Is Crazed Super Bowl Security a Taste of America To Come?

Think of a TSA checkpoint that goes on, forever.

(Page 2 of 2)

So...does any of this actually make anybody safer?

Don't count on it.

TSA checkpoints at airports are rightly mocked for providing security theater—lots of show with no improved safety. The Department of Homeland Security's Inspector General, the Government Accountability Office, and private researchers have all called out the TSA for its failure to assess the validity of any of its procedures and its general uselessness. A 2007 review of TSA methods published in the British Medical Journal found “no comprehensive studies that evaluated the effectiveness of x ray screening of passengers or hand luggage, screening with metal detectors, or screening to detect explosives.”

"One might wonder if the Transportation Security Administration has found the right balance between safety and convenience with its notoriously burdensome airport screening procedures," notes the New York Times editorial board.

But that TSA model of checkpoints, hardened perimeters, and lots of creepy scrutiny has grown in vogue after attacks at public events like the Boston Bombing, no matter that it's a lousy model to begin with. After the Boston tragedy, security expert Bruce Schneier told Reason, "The most dangerous part of any airplane flight, movie-theater outing, or marathon run is still the drive to and from the venue. By far. Terrorism almost never happens, and we shouldn’t let the media’s endless replaying of the details fool our brains into over-magnifying the threat."

Unleashing cops and surveillance on a street fair miles from a popular football game is only marginally nuttier and more pointless than doing the same at the game itself. If street fairs are considered public events worthy of high-security responses, where do you draw the line? Can you draw a line?

After a September 2013 terrorist attack at a shopping mall in Nairobi, Kenya, Interpol Secretary General Ronald Noble pointed out that security requires a choice between creating hardened perimeters around every possible target in their endless number, or leaving people to respond to situations as they happen and provide for their own defense. The truth is, he pointed out, "you can't have armed police forces everywhere."

Looking at the failure of security at the Nairobi mall, Noble asked, "'Where would you have wanted to be? In a city where there was gun control and no citizens armed if you're in a Westgate mall, or in a place like Denver or Texas?" Noble, who was Undersecretary for Enforcement of the United States Department of the Treasury before he took the Interpol job, strongly suggested that letting people take responsibility for their own safety—specifically, he referred to "armed citizenry"—made more sense than what we're now seeing at the Super Bowl.

It also, incidentally, might also allow for a game that's more enjoyable to attend, and less like visiting a politician in prison.

But the United States, one of the few nations in the world that generally respects its citizens' right to defend themselves, is the scene of massive security theater around Super Bowl XLVIII, echoing similar, if lower-key, build-ups at other public events in the post-9/11 world. If the U.S. won't step away from the intrusive and ultimately pointless security measures sucking the joy from public gatherings, where will the trend end?

Once you're deploying surveillance cameras and an "amazing arsenal of security initiatives" for themed street fairs, you're only a step away from making that part of daily life.

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  • Adam.||

    you're only a step away from making that part of daily life.

    That's the point, slowly and methodically increasing exposure to government scrutiny until it's everywhere. It's exactly what they want.

  • steve baker||

    Stand up to terrorists now, or bend over for anal probes tomorrow.

  • kris713||

    what Patrick said I'm shocked that a mom able to get paid $5552 in four weeks on the internet. did you read this site link ..,.,..,.,.,., jobs80
    (Go to site and open "Home" for details)

  • Anvil||

    Which is why "Progressives" love it so much

  • MiloMinderbinder||

    What no comments, yet?

    J.D. is my current favorite Reason writer. And he nails this completely.

    MLB already said wanding will be mandatory starting in 2015. I went to the courthouse last week to look up a will. More metal detectors. It also provided employment for a couple of that county's finest to sit on their ass all day while demanding that citizens empty their pockets.

    What's next malls?

    Well that's it I am done with pro sports. Maybe if enough people feel this way and act, the owners will get the message. Probably not.

  • XM||

    Going to stadiums to watch games is fun once in a while, but the hassle with parking and trying to leave the parking lot is something I can do without.

    I don't approve of the TSA, but it's only a matter of time before someone detonates a home made bomb. The last two shooters arrived at the scene with a shotgun and makeshift bombs.

