Scott Walker Turns Up the Heat on Flawed Milwaukee Crime Stats

Wisconsin gubernatorial candidates debate high-profile police controversy.

Milwaukee, Wis.— The combatants in Wisconsin's historic gubernatorial recall election brought the heat on the campaign trail Thursday, after a newspaper story about the Milwaukee Police Department improperly identifying hundreds of violent crimes.

Gov. Scott Walker’s campaign shifted the spotlight on Milwaukee Mayor Tom Barrett after a Milwaukee Journal Sentinel investigation found that, since 2009, the police department misreported more than 500 incidents to the FBI as lesser offenses.

The city had reported a decline in violent crime last year, and Barrett has trumpeted the lower numbers on the campaign trail.

The Journal Sentinel found enough misreported cases in 2011 alone that violent crime would have increased 1.1 percent instead of falling 2.3 percent from the reported 2010 figures, which had their own errors,” the newspaper wrote.

Walker’s campaign pounced Wednesday, accusing Barrett of cooking the books on crime statistics.

On Thursday morning, the governor joined a chorus of city and state officials calling for an independent audit of the crime statistics.

Walker said the matter boils down to trust, not just in Milwaukee but in the state recall election.

“As a candidate, I think it’s important for the mayor of Milwaukee to acknowledge that on the one item he highlights as an example of leadership—the claim that violent crime has gone down in the city of Milwaukee—the facts now in this report show that’s not accurate,” the governor said during a news conference at the office of the Milwaukee Police Association. The union, which represents 1,700 law enforcement employees, has endorsed the governor in the June 5 election.

Barrett was on the defense at a news conference Thursday morning in Milwaukee, asserting there was no ill intent in data.

“Of course if the numbers are wrong we will correct them. I think that goes without saying," Barrett said Thursday. "My concern really goes more to that the attacks on what is essentially the rank-and-file members of the Milwaukee Police Department.”

“You’ve got a governor of the state coming in to attack the Milwaukee Police Department,” Barrett added. “If he attacks the integrity of the Milwaukee Police Department, if he attacks the integrity of the beat cops or the supervisors or the chiefs, I will call him on that."

Walker, standing before law enforcement officials, countered that the question was not about policing but rather about Barrett taking political credit for numbers that appear to be wrong. 

“That’s important information for not only people across the state to know, but particularly for the citizens here in the city of Milwaukee," Walker said. “We should be able to question whether that’s an example of failed leadership in the city of Milwaukee.”

Michael Crivello, president of the Milwaukee Police Association, said he took no offense by the governor's comments, and that he did not perceive Walker's criticisms as an attack on front-line officers.

"I see it as an affront to police officers by the mayor even bringing that up," he said. "Why the mayor would even suggest that is insulting."

Crivello said he has asked police and city leadership for the better part of two years to check the numbers. He said said he has suspected the data hasn't represented the real crime picture in the city, and that becomes a safety issue for the community and police.

"Nothing was taken seriously," he said. That is until the newspaper's crime report came this week.

This article originally appeared on

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  • Being Waterboarded||

    OK. So, being from MI, I know that people from WI are mostly retarded. However, is this fact enough to explain why people in a mostly rural, low-crime state would vote for a candidate whose biggest campaign claim is that they reduce crime? Or is the good Mayor misreading his constituency?

  • Almanian's Evil Twin||

    So, being from MI, I know that people from WI are mostly retarded.


    /fellow Michiganderanian

  • WWJGD||

    With the MPA siding with Walker, how did Barrett expect this to play out?

    Also, Life Imitating The Wire

  • BMFPitt||

    The Wire didn't just come up with that stuff out of thin air, this shit has been going on for a while.

    "Sorry, miss, you weren't raped because we need to get our numbers down. Move along now."

    We really need to start making that type of corruption a capital crime.

  • Almanian's Evil Twin||

    Politicians gaming stats to further their own interests?

    Sure, like THAT could ever happen! LOL!

