Under a universal "all payer" health-insurance policy, the Medicare price-fixing policy would be applied to the entire health-care system. The fears the AMA expressed at the time of Medicare’s enactment 25 years ago that it would lead to socialized medicine seem fated to be realized.
As the nation barrels toward some kind of universal healthcare policy, there is an ominous political parallel shaping up between 1965 and 1993. What finally tipped the balance in favor of Medicare in 1965 was the huge turnover in Congress. The next Congress will have more than 100 new House members. Despite some losses, the Democrats will have a solid majority, and even some Republican congressional candidates adopted as boilerplate the slogan that the federal government must take a role in providing some kind of universal health coverage. Bill Clinton has vowed to make health care a top priority, and Congress isn’t likely to hesitate much over the legacy of Medicare.
In light of the alarming actuarial projections for Medicare’s hospital-insurance program, it is no wonder that politicians are loathe to propose a national health plan that explicitly includes a new payroll tax. But the halfway house of "play or pay" that Democrats are advocating will quickly fall into the same trap as Medicare.
First, Medicare is simply one example of the fact that, as an HCFA official put it, the federal government "continually underestimates the cost of social insurance programs." This problem would be compounded under a "play or pay" scheme because the alternative payroll tax would initially be set low to entice participation.
As a consequence, the government would end up with a disproportionate share of high-cost enrollees (similar to what has happened with the state-run "assigned risk" pools for auto insurance) because companies with high health-insurance costs would find it to their cost advantage to dump the burden onto the government program. Thus, the "pay" portion of the government program would certainly be underfunded. ‘It is guaranteed to increase the federal deficit," says a source at the HCFA. "It is impossible to set a payroll tax that will cover the cost."
A recent study by the Urban Institute found that if the payroll-tax rate of a "play or pay" policy were set at 7 percent, 112 million nonelderly people, or 52 percent of the insured population, would be covered through the "pay" option. This number includes 59 percent of all private-sector workers. If the rate is 9 percent, an estimated 84.8 million would still be enrolled in the public plan, or 39 percent of the nonelderly insured population. These numbers suggest it will be a massive, and massively underfunded, program.
Providing significant funding through cost containment is equally chimerical, unless the government is prepared to administer an onerous "all-payer" regime of price controls on the entire health-care system, and then employ a rigorous scheme of rationing on top of that. Although a few liberals speak openly of price controls and ‘all-payer" regulations, they are loathe to entertain the necessity of rationing because of the inequities it would generate.
There is one decided difference between the politics of Medicare in 1965 and today. In 1965, all the opponents of Medicare had to offer was a watered down version of that program, Medicare on the cheap. Today, opponents of increased federal involvement in health care have a true market-based alternative to offer. The combination of "Medi-save accounts," in which people would be encouraged to save their own money for health insurance and direct payment of medical expenses, and tax credits to enable low-income families to purchase health insurance, offer a viable alternative to centralized big-government health insurance portion of Medicare
Although this isn’t the magic answer to soaring health-care costs, it is a policy that rests on the one proven strategy for holding costs down: making the individual responsible for first-dollar costs of health care. If the critics can portray the issue as big government versus individual empowerment, there just might be a chance for positive reform of the health-care mess.
Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time.