  • Robert||

    All the better for the Cheapskate Pro Football League I'm going to start up some day. Security will be your own business, subject to traditional legal duty of care & bailments.

  • Robert||

    Both the Men's & Women's divisions will play according to the rules I draw up for at least the 1st 3 seasons. After that I'll let a panel make revisions annually. Other than to please me, however, the idea will be to entertain people in the stands and get them out of there in a reasonable amount of time. Teams will all be owned by the league though operated somewhat autonomously, and costs will be held way down compared to the majors.

  • Fisthardcheese||

    Vince McMahon called this the XFL.

  • miriambenderpy||

    my best friend's ex-wife makes $87 an hour on the internet . She has been without a job for 6 months but last month her paycheck was $15058 just working on the internet for a few hours. Read Full Article
    http://www.cash46.com

  • Robert||

    Miriam ben Derp-y? Grinning out loud!

  • Greenthumb||

    Wow! 173 = few. Do people dumb enough to click on that link actually exist?

  • The Last American Hero||

    The Line goes ever on and on
    Down from the spot where it began.
    Now far ahead the Line has gone,
    And I must follow, if I can,
    Pursuing it with eager feet,
    Until it joins some larger queue
    Where many paths and errands meet.
    And whither then? I cannot say.

    --J. R. R. Tolkien

  • miriambenderpy||

    my best friend's ex-wife makes $87 an hour on the internet . She has been without a job for 6 months but last month her paycheck was $15058 just working on the internet for a few hours. Read Full Article
    http://www.cash46.com

  • Paul.||

    200 "temporary" surveillance cameras to ensure that dirty deeds remain undone at the big game.

    As evidence has shown, despite the fading protestations of our 'pro-camera' set, the surveillance cameras do little to prevent crime, but do admittely help in identifying the perpetrators after the fact.

  • Jerryskids||

    I have it on good authority that all these extraordinary security precautions are there just to make sure no Cleveland Browns fans slip into the game.

  • Marshall Gill||

    At this point, every step toward tyranny is probably a good thing. We are going to have to "take our medicine" at some point and I often think that we might as well get on with it. It isn't until things get worse, and then really worse, that they will get better.

  • Paul.||

    I sometimes wonder if people in North Korea think the same thing.

  • IT||

    Let's ask Rodman.

  • Robert||

    Of course, tyranny will lead to pushback against it, the result of which will be less tyranny than when it hits bottom, but more than now.

  • DenverJay||

    sure, because once the modern surveillance state gets settled in, it will be SOOO easy to rebel

  • Almanian (yeah, I said it)||

    Yes

  • iEagleHammer||

    The security got ridiculous jacked up at last years Indy 500 too... that event easily has 3 times as many people compared to the superbowl. It was pretty ugly, half of the fans waited in line for an hour and didn't make it through the gates in time for the start of the race. Then the flood gates open and they stormed through in one giant wave. People were ANGRY, I wouldn't be surprised to see a similar debacle.

  • Robert||

    Listen to Andy & Ken encountering the security at a hotel in Jersey City where the Broncos are staying:
    http://wfmu.org/flashplayer.ph.....hive=94117 or
    http://wfmu.org/listen.m3u?sho.....hive=94118

    Not clear whether that's the Denver or Denville, NJ Broncos, nor whether this is for the Big Game or just the semi-finals in the worldwide championship tournament. And don't forget next week's program, which they recorded that evening at the same place.

  • AlmightyJB||

    9/11. Big Brother's wet dream come true.

  • steve baker||

    "Terror", from the Latin "terrere", meaning "to frighten".

    The Terrorists won.

  • Mark22||

    I think you are going to see a massive exodus from cities over the next few decades. They had a brief renaissance because travel by car became tedious for a while. With improved transportation, delivery, and communications, there is less and less reason to live in cities.

  • IT||

    This won't be allowed (or made difficult by Agenda 21 regs), so do it now. Just not near me please.

  • ecw||

    We have totally succumbed to Cheney's "One-Percent Doctrine" under which even the tiniest perceived threat warrants whatever expenditure (usually huge) government/business decides to spend to eliminate that often fictitious threat.

