Fools for Communism

Still apologists after all these years

Glenn Garvin from the April 2004 issue

(Page 4 of 4)

Eric Foner
DeWitt Clinton Professor of History
Columbia University
New York, NY

Glenn Garvin writes, "During World War II, when the Soviet Union and the United States were allied against Hitler, [Christopher] Trumbo's Communist father, Dalton, also named names, secretly pointing the FBI to Hollywood figures he believed were suspiciously anti-war. But there was no suggestion during the [2003] press conference [about Hollywood and the blacklist] that his screenwriting Oscar be revoked."

The assertion that Trumbo pointed "the FBI to Hollywood figures he believed were suspiciously anti-war" is a product of Garvin's fecund imagination. There is no evidence to support it. The only reference to Trumbo's speaking to the FBI that I know of can be found in his published letters, Additional Dialogue: Letters of Dalton Trumbo, 1942-61 (M. Evans & Co.). Anybody sufficiently interested in Garvin's garbled thesis can find enlightenment on page 26 of that volume.

Finally, at the press conference Garvin attended, there was no suggestion that anybody's Oscar "be revoked." Revoking Oscars originates with Garvin. And by the way, Dalton Trumbo was given two of them�for motion pictures he wrote using a pseudonym during the time he was blacklisted and unable to find work using his own name.

Christopher Trumbo
Beverly Hills, CA

Glenn Garvin replies: If anything, both the book In Denial and my review soft-pedal the�tone of Foner's essay, which appeared in the December 1990 issue of Harper's. The air of bitter disappointment was palpable as Foner described young Russians who admire Abraham Lincoln but "paint the history of the Soviet era in the blackest hues, reclassifying every top leader between Lenin and Gorbachev as either criminal or incompetent." Worse yet, he wrote, the Russians were turning away from distinctions between bourgeois and socialist ideologies in favor of something he referred to, contempt practically dripping from the quotation marks, as "universal human values." Foner sounded like nothing so much as a jilted paramour as he complained of "this love affair with America."

As for Christopher Trumbo, I am astonished to find myself in agreement with him: Everybody, including his father's leftist admirers, should read Dalton Trumbo's 1944 letter to the FBI reprinted in Additional Dialogue. In it, he boasts of having provided the FBI with letters from writers who are "1) anti-war, 2) anti-Semitic, 3) in the process of organizing politically, 4) distributing pamphlets to further their cause and corresponding with persons detained by the Federal government, and 5) of the opinion that the Commander in Chief of American forces is 'the greatest criminal incendiary in history.'" He adds, "I share with the men of your organization a sincere desire to see an end to all such seditious propaganda as criminal slander of the Commander in Chief, defeatism, pacifism, anti-Semitism and all similar deceits and stratagems designed to assist the German cause." He closes by noting that he's including more letters and begging the FBI not to tip off the writers about what he has done, presumably so he can keep ratting on them.

I will concede Christopher Trumbo one technical point. Although he continues to object to the decision to give Elia Kazan a lifetime achievement Oscar, he did not use the word revoke. The importance of the distinction eludes me, but I am inclined to be charitable to a man whose father was not only one of Stalin's loudest apologists but also one of J. Edgar Hoover's pet rats. Talk about a childhood of mixed signals.

Page: ‹ First < 2 34

Reason needs your support. Please donate today!

Try Reason's award-winning print edition today! Your first issue is FREE if you are not completely satisfied.

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment or disable your ability to comment for any reason at any time.

Pingback| 10.23.09 @ 6:45PM

Instapundit » Blog Archive » MICHAEL MOYNIHAN: The Cold War Never Ended: Twenty years links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…;A well-known Democratic … October 23, 2009 MICHAEL MOYNIHAN: The Cold War Never Ended: Twenty years later, historians still can’t figure out why the West won. But some people are still making excuses for the losers. Posted at by Glenn Reynolds at 6:44 pm if (WIDGETBOX) WIDGETBOX.renderWidget('c6738f00-977c-48fd-98da-0afe24da2ee8'); Get the Pajamas TV - V2.0 widget and many other great free widgets at…

Pingback| 10.23.09 @ 7:49PM

Unless . . . « Oh, My! links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

Unless . . . « Oh, My! /* */ /* */ Oh, My! Hit Shappenings – Personal Rants « Now, Dude . . . Unless . . . By jbiii You are brain dead . . . The Soviet Union never disappeared. Just took a few years for re-organization, that is all. If you think not, go here–CBS, screaming libs, no less. Plain and simple. Bamm-Bamm is an amateur in the kiddie pool, and he…

|10.23.09 @ 8:32PM|#

"and a mere 2.5 million arrests"

I think the low ball number of arrests and the large difference in demographic data (millions more missing) has something to do with you and your family tending to be fired and loose your place to live and ration cards. One arrest can then lead to several deaths / the whole family...

saxon|10.23.09 @ 11:16PM|#

Why would they admit that communism was wrong; the SOBs are trying it again in the West. The red 'intellectuals' have morphed into 'greens' and 'progressives'.