Pingback| 11.18.09 @ 4:58PM
Would You Buy Insurance From This Man? « Left Coast Ledger links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 12.15.09 @ 10:42PM
The Medicare Monster: A cautionary tale revisited. « The Western Experience links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 1.6.10 @ 11:21AM
TAKEbackMEDICINE.org » Blog Archive » Look What Massachusetts Has To Say About HCR!! links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 1.6.10 @ 11:27AM
Mayo clinic decided to stop accepting Medicare « Harmony Health and Wellness links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 1.6.10 @ 2:22PM
Obama Says "Look at the Mayo Clinic" - Political Forum links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 1.7.10 @ 9:04PM
Photomaniacal » Blog Archive » Medicare and the Mayo Clinic links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 1.8.10 @ 4:17AM
Real Change- Rebuild American Manufacturing « Speaking of Precision Blog links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 2.9.10 @ 2:28PM
Yes, Mr. President, there are other health care plans…if you REALLY want to listen links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 2.25.10 @ 2:47PM
Medicare working so great, doctors are threatening to drop more patients - Politics a links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 2.25.10 @ 2:48PM
Medicare working so great, doctors are threatening to drop more patients - Politics a links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 2.25.10 @ 5:27PM
Medicare working so great, doctors are threatening to drop more patients - Politics a links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.2.10 @ 3:22PM
» New Government Programs Always Cost More Than Predicted - Big Government links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.20.10 @ 1:04AM
Did this guy actually read it? - Page 3 links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.21.10 @ 11:33PM
OpinionEditorial — Blog — Beware the Fury of a Patient Man links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.22.10 @ 3:18PM
What’s Really Bad About the Bill « the Global Observatory links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.23.10 @ 8:50PM
Health Care Passed, A serious question about the past. links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.24.10 @ 7:51AM
William M. Briggs, Statistician » Democrat’s Appalling Budget Wishcast links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.26.10 @ 3:40PM
The True Prescription for Medical-Care Reform Is A Freed Market « The Freeman Chronic links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.29.10 @ 1:16AM
Political News Highlights and Controversy» Did The CBO Report Double Count Medicare D links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.29.10 @ 1:16AM
Political News Highlights and Controversy» Did The CBO Report Double Count Medicare D links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.29.10 @ 1:16AM
Political News Highlights and Controversy» Did The CBO Report Double Count Medicare D links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.29.10 @ 1:16AM
Political News Highlights and Controversy» Did The CBO Report Double Count Medicare D links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.29.10 @ 1:16AM
Political News Highlights and Controversy» Did The CBO Report Double Count Medicare D links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.29.10 @ 1:16AM
Political News Highlights and Controversy» Did The CBO Report Double Count Medicare D links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.29.10 @ 1:16AM
Political News Highlights and Controversy» Did The CBO Report Double Count Medicare D links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.29.10 @ 1:16AM
Political News Highlights and Controversy» Did The CBO Report Double Count Medicare D links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.29.10 @ 1:16AM
Political News Highlights and Controversy» Did The CBO Report Double Count Medicare D links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.29.10 @ 1:16AM
Political News Highlights and Controversy» Did The CBO Report Double Count Medicare D links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.29.10 @ 1:16AM
Political News Highlights and Controversy» Did The CBO Report Double Count Medicare D links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.29.10 @ 1:17AM
Political News Highlights and Controversy» Did The CBO Report Double Count Medicare D links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.29.10 @ 1:17AM
Political News Highlights and Controversy» Did The CBO Report Double Count Medicare D links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.29.10 @ 1:17AM
Political News Highlights and Controversy» Did The CBO Report Double Count Medicare D links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.29.10 @ 1:17AM
Political News Highlights and Controversy» Did The CBO Report Double Count Medicare D links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.29.10 @ 1:17AM
Political News Highlights and Controversy» Did The CBO Report Double Count Medicare D links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.29.10 @ 1:17AM
Political News Highlights and Controversy» Did The CBO Report Double Count Medicare D links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.29.10 @ 1:17AM
Political News Highlights and Controversy» Did The CBO Report Double Count Medicare D links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.29.10 @ 1:17AM
Political News Highlights and Controversy» Did The CBO Report Double Count Medicare D links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.29.10 @ 1:17AM
Political News Highlights and Controversy» Did The CBO Report Double Count Medicare D links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.29.10 @ 8:40AM
If You Can Find A Path With No Obstacles It Probably Doesn’t Lead Anywhere « Finding links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 3.31.10 @ 10:18AM
The Glenn Beck Boycott Gaining Traction - FOX News Losing Money - Page 60 links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 4.4.10 @ 12:39AM
Farmer Barrack And His Crop Of “Cabbage” « RoadSideSatire.com links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 4.6.10 @ 12:52AM
U.S. Supreme Court to strike down Obamacare - Page 5 - US Message Board - Political links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 4.24.10 @ 12:25PM
Another Obama lie. New Report. Obamcare will raise - Page 2 - US Message Board - Pol links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
Pingback| 4.28.10 @ 9:07AM
State Policy Blog » Blog Archive » Breaking Down Obama’s Debt Commission links to this page. Here’s an excerpt:
nfl jerseys|11.26.10 @ 8:22PM|#
jsxth