  • GroundTruth||

    Well, maybe Graystone Industries can get those cylons stationed nearby so that if some does get wind of a plot, at least they'll be ready to roll.

    Face it people, last week's science fiction dystopia looks more and more like this weeks's news.

    Paul-Amash 2016!

  • Agile Cyborg||

    I'll never attend such an event but if subservient sport fans willfully subjugate themselves to invasive state gropings and restrictions then more power to the dumbbells.

    If people en masse just said, "Fuck it, you can keep your lousy tickets" the system of command and control at these types of events would lessen considerably. That being said and knowing a few diehard sport fans I'm pretty certain no level of draconian security will stem the bleating and herding instinct of people obsessed with attending team events.

  • GroundTruth||

    I had the same hope about air travel, but see that the sheeple just got right in line for their tail-docking.

  • pob||

    up to I saw the check of $9317, I be certain that my mom in-law was actually erning money parttime from there labtop.. there neighbor had bean doing this for under and as of now repaid the dept on there place and purchased Ford Mustang. view website W­ o­ r­ k­ s­ 7­ 7­ .­ C­ O­ M­

  • pob||

    Piper. I see what you mean... Steven`s rep0rt is impressive... last thursday I got Ford Mustang after having made $9565 this - 5 weeks past and just over 10 grand lass-month. with-out any question its my favourite-work Ive had. I started this three months/ago and pretty much immediately was bringing home at least $80.. per hour. use this link W­ o­ r­ k­ s­ 7­ 7­ .­ C­ O­ M­

  • JD3||

    Who the hell is Piper?
    Ain't no friggin' Piper on these message boards.
    You must be lost son. Where's your mom?
    Does she also work at the Spammer Factory with you?

  • dozzy||

    Well, on the bright side at least we have more to joke about than "turn your head and cough" now.

  • pob||

    my stepmom just got a fantastic cream Mercedes CLS-Class CLS63 AMG only from working parttime off a home pc... browse around this website ➤➤➤➤➤➤ www.works77.ℂℴ¬m

  • julia14juli||

    my best friend's sister-in-law makes $70 /hour on the computer . She has been without work for 7 months but last month her check was $12532 just working on the computer for a few hours. you can look here

    =========================
    http://www.tec30.com
    =========================

  • Satyrical||

    So all of this, just because 3 people died last year? Imagine if they put this many regulations on the police every time THEY killed 3 innocent people.

  • Mr.Krinkle||

    I went to the celebration for the FSU Seminoles yesterday. I guess about 30-35,000 people, the Marching Chiefs, local celebrities, Heisman winner, BCS National Championship trophy, Jimbo, etc.
    It was a fairly large event.
    The four of us walked up, said hello at the 'check point' (which was a couple of women telling us we could not take beverages in), and we went on in.
    No metal detectors. No pat downs. No body scans. No dogs. I mean, there were State Troopers, campus police, and deputies there, but they just kept to themselves. Anyway, despite the (relatively) lax security, no one was hurt, no one died, everything was all right.
    Funny how that is.

  • Mr.Krinkle||

    Can you imagine the NFL letting 35,000 fans onto the field with the Super Bowl champs?
    Yesterday they were letting people take photos with the Coaches' Trophy and the Heisman! lol...it was nice to see what happens when you have reasonable expectations of the public...they'll often surprise you if you give them the chance.

    This is a video of thousands of people on Bobby Bowden Field with the team.
    http://youtu.be/oyvk3TmPc1g?t=2m12s

  • wwhorton||

    Fans will enter heated welcome pavilions at MetLife Stadium, where they can expect to encounter walk-through metal detectors, X-ray machines, K-9 dogs and pat-down searches. They are encouraged to arrive early to avoid delays and to speed up stadium entrance.

    I love this newspeak. Maybe we can start calling TSA checkpoints "Freedom Parades".

  • steve baker||

    I'll bet the terrorists are glad they didn't waste any effort ruining THAT Super Bowl!

GET REASON MAGAZINE

Get Reason's print or digital edition before it’s posted online

  • Video Game Nation: How gaming is making America freer – and more fun.
  • Matt Welch: How the left turned against free speech.
  • Nothing Left to Cut? Congress can’t live within their means.
  • And much more.

SUBSCRIBE

advertisement