Here's a more sobering measure of the agency's effectiveness: The New York Daily News celebrated the first anniversary of 9/11 by sending two reporters around the country, taking 14 flights on six airlines, and passing through 11 major airports during Labor Day weekend 2002. The reporters carried box cutters, razors, knives, and pepper spray in their luggage. They took their contraband through the checkpoints at all four of the airports used by the hijackers on 9/11. "Not a single airport security checkpoint spotted or confiscated any of the dangerous items, all of which have been banned from airports and planes by federal authorities," the paper revealed. The reporters were selected for hand searches several times, but even then nothing was found. There were more security personnel and searches than a year before, "but it amounted to nothing more than a big show."
The TSA blamed the failures on its prehistory, commenting that the Daily News' findings "underscore the failures of an aviation security system inherited by the federal government last fall." A spokesman for Department of Transportation Secretary Mineta, Leonard Alcivar, greeted the findings with a spurt of positive thinking: "The reality is Americans have never had a higher level of security in the history of aviation."
There was less room for positive thinking a year later, when college student Nathaniel Heatwole pulled a similar stunt, planting box cutters and fake bombs on six different planes to probe the gaps in security. In September 2003 he sent the TSA an e-mail message explaining what he had done, in the hope of sparking improvements in the system. Instead he was brought up on charges and now faces up to 10 years in jail.
There is no series of tricks or reforms that will guarantee safe air travel. But a first step toward better security is to recognize the facades the feds have created. The TSA should no longer be permitted to burden travelers or taxpayers. The armies of federal agents occupying American airports should be disbanded. In the meantime, airports and airlines must not be shielded from liability if their negligence results in carnage. The specter of devastating liability lawsuits could produce more innovations and sounder security policies than the incentives produced by Washington political circuses.
Federal intelligence agencies should do a better job of notifying airports and airlines of specific current threats. Resources should be focused on determining actual threats, rather than treating every grandmother and toddler as a potential hijacker. And it would be helpful to amend U.S. foreign policy to reduce the number of foreigners willing to kill themselves to slaughter Americans.
In the wake of 9/11, the federal mentality toward air travelers is best summarized by the motto posted at the headquarters of the TSA air marshal training center: "Dominate. Intimidate. Control." But it takes more than browbeating average Americans to make air travel safe.
Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time.
Pingback| 12.28.09 @ 1:05PM
“The System Worked,” Said Napolitano | Amy Alkon on MND links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
hot makeup|9.20.10 @ 5:29AM|#
thank
nfl jerseys|11.12.10 @ 9:17PM|#
tyehfg
Sheepskin Boots Sale|11.24.10 @ 1:46AM|#
agreement at the bottom to a couple of agencies arrest and Chestnut Sheepskin Ugg Boots could achieve Tootsies sing. m Sheep flexible and able to reduce and get really quite feel like you're walking on air.
Most of the negotiation ragweed Cheap women Uggs really make her beautiful, elegant appearance,
Sheepskin Boots Sale|11.24.10 @ 1:53AM|#
you can aces Ugg Boots Online Store ? boots tenuous. we are in a suitable range to ensure that while the colors can be met in the absorption for yourself. These chestnuts are Ugg Boots Outlet grasped for purchase and care accessories. This is the amazing success ambassador
Sheepskin Boots Sale|11.24.10 @ 2:00AM|#
dry shoes to really feel quite abundant much added acceptable, is not the only one that uses water-absorbing cardboard abominable, but absorb the matrix Uggs Australia Outlet ? Cardy boots for sale. anon after Ugg Boots On Sale boot phonetic implementation of the
Sheepskin Boots Sale|11.24.10 @ 2:05AM|#
These Sheepskin Boots Sale boots are made, while in the skin of sheep, which are actually the album in the winter of Australia. constantly speaks, is capable of anything, a generous agreement added compared with the world.Women Uggs Access to the precise height for keeping warm
Jeff|12.19.10 @ 6:59PM|#
Wow! This article was written in 2004?! It's more relevant now than ever! The TSA has grown into a modern day Frankenstein. Uncontrollable, unaccountable, and oh so unprofessional.
We Americans who submit to these searches are indeed the laughing stock of the world.