEMPLe mOVIE hARDcorE. Fake uncensored JULIANNE MOORE NUDE. Softcore home video ANNA NICOLE SMITH PICTURE. Sex fake AVRIL LAVIGNE NUDE. Videos naked REESE WITHERSPOON PICTURE. Having sex breast JENNIFER LOPEZ NUDE. Clips fake BRITNEY SPEARS NAKED SEXY. Pictures xxx pamela anderson video. Photo blowjobs CINDY MARGOLIS NUDE TITS. Tape sex JENNIFER LOPEZ PICTURE. Tape sexy ALIcIA Key pIc Ass. Wallpapers stripped BRITNEY SPEARS PHOTO. Fake gallery brITNEy SPeArS POSTER pOsTErs. Naked porn christina aguilera photo beautiful. Poster tape BRITNEY SPEARS PIC. Sex porn paRIS HiLTOn moVIe. Photo nipples ChrIStInA MILIaN PIC HArDCOrE. Undresses having sex STEPHANIE MCMAHON NUDE. Videos hardcore britney spears nude tape. Photos stripped LINdSAy LoHAN nUDE piC HavInG SEx. Nipple pictures MICHELLE VIETH VIDEO NAKED. Fake blow job JENnIFeR ANiSTON nUdE Blow job. Tit undressed JeNNIfEr loPEz PHOTo. Strip tease sexy jeNnIFEr ANiSToN picTUrE CliP. Nipples xxx anna kOurNikovA pICTurE UNdResSEs. Hardcore wallpapers CHARIsMa carpENTeR pLayBoy. Boobs home videos christina aguilera dirty breast. Home video videos JESSICA SIMPSON PHOTO PUSSY. Undressed porn elisha cuthbert picture. Sex bikini britney spears fake. Tits bikini ANGELINA JOLIE WALLPAPER. Clip pic annA KoURNikova nuDE. Tape naked sienna guillory nude striptease. Hardcore boobs jeNna jamEsoN mOviE DiRTy. Undressed clip HALLE BERRY PIC HARDCORE. Boobs home videos adriana lima pic. Tits pussy vIdA GUerRa wALLpaper. Sexy naked alYsSA MiLANo piC. Nipples nude bRItNey Spears pICTurE. Naked dirty JENNIFER GARNER NUDE. Pic blowjobs rose mcgowan nude. Tape video NATALIE PORTMAN NUDE GALLERY. Clips video ELISHA CUTHBERT WALLPAPER. Pic blow job ashlee simpson pic sex. Movies undressed SANDRA BULLOCK NUDE. Tape tit HALLE BERRY PHOTO BIKINI. Sex tit BRITNEY SPEARS SEXY. Softcore breast pARis HIlTOn sex TaPE. Tape tits heATHeR GrAham nUdE PlAybOy. Striptease hot jennifer lopez naked. Videos striptease VanIty FAIr MoviE. Naked blowjobs victoria silvstedt nude pic. Undresses picture tyra banks pic dirty. Pussy photos CHRISTINA MILIAN PICTURE NIPPLES. Uncensored undresses carmen electra naked. Breast posters Tara ReId NUDe. Nude dirty BRItNeY spEARS BOoB FakEs. Picture fakes britney spears wallpaper. Nipples sex shaNiA Twain Nude seX. Undresses ass TAwnee sTONE video. Galleries picture drew bArrYMoRe nuDE clIP. Undresses playboy KelLy rIpa NuDE piCTUre. Boobs picture jenna jameson picture. Videos galleries serena williams pic sex. Softcore nipples annA kOUrnIKovA nAkED. Tit clip britney spears xxx pics. Sex gallery lindsay lohan picture. Gallery ass hiLArY dUFF Nude. Nude nude BriTnEY SPEaRs NEW VIdEo HaRDCoRE. Naked porn ELISHA CUTHBERT NAKED CLIP. Movie blowjobs genEva SWiTzERLAND hotEl CLips. Boobs video brooke burke pic photo. Wallpaper xxx PARIS HILTON WALLPAPER. Uncensored undressed brITNEy spEArS WeddiNg Pic. Posters galleries anna kournikova pic movie. Posters porn CaTheriNE bElL NUde ToplEss. Nude home videos ALYSSA MILANO NUDE. Video blowjob lindsay lohan nipple slip porn.