Why go back that far to learn lessons from history; they are talking of Stimulus II and Community Reinvestment Act v2 ... and Barney Frank wants to lend more money to poor people ... it 'd be hilarious, if not actually sad

Andy Jones|10.24.09 @ 12:13AM|#

Communism lost?

Better go ask the ex - CEO of GM about that. Or the (mostly former now, strangely enough) executives that have had their contracts waived with a wave of the Leader's hand.

Somewhere down in Florida, three old guys sitting in a bar by the beach are talking about the old days before the fall of the Soviet Union marooned them in their KGB sleeper identities.

Barak Obama is speaking on the cabana bar TV, talking about why Utah can't drill for oil, or why secret ballots aren't fair for unions, or why America must accept the goals of Islamic terror as legitimate grievances.

They shake their heads.

"It took a while, but we WON!"

fin.

Pingback| 10.24.09 @ 10:12AM

Communism and its Apologists @ Helian Unbound links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…sages concerning the supposed “stability” of Communist regimes in the years immediately prior to the time that most of them collapsed, and their continuing attempts to revise history so as to present Stalin at his most charming. We at least have the consolation of knowing that the remaining representatives of the “New Left” of the 60’s who are still busily decorating…

|10.24.09 @ 10:29AM|#

What the sympathizers and apologists for communism cannot get over is that their analysis of the USSR was dead wrong while that of the Reader's Digest, with its focus on ordinary people and stories of escape from the slavery and oppression of communism, was correct. Being well-degreed does not equal being smart and insightful.

|10.24.09 @ 12:51PM|#

Back during the Cold War I developed the "Nazi" test. I would take a statement by a leftist and substitute Nazi for Communist and Jew for Capitalist and then ask whether he agreed or disagreed with the statement.

If you apply it to the revision on the Great Terror you get Holocaust denial. Perhaps that explains the rise of anti-Antisemitism among Progressives.

Pingback| 10.25.09 @ 3:53PM

Fools for Communism links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

Fools for Communism Headspace and Timing v2.0 Don't Tread On Me! // Fools for Communism by HSAT 25. October 2009 15:51 Still apologists after all these years Glenn Garvin from the April 2004 issue In Denial: Historians, Communism and Espionage , by John Earl Haynes and Harvey Klehr, San Francisco: Encounter Books, 300 pages, $25.95 In 1983 the…

Trackback| 11.17.09 @ 3:06AM

san diego yoga classes, on san diego yoga classes, links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

If you are pregnant, your body undergoes changes each day. While a pose may feel wonderful today, it may not feel too good some other day. The most important thing to keep in mind while exercising is the principle common to all forms of yoga, which is non- violence to yourself. It involves allowing and accepting limitations in your body caused by pregnancy and selectively doing poses which make you feel comfortable. This is because the growing baby often changes positions, causing a certain…

Pingback| 12.20.09 @ 4:17AM

0bamacare, political prostitution, and belated buyer’s remorse « Spin, strangeness, a links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:

…of the Soviet Union, archives were opened, and his already high estimated death tolls were revealed to be too low, if anything. When the publisher asked him for a subtitle for a new edition of his book, he reportedly proposed: "I told you so, you f*cking fools!"] A Hebrew proverb says that a smart man will get out of messes that a wise man would never have gotten into in the first place. Here’s hoping that some of…

nfl jerseys|11.8.10 @ 3:50AM|#

jht

WOMENUGGS|11.24.10 @ 2:18AM|#

dry shoes to really feel quite abundant much added acceptable, is not the only one that uses water-absorbing cardboard abominable, but absorb the matrix Uggs Australia Outlet ? Cardy boots for sale. anon after Ugg Boots On Sale boot phonetic implementation of the

WOMENUGGS|11.24.10 @ 2:21AM|#

anytime you are analytic for Women Uggs that are actually both contemporary and comfortable, you can go to Ugg Sheepskin Boots reality in which all kinds of Ugg auction shown

WOMENUGGS|11.24.10 @ 2:25AM|#

And Cheap Womens Uggs Classic Shortening occurs adapted equipment - polar expensive. In an arctic climate, the expensive blood provides a range of care amore accoutrement the warmth of his absolute readiness capable, sharp as reducing goose court. However,Sheepskin Boots Sale central heating summer, use the fibers of all amoebic really alarming bleeding exact anxiety that absorbs the perspiration away

Reason.com