  • ||

    Just another case of The Emperor/ Mayor Has No Clothes. 1. Barrett puts out a lie to promote his administration (translation: Get votes while deceiving the citizen). 2. Barrett is caught in lie and that is reported in newspaper (No problem for Barrett: Blame someone else… not for anything to do with the issue… for telling the truth). 3. Barrett is an idiot (Barrett version of racist card: says the governor is attacking the police officers… while they in turn support the governor and the governor makes his comments about Barrett's lying in the presence of a police gathering. Ignore the obvious falsity of my charge… just believe what I say… because I said it). 4. Wisconsin citizens have a choice (pretend, with the Milwaukee Mayor, that he is fully clothed with his typical Democrat lies… or thank the Governor for his exposure of the nakedness of this and all other Barrett and recall supporter lies by ending this recall nonsense and keeping him on the job in Madison).

  • sweeterjan||

    Barrett was on the defense at a news Thursday morning in Milwaukee, asserting there was no ill intent in data

  • cheap sunglasses||

  • joy||

    Of course if the numbers are wrong we will correct them. I think that goes without saying," Barrett said Thursday. "My concern really goes more to that the attacks on what is essentially the rank-and-file members of the Milwaukee Police Department.”

  • amy56||

    1s Nike pression de l'air ont tendance à obtenir baskets ayant une grande variation qui sont faites à la finale et vous fournir une assistance décontractée avec rembourrage vers surprise. Nike a conduit à quel point en ce qui concerne à fournir d'excellents baskets pour le joueur, et maintenant aussi à cela, comprend une suite bien des gens qui veulent que des chaussures pour Nike informelle de même. Vieux et jeunes choisiront des chaussures de tennis Nike non seulement pour leur excellent très bien, mais en outre, pour une image statut de sportifs les espadrilles supérieures available.

  • kram123||

    Perhaps there are more cities that "enhance" or "stroke" crime stats. I believe Memphis,TN could use some scrutiny.

  • joy||

    Barrett was on the defense at a news conference Thursday morning in Milwaukee, there was no ill intent in data.

  • amy567||

    Or Else relating to needing their purchasers relating to specific capabilities as a result of their sneakers, they nowadays fabricate gals sneakers measurement 12 to increase the variety of their market also to facilitate the particular annoyance that in abundance women of all ages with large shoe dimensions observe after they do getting.Abnormal Contrives For Superb Shoe SizeIt is grievous should you realise exquisitely-designed sneakers in stores along with gown stores nevertheless they dont hold the dimensions within your circumstance. Nevertheless the completely wrong encountering could be reworked into any thoughtful exhilaration too as pleasure after you degree off which the go shopping you viewed gets the dimensions you would like.

  • amy56||

    Auparavant, les bikinis brésiliens ont été perçues comme habituellement le morceau d'un seul ou une paire de maillots de bain à la pièce. Pour le plus, vous avez accès à une poignée de couleurs dans les dessins ou modèles identiques réguliers. Mais maintenant, avec la tendance de modifier, vous pouvez être séduit avec le bikini supérieure large et attrayant d'utiliser tout autour de là-bas mis. Les femmes sont l'obtention de moyens formidables pour exhiber leurs bods soleil bronzage sur la plage. Les plus chauds comme les bikinis, le bikini string peu est fantastique pour un idéal filles figuraient.

  • allen567||

    The old adage that your Nike Free Running Men footwear requires; does not hold fact. The footwear should really fit appropriate along with comfortably from the starting point. If you are uncomfortable maybe foot slides all around within the shoe, you almost certainly have the wrong size or style.In search of.


Get Reason's print or digital edition before it’s posted online

  • Progressive Puritans: From e-cigs to sex classifieds, the once transgressive left wants to criminalize fun.
  • Port Authoritarians: Chris Christie’s Bridgegate scandal
  • The Menace of Secret Government: Obama’s proposed intelligence reforms don’t safeguard civil liberties