elle macpherson picture|11.4.04 @ 7:55PM|

Wallpapers nude pamela anderson photo clip. Video softcore ashlEe SimpsoN PictuRE StRipPed. Undresses pussy ShIRlEy tEMPLe mOVIE hARDcorE. Fake uncensored JULIANNE MOORE NUDE. Softcore home video ANNA NICOLE SMITH PICTURE. Sex fake AVRIL LAVIGNE NUDE. Videos naked REESE WITHERSPOON PICTURE. Having sex breast JENNIFER LOPEZ NUDE. Clips fake BRITNEY SPEARS NAKED SEXY. Pictures xxx pamela anderson video. Photo blowjobs CINDY MARGOLIS NUDE TITS. Tape sex JENNIFER LOPEZ PICTURE. Tape sexy ALIcIA Key pIc Ass. Wallpapers stripped BRITNEY SPEARS PHOTO. Fake gallery brITNEy SPeArS POSTER pOsTErs. Naked porn christina aguilera photo beautiful. Poster tape BRITNEY SPEARS PIC. Sex porn paRIS HiLTOn moVIe. Photo nipples ChrIStInA MILIaN PIC HArDCOrE. Undresses having sex STEPHANIE MCMAHON NUDE. Videos hardcore britney spears nude tape. Photos stripped LINdSAy LoHAN nUDE piC HavInG SEx. Nipple pictures MICHELLE VIETH VIDEO NAKED. Fake blow job JENnIFeR ANiSTON nUdE Blow job. Tit undressed JeNNIfEr loPEz PHOTo. Strip tease sexy jeNnIFEr ANiSToN picTUrE CliP. Nipples xxx anna kOurNikovA pICTurE UNdResSEs. Hardcore wallpapers CHARIsMa carpENTeR pLayBoy. Boobs home videos christina aguilera dirty breast. Home video videos JESSICA SIMPSON PHOTO PUSSY. Undressed porn elisha cuthbert picture. Sex bikini britney spears fake. Tits bikini ANGELINA JOLIE WALLPAPER. Clip pic annA KoURNikova nuDE. Tape naked sienna guillory nude striptease. Hardcore boobs jeNna jamEsoN mOviE DiRTy. Undressed clip HALLE BERRY PIC HARDCORE. Boobs home videos adriana lima pic. Tits pussy vIdA GUerRa wALLpaper. Sexy naked alYsSA MiLANo piC. Nipples nude bRItNey Spears pICTurE. Naked dirty JENNIFER GARNER NUDE. Pic blowjobs rose mcgowan nude. Tape video NATALIE PORTMAN NUDE GALLERY. Clips video ELISHA CUTHBERT WALLPAPER. Pic blow job ashlee simpson pic sex. Movies undressed SANDRA BULLOCK NUDE. Tape tit HALLE BERRY PHOTO BIKINI. Sex tit BRITNEY SPEARS SEXY. Softcore breast pARis HIlTOn sex TaPE. Tape tits heATHeR GrAham nUdE PlAybOy. Striptease hot jennifer lopez naked. Videos striptease VanIty FAIr MoviE. Naked blowjobs victoria silvstedt nude pic. Undresses picture tyra banks pic dirty. Pussy photos CHRISTINA MILIAN PICTURE NIPPLES. Uncensored undresses carmen electra naked. Breast posters Tara ReId NUDe. Nude dirty BRItNeY spEARS BOoB FakEs. Picture fakes britney spears wallpaper. Nipples sex shaNiA Twain Nude seX. Undresses ass TAwnee sTONE video. Galleries picture drew bArrYMoRe nuDE clIP. Undresses playboy KelLy rIpa NuDE piCTUre. Boobs picture jenna jameson picture. Videos galleries serena williams pic sex. Softcore nipples annA kOUrnIKovA nAkED. Tit clip britney spears xxx pics. Sex gallery lindsay lohan picture. Gallery ass hiLArY dUFF Nude. Nude nude BriTnEY SPEaRs NEW VIdEo HaRDCoRE. Naked porn ELISHA CUTHBERT NAKED CLIP. Movie blowjobs genEva SWiTzERLAND hotEl CLips. Boobs video brooke burke pic photo. Wallpaper xxx PARIS HILTON WALLPAPER. Uncensored undressed brITNEy spEArS WeddiNg Pic. Posters galleries anna kournikova pic movie. Posters porn CaTheriNE bElL NUde ToplEss. Nude home videos ALYSSA MILANO NUDE. Video blowjob lindsay lohan nipple slip porn.

Most Popular Stories

advertisements

Get Reason E-mail Updates!

Manage your Reason e-mail list subscriptions

Site comments/questions:

Media Inquiries and Reprint Permissions:


(310) 367-6109

Editorial & Production Offices:

3415 S. Sepulveda Blvd.
Suite 400
Los Angeles, CA 90034
(310) 391